News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why numbering should start at zero (1982) by joatmon-snoo on Thursday December 15, 2016 @01:14PM (#13186722)
Dijkstra is arguing in the context of natural numbers, which in the standard naive set-theoretic construction starts with 0.
Re:Why numbering should start at zero (1982) by thanatropism on Thursday December 15, 2016 @01:48PM (#13187032)
I've only seen naturals start with zero in Calculus 101 books. Any "introduction to real analysis for third-year undergrads" will do 1, at least in my experience.
Re:Why numbering should start at zero (1982) by joatmon-snoo on Monday December 19, 2016 @11:56PM (#13217566)
Despite having a math degree, somehow I never took an analysis class, so I can't common on that specifically (I do believe that's one of the places where analysis diverges from other field's conventions; that being said, I do believe it is fairly standard practice to specify whether naturals start from 0 or 1 in a paper).

In naive set theory, starting with 1 poses some problems (specifically, you don't have numbers yet, so you start with the notion of the empty set, which you use to define 0, and then proceed from there).

Starting the naturals from 0 is also problematic in group theory, since you lose the additive identity.