In a test like this, it's anything but fair to use the first, simplest h.264 encoder at hand, with the weakest settings possible, and then claim that "this is what h.264 looks like", when the most substantial component in video quality is not the data format itself, but the frame analyzer software and the stream programmer (read: the encoder itself). I've dealt in video ripping and encoding since the late 90s, having experience in pretty much every mpeg-1, mpeg-2, mpeg-4 asp and mpeg-4/avc encoder available, and Theora JUST DOES NOT COME CLOSE to what x264 can create for the h.264 format. In fact, it barely beats what Xvid can produce for the older mpeg-4 asp format.
So far I have not come across a single, proper, honorable comparison of h.264's capabilites compared to Theora. One of these damned days I hope I myself will be bothered enough to get my thumbs out of my ass and put the definite facts out there for people to see.
add.: if anyone wonders, i have ripped and encoded video (and audio) for illegal distribution in the so-called "audio/video scene" for almost 13 years now
People seem to get really annoyed that Xiph aren't making whatever argument they wanted made, c'est la vie.
I find it weird to use a GPL encoder that's had a lot of optimisation work done on it, to undermine an open format where the encoder hasn't had a lot of work done on it. If the format is the key rather than the implementation, then why are so many of them mediocre?
If you would make your own fair comparison (article/site), it would be much appreciated.
There are http://people.xiph.org/~maikmerten/youtube/ and http://people.xiph.org/~greg/video/ytcompare/comparison.html , did you see them?
edit: Above is evil. Very evil. Or stupid. I encoded the audio from the MP4 to Vorbis to a size of ~800 Kilobytes and it sounds good. Also the Theora video is so bad and damaged, it does not remotely look like a normal encode. I would like to know what went wrong there. Anyways, disgard parent post and the links inside. It's nothing but FUD in my eyes (and ears).
edit2: I also get far better visuals than in the linked Theora by even transcoding linked H264 with "-K 170 -V 465" in ffmpeg2theora...