Re:Elementary proof that e is irrational
by Certhas on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:26PM
(#13169908)
Anecdote has it that a professor at my alma mater was presenting a proof to students, stating that X was obvious, before halting and wondering aloud: "Is this really obvious?" He examined the blackboard and started pacing for a good 15 minutes mumbling and thinking, before exclaiming with a triumphant expression on his face: "Indeed it IS obvious!"
That said, obviously no proof can function without assuming some mathematical background knowledge. This is a paper from a research journal, not a textbook and the readership of the journal where it was published would presumably find this clear.
Re:Elementary proof that e is irrational
by stablemap on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:25PM
(#13170609)
The site doesn't seem to mention it but the article is from the Monthly [1], which has a focus on exposition. Still, assuming some analysis seems fair.
That said, obviously no proof can function without assuming some mathematical background knowledge. This is a paper from a research journal, not a textbook and the readership of the journal where it was published would presumably find this clear.