News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kkirsche on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:06PM (#13181408)
I don't have the context here to understand what's going on by I feel bad for the author that their work was plagiarized. With that said, why didn't the author have a signed legal NDA in regards to the document?
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by robotresearcher on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:14PM (#13181451)
Academic reviewers don't sign NDAs. We are working for free, as a community service. There's no way we'd accept legal restrictions on future speech in the process.

Copyright law provides legal remedies for plagiarism.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kkirsche on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:20PM (#13181484)
How is reviewing a research paper a community service? I don't mean that sarcastically but realistically medical journals specifically like in this article are commonly not free, thus I'm hard pressed to understand how this is a community service. An NDA would simply restrict you from discussing it prior to the authors publishing of it as I see it.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by robotresearcher on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:34PM (#13181574)
> How is reviewing a research paper a community service?

Traditionally we are neither offered nor would accept payment for technical paper reviews to avoid any suggestion of bias. Since someone reviews my papers too, I get roughly the same value of work back in-kind.

We are bound by academic integrity to not discuss reviews, unpublished work, or the identity of any reviewer. This is a very strong norm.

On NDAs generally: if your entire job is based saying what you think, you avoid signing anything that restricts your ability to do that.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by privong on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:51PM (#13181668)
> Since someone reviews my papers too, I get roughly the same value of work back in-kind.

I've heard of journals that are loosely codifying this by saying they may refuse submissions from authors who serially refuse to review manuscripts. I don't know how prevalent it is overall, though.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by jonchang on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:28PM (#13181536)
Peer review does not happen in a vacuum. If you do not review my manuscript, who will review your manuscript when you submit it? Scientists are generally encouraged to complete a review for every review they receive. Reviewers are generally not paid.

> medical journals specifically like in this article are commonly not free

Yes, this is one of the biggest issues in scientific publishing today. I don't believe there are any easy solutions, just trade-offs (absent governments nationalizing scientific publishers and returning control to universities)

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by privong on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:29PM (#13181550)
> How is reviewing a research paper a community service? I don't mean that sarcastically but realistically medical journals specifically like in this article are commonly not free, thus I'm hard pressed to understand how this is a community service.

I can't speak to medicine, but in astronomy peer review is done for free. The reviewers receive no benefits or compensation from the journal for their time/effort. I believe it is similar across most scientific disciplines.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by santaclaus on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @10:50PM (#13182235)
> The reviewers receive no benefits or compensation from the journal for their time/effort.

Some of the ACM venues give five dollar coffee mugs to reviewers if they go to the actual conference. I wonder how much of a discount that works out to per hour of review time. :)

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by privong on Thursday December 15, 2016 @09:03AM (#13184586)
> Some of the ACM venues give five dollar coffee mugs to reviewers if they go to the actual conference. I wonder how much of a discount that works out to per hour of review time. :)

It would vary a lot on the size/complexity of the paper, but I typically spend 1–3 days reviewing a paper.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by wbhart on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:31PM (#13181556)
Peer review is done for free by other academics, not by the journal publishers. The fact that the published journal is not free is unrelated to the peer review process, which is entirely academic.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by ctrl-j on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:28PM (#13181537)
> medical journals specifically like in this article are commonly not free

Generally speaking - peer-reviewers are not employees of, nor get compensated by, academic journals.

The journal being free or paid has no bearing on the review process.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by detaro on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:28PM (#13181540)
It's a community service in that you are not paid for it and don't have work contract requiring you to do it. It's something everybody does a bit.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by dbcooper on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:28PM (#13181538)
Researchers provide peer review services to journals free of charge.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by dpark on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:12PM (#13181441)
Do you imagine that someone willing to blatantly steal a research paper and publish it as his own would be deterred by an NDA?

Also an author does not have contact or control over peer reviewers and typically no way to demand an NDA.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kkirsche on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:21PM (#13181489)
Deterred? No. But I do think it would add valuable ammunition for legal repercussions.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by wbhart on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:37PM (#13181585)
It's not at all difficult to prove copyright infringement of a paper submitted for peer review. The editors will have a copy of the paper and its submission will be date stamped in the peer review submission system. That's simply not the issue here. What happened is the reviewer submitted substantially the same manuscript to another journal, hoping no one would notice. The difficulty isn't in remedying or proving copyright infringement, but noticing it!
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by robotresearcher on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:41PM (#13181611)
The publisher has already sent the original author a formal receipt for the manuscript, and a keeps a dated copy of the letter to the plagiarist asking for a review.

This has been standard practice for a couple of hundred years, and is well understood legally.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by jonchang on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:17PM (#13181465)
During the scientific peer review process reviewers are generally agree to keep the process confidential and are usually bound by codes of professional ethics, e.g., http://publicationethics.org/files/Peer%20review%20guideline...
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kkirsche on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:21PM (#13181492)
I wasn't aware of that. Thanks for sharing. I'll have to look into it more
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by lucasmullens on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:14PM (#13181447)
Isn't stealing it like this illegal anyway, without an NDA?
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kkirsche on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:18PM (#13181473)
Do you have sufficient proof to show in court that you developed it and wrote it prior? I view an NDA as one more layer of proof that it's yours in that battle
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by jonchang on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:22PM (#13181496)
I do not think you know how the scientific peer review process works. The manuscript will generally get sent to the editor of the journal through their submission system, with the corresponding electronic trail. Most manuscripts are also written with coauthors who can attest to their own personal contribution.

Recommend you read this for a primer on how peer review works: http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/howscienceworks_16

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kkirsche on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:26PM (#13181528)
While I admit I don't I can't say that trust in a system that leverages trust in peers is a valid excuse for being passive bystanders when more concrete actions should be taken to prevent further damages.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by wbhart on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:43PM (#13181620)
There's about a thousand different ways the authors could prove they did the work. Many are listed in the actual post. Unless you did all the work yourself, didn't apply for a grant for it, kept all your work quiet from your colleagues and institution, didn't hire anyone for the project, didn't request materials from your institution, didn't have coauthors, sent it to an editor with a bad memory, didn't use the proper submission system, didn't back the files up and lost your computer, didn't send preprints to any of your friends or colleagues, and the editor reviewed it themselves without sending it to anyone else, you aren't going to have the slightest difficulty proving it is your own work. On the flip side, the plagiarist isn't going to be able to do any of that.