I'd say that the only situation where it makes sense to count from 1 is when you are counting objects. Of course, counting objects is so important that it dominates people's perception of numbers and counting.
"pause one, pause two, ..."
So when you get to 10, you have said 10 numbers and there have been ten pauses. The "you are only counting 9 seconds" thing would only make sense if the counting period starts when you say the first number, which is not how I usually do it...
|------------|-------
t0 t1
^ ^
First SecondAnyway, if you do make a conscious pause, I would argue that you are effectively counting from 0 even if you don't pronounce 0 due to the bias against that number caused by counting objects. The first pause needs to start somewhere, the start of that pause is in your mind (even if you don't pronounce it) and it corresponds to 0.
In naive set theory, starting with 1 poses some problems (specifically, you don't have numbers yet, so you start with the notion of the empty set, which you use to define 0, and then proceed from there).
Starting the naturals from 0 is also problematic in group theory, since you lose the additive identity.
But it doesn't really apply in the natural world, where 1 is a much better starting number for probably all contexts where you have to number or reference things in an order.
Maybe this clarification is redundant, I don't know. But when I read the headline, I assumed it was talking about everywhere, which is why I found it interesting and even clicked it in the first place.