Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads
by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @05:41PM
(#1319443)
Thanks!
I'm very impressed by the technical smarts of the judges in this case, but I do think that a hash on a file (say a 512 bit hash) in combination with the filename would be good enough to warrant automatic removal, I really wonder if this will hold up in the longer term.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads
by ars on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @06:42PM
(#1319668)
A hash would be worthless. Just rar it again with slightly different options and you have a different hash.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads
by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @07:17PM
(#1319768)
On the rar file yes, but on the file that is packed not. After all the rar compressor is 'lossless'.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads
by IChrisI on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @11:22PM
(#1320244)
Add IllegalFile and RandomData.txt to a password protected rar. The hash is essentially random, you can't check the contents, and the illegal file is easily retrievable if the downloader knows the password.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads
by eru on Friday May 07, 2010 @03:47PM
(#1328519)
Password protection (or other cryptography) aside, you can make `hashes' that are similar for similar files. This way if you only added a short RandomData.txt the hashes wouldn't differ too much.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads
by silvestrov on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:32PM
(#1320038)
Then put the modified rar inside another rar (i.e. nest it). And both rars can be password protected, so RS can't even check the first rar.
to 3b: part of the claim was that "if a file is of the RAR format, that is a clear hint at being a movie file" which the judges identified as false (sometimes they ARE smart).
to 3c: most germans are on dynamic IPs that change all 24h.
everything seems to be intepreted correctly.