Re:No Copyright for Pornography: A Response to File-Sharing ...
by pvg on Saturday December 17, 2016 @06:52AM
(#13200343)
Well, I'm no lawyer let alone a constitutional one but the purpose is clearly to enable a particular kind of legislation for a particularly defined purpose. It doesn't say 'every work granted the temporary exclusive rights must promote [...]'.
The phrasing actually grants Congress the power to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts", and restricts the means of doing so to the granting of temporary exclusive rights. This is quite different from something like the Second Amendment, where the explanatory text about "A well regulated Militia" doesn't actually modify the meaning of the clause that has legal effect.