News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by robotresearcher on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:34PM (#13181574)
> How is reviewing a research paper a community service?

Traditionally we are neither offered nor would accept payment for technical paper reviews to avoid any suggestion of bias. Since someone reviews my papers too, I get roughly the same value of work back in-kind.

We are bound by academic integrity to not discuss reviews, unpublished work, or the identity of any reviewer. This is a very strong norm.

On NDAs generally: if your entire job is based saying what you think, you avoid signing anything that restricts your ability to do that.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by privong on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @08:51PM (#13181668)
> Since someone reviews my papers too, I get roughly the same value of work back in-kind.

I've heard of journals that are loosely codifying this by saying they may refuse submissions from authors who serially refuse to review manuscripts. I don't know how prevalent it is overall, though.