News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by mixedCase on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @09:57AM (#13114989)
Dark Mail seems to be dead. Are there any efforts to make e-mail secure by default and e2e encrypted?.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by psiconaut on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:03AM (#13115042)
A few projects that I'm aware of (disclaimer: I'm involved with LEAP):

- https://pixelated-project.org/

- https://www.mailpile.is/

- https://modernpgp.org/memoryhole/

- https://inbome.readthedocs.io/en/latest/

- https://leap.se/

Edit: btw, if you're in Berlin from 14-18 Dec, drop by the AME2016 unconf+hackaton https://github.com/mailencrypt/ame2016

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by 102030485868 on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:39AM (#13115937)
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by raimue on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @01:55PM (#13117227)
It does not have a valid certificate just like any other custom domain hosted on GitHub Pages.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by mixedCase on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @11:40AM (#13123827)
Then you shouldn't consider either GH pages for hosting a security-oriented project or a custom domain redirect.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by rakoo on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:26AM (#13115223)
That's a very nice list of links and overlaps with some idea I had, thanks a lot !

INBOME in particular looks to me to be (part of) the way forward, is there any way to follow progress ?

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by psiconaut on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:33AM (#13115265)
some discussiong going on in the ame2016 ML: https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/listinfo/ame2016

you can also track the repo: https://github.com/mailencrypt/inbome/

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by kkl on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:10AM (#13115114)
Most interesting e2e projects have abandoned email, specifically SMTP, as a secure messaging platform. I would look outside SMTP-based solutions if I were to start using a different project (assuming doing so is an option... I hope it is!).

My recommendation here is Signal: https://whispersystems.org/

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by CmdrSprinkles on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:19AM (#13115177)
A big problem is that a lot of this is driven less by people who have a genuine need for encrypted communication and more by people who want one on principle. And the latter tend to include the people who are more likely to try The Next New Thing.

And it also makes sense. A lot of these services are from companies that need to make money. And there isn't much money in the journalists and dissidents who don't have a bespoke solution.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by NoGravitas on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:40AM (#13115332)
Signal is nice, and I use it. But it's an instant messaging system. Email has different use cases.

I think what we're going to need is a new, non-SMTP protocol, which preserves all of the good things about email, while providing e2e encryption and (pseudonymous) identity assurance. I don't know enough to be involved in designing that protocol, though, other than saying what I want to see as an end-user.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by psiconaut on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:55AM (#13115486)
pond has interesting properties, I think the next generation mail will have to implement some of those ideas.

and Signal/WhatsApp comes to replace (and kill) xmpp, not email. Another issue is the generational shift away from email, that is only for Spam and Work, more and more everytime...

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by NoGravitas on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:25AM (#13122315)
Since Pond is hard to search for, [link attached][0].

[0]: https://github.com/agl/pond

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by kkl on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:18AM (#13115741)
What properties does email have that asynchronous messaging services (e.g. Signal) do not?
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by ThatGeoGuy on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:43AM (#13115980)
Cross-platform (Chrome web-apps don't count), Federated, Distributed, to name a few. The reason email is so entrenched is probably because of these reasons entirely. Being able to send a message from any provider to any provider certainly helped spread adoption easily.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by NoGravitas on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:16AM (#13122267)
There are protocol properties, and client properties. I think some of both are important.

### Protocol

* Easily federated

* Identifiers can be memorable/meaningful (unlike phone numbers) while still being globally unique (thanks to federation)

* Device independent (not tied to a phone number, can generally use the same account on different devices)

* Can contact people you don't know/haven't met (this is possible with Signal, but they'd have to publicly share their personal cell phone number, which is a no-go).

### Client

* Optimized for longer-form, less immediate messaging (folders, drafts, rich text)

* MIME attachments (Signal supports only a limited number of predefined types of attachments)

I feel like you could probably layer an email-equivalent on top of Matrix, but I'm not 100% sure about that.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by Freak_NL on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:31AM (#13115255)
The author of the article mentions Signal as well, but how do you handle communication from a laptop or desktop computer and/or with people who don't own an Android or IOS smartphone?
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by kkl on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:12AM (#13115676)
Signal does have a desktop application. I believe you can also register a Signal account using a phone number from a service like Twilio. I'm not 100% sure that will work with Signal desktop though.

https://whispersystems.org/blog/signal-desktop/

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by sliken on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @10:15AM (#13123067)
Signal in a chrome app can pair to signal on android/IOS. But I don't believe you can use chrome only. The chrome app just waits for you to pair with a phone and can't send/receive messages until you do so.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:14AM (#13115141)
Why not S/MIME? Most clients support it, its stupid easy, and has had a lot of eyes on it considering its age.

Constantly re-inventing email encryption seems to be the problem here. None of them really make this stuff any better. Key distribution is still going to be PITA, but sticking with a supported standard makes the most sense.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by drdaeman on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @12:04PM (#13116178)
No one seem to want to touch anything that already exists. Never heard of anyone thinking of redesigning UI/UX for a typical MUA or browser's keystore (throwing in BTBV option or whatever), although I still believe that must be possible. Everyone's off with their own proprietary non-interoperable (occasionally, "open") standards.

Also, _almost_ no client supports _any_ form of authentication and encryption on mobile, be it OpenPGP, S/MIME, PEP, SaltPack or whatever else. There are few, but that's not even remotely close to "most". Neither there is much choice of good desktop client software as well.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by noinsight on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @12:43PM (#13116566)
> authentication and encryption on mobile

The iOS built-in Mail application supports S/MIME. However, it doesn't support anything above TLS 1.0 for IMAP, curiously.

K-9 and the Android mail client don't support S/MIME, however.

On the desktop, Thunderbird and Outlook support S/MIME. So does mutt.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @12:15PM (#13116281)
iPhone supports S/MIME out of the box. Android has 3rd party mail clients that do. Several desktop clients do, including Outlook.

Its not as dire as you make it to be. People just dont want the hassle and don't value their email privacy. Once they do value this, which they should considering all the breaches of late, then it'll catch on. I work with companies that have S/MIME internally for just this reason. Its completely feasible.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by CalRobert on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:08AM (#13115093)
Doesn't cover "default", but mailvelope is a project working on making email for real people (i.e. webmail) easy to secure. I use it often.

https://www.mailvelope.com/

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by 45h34jh53k4j on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:20AM (#13115178)
Requires private keys to loaded into the browser extension. No thanks! Google's E2E is the same, which is to, say garbage.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by mixedCase on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @02:52PM (#13117719)
There's no way of doing E2E without a key in the client, per its very definition.
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by mtgx on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:19AM (#13115175)
Google's End-To-End also seems dead.

https://github.com/google/end-to-end

I would say ProtonMail or the miniLock-based Peerio.com are now the most interesting projects for encrypted email.

EDIT: https://minilock.io/

https://github.com/PeerioTechnologies/peerio-client

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by 45h34jh53k4j on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:21AM (#13115190)
Private keys accessible to the browser is the worst model. I don't think this was ever taken seriously at Google either...
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by mtgx on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:13AM (#13115688)
It's not the worst model. It's still significantly better than what Google/Microsoft/Yahoo are offering.

And at least it's a model that can scale. When we'll get 10% of the email users to use (real) PGP, then we can talk about about switching everything else to it, too.

But I assume that's never going to happen. The only way PGP would reach those numbers is if Google actually finishes the End-to-End tool, and not only that, but then it actually makes it part of the Chrome browser and automatically asks all Gmail users at sign-in if they want to set-up End-to-End, too. That's the only way I can see PGP reach 10% of the email market. But even then I assume you'd argue it's still "browser-based" encryption. So I guess it's pointless.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by nickik on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:14AM (#13115700)
Private key required in the browser is bad. However if we had a system where those people that want or care can key their keys offline (or on a Smartcard) while those that don't want.

Protonmail with SRP and 2FA where a attack has to pretty tricky stuff but you still get a e2e system is far better then what we have now. Its a far more involved attack to just look at your old emails, and its easier to detect.

We will never have a useable experience for all user if we do not accept compromises. I would prefer if everybody of my family was on some system like that, compared to gmx or yahoo.

There is a lot more you can do to protect the client from the server as well. Keybase is doing some interesting stuff in that direction.

We just have the change our assumption of what it means if a email arrives encrypted with GPG.

GPG is already not perfect and we should move away from it anyway, again, Keybase is offering some interesting steps in the right direction.

Steps on a long road.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by twr on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @09:34PM (#13120045)
> Protonmail with SRP and 2FA where a attack has to pretty tricky stuff but you still get a e2e system is far better then what we have now. Its a far more involved attack to just look at your old emails, and its easier to detect.

Can you explain how this is better than Google End-to-End? (Which isn't completed, I know.)

Or even how it's worth implementing over regular webmail in the first place?

Extensions are obviously not optimal, for the very same reason crypto in JavaScript is not good: timing attacks, cache attacks, optimizations, secure storage (in-memory and on-disk), random-number generation, verifiability, ....

Protonmail suffers from that too. Except it's also subject to key exfiltration. Without an exploit. The server simply promises not to send malicious JavaScript.

It isn't significantly more involved for an attacker who has breached their servers to send malevolent code. It's also not easy to detect.

> We will never have a useable experience for all user if we do not accept compromises.

There are usable end-user interfaces capable of featuring secure cryptography.

Desktop applications. Mobile apps. Browser extensions. Hardware tokens (U2F).

Those can be audited. Inspected. Users can freeze updates.

Trying to implement secure cryptography in JavaScript that is fetched repeatedly from an assailable server is just asking for trouble.

> GPG is already not perfect and we should move away from it anyway

Yes, but that doesn't mean ignoring the advancements that have been made in modern security.

The most appropriate response to securing email is still this: Don't, use a secure messenger; or use out-of-band encryption. It's likely to remain that way forever.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by nickik on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @12:39PM (#13124375)
I have not look at google end to end.

The main benefit seems to be that to read your messages code has to be send to your browser. That is much easier to detect compared to compromise of the server now.

Plus it would have network effects that would benefit normal users.

In theory you could have clients with good guis and all that, these however barly exist and people simply want to use the web for this sort of stuff.

If your answer to solving a issue that billions of people deal with, then "Don't" is just not the solution expet maybe if there is a feature complete replacement.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by twr on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @09:34PM (#13127984)
Sending code to a desktop is easy to detect. Sending code to a non-web-based mobile app is easy to detect. Sending code to a browser isn't even detectable. In practice, no one audits JavaScript. If browsers offered the means to detect changes to cached content, security experts[1][2][3] would be less grim about webpage security.

Encryption done in untrusted JavaScript is security theater. If these websites offered privacy policies claiming to never read your data, like Riseup does, the end-result would be the same. Safer, actually, because deploying unnecessary crypto increases the vulnerability risks.

Recommending these websites is actively dangerous. Journalists and whistleblowers who take these claims of fraudulent security seriously, are going to be killed. Getting them to understand that email cannot be secured in-browser, is the entire point. That if you have important information to protect, you should be moving onto different approaches.

WhatsApp is literally safer than this, and it's more accessible.

[1] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/08/cryptocat.htm...

[2] https://www.nccgroup.trust/us/about-us/newsroom-and-events/b...

[3] https://rdist.root.org/2010/11/29/final-post-on-javascript-c...

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by arebop on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:29AM (#13115238)
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by teddyh on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:40AM (#13115324)
https://pep.foundation/

Commercial offerings for companies at https://www.prettyeasyprivacy.com/

(No, they are not, as far as I know “open core” – they are 100% free software.)

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by CoryG89 on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @10:14AM (#13115140)
There is a reason they mostly don't exist, at least in the US. After Lavabit was so publicly shut down, it's going to be a losing proposition for anyone to put so much time and effort into it, just to then be given a choice between providing a backdoor or shutting down as soon as the government realizes they can't break your service.

If your going to start such a service, it needs to be in a country that will respect free speech. And there aren't many.

Re:I'm giving up on PGP by mixedCase on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:04AM (#13115581)
Lavabit didn't do E2E or at least stored the user's keys; since the owner did in fact have the keys needed to unencrypt the Snowden e-mails (and sent them to the FBI in paper using infinitely small character size, apparently).
Re:I'm giving up on PGP by CoryG89 on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @11:34AM (#13115886)
IIRC, they did not store user's keys. What they wanted was for Lavabit to turn over their SSL key, which would have compromised security for the entire service, rather than just targeting Snowden specifically.

Presumably they did not have the ability to turn over the emails themselves, so they wanted Lavabit to provide a vector to do a man in the middle attack.