News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @04:13PM (#1319157)
That's pretty huge, given that in other European countries linking to copyrighted content has been found to violate the law, rapidshare actually distributes the files themselves.

This is likely not the last shot though, the 'ueberlandesgericht' is not the highest court.

Edit: I've been reading the German response by 'telemedicus' linked in the article, here are the highlights (German native speakers please correct me if I'm wrong, stuff in brackets I've added):

--

1) rapidshare is neither the party that commits the crime nor a participant

2) rapidshare does not make the data publicly available (you need a downloadlink)

3a) checking the filenames is not applicable because you can choose a filename, on the other hand the risk exists that legitimate data would be refused

3b) a datatype can not be blocked because there is no indication a datatype is tied to the legality of the data

3c) a tie with IP addresses is to be declined because IP addresses are regularly used by multiple people

3d) a manual checking of the lists of links can not be required because there is no business relationship between hoster and the people that host lists of links

--

from http://www.telemedicus.info/urteile/Internetrecht/Haftung-vo...

I'm especially amazed at '1', that they're not even seen as an accessory is very interesting as a conclusion.

Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by ugh on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @04:59PM (#1319302)
That’s a accurate translation :)

I would add that 2) also refers to the business model of Rapidshare: uploaded files are by default confidential. Only users make downloadlinks public, not Rapidshare. (Is that true, by the way? Is the only way to search Rapidshare to search for published links somewhere on the internet?) Giving the user the option of publishing the downloadlink cannot be prohibited. (I would guess because such a feature can have legitimate uses.)

Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @05:43PM (#1319447)
> Is that true, by the way? Is the only way to search Rapidshare to search for published links somewhere on the internet?

I think it is, google lists some 15,000 files in the 'files' subdirectory of rapidshare ( http://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Arapidshare.de ), I can't imagine that's all of them.

Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by aw3c2 on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @04:58PM (#1319299)
to 1: Rapidshare is considered a provider/service. They cannot be responsible for things done "through" them. Same like ISPs or E-Mail providers. 3 plays into this. RS could not manually check all files and it obviously is not possible to automate it either.

to 3b: part of the claim was that "if a file is of the RAR format, that is a clear hint at being a movie file" which the judges identified as false (sometimes they ARE smart).

to 3c: most germans are on dynamic IPs that change all 24h.

everything seems to be intepreted correctly.

Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @05:41PM (#1319443)
Thanks!

I'm very impressed by the technical smarts of the judges in this case, but I do think that a hash on a file (say a 512 bit hash) in combination with the filename would be good enough to warrant automatic removal, I really wonder if this will hold up in the longer term.

Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by ars on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @06:42PM (#1319668)
A hash would be worthless. Just rar it again with slightly different options and you have a different hash.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @07:17PM (#1319768)
On the rar file yes, but on the file that is packed not. After all the rar compressor is 'lossless'.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by IChrisI on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @11:22PM (#1320244)
Add IllegalFile and RandomData.txt to a password protected rar. The hash is essentially random, you can't check the contents, and the illegal file is easily retrievable if the downloader knows the password.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by eru on Friday May 07, 2010 @03:47PM (#1328519)
Password protection (or other cryptography) aside, you can make `hashes' that are similar for similar files. This way if you only added a short RandomData.txt the hashes wouldn't differ too much.
Re:Court: RapidShare doesn't need to filter user uploads by silvestrov on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:32PM (#1320038)
Then put the modified rar inside another rar (i.e. nest it). And both rars can be password protected, so RS can't even check the first rar.