Toxic threads like this one are the reason why we're going to try an experiment called "Political Detox Week" on Hacker News. For one week, starting Monday, all political stories and threads will be off topic. We'll kill them when we see them and ask users to flag them.
Then we'll see what happens.
Im pro voter id because its sensible, you need an id to drive, rent a home, buy large goods, get a bank account, and even a nation with a billion people has voter ids.
Both parties have exhibited enormous distrust in the current process, and we need solutions. Im also pro having a paper trail, and neutral observers.
You need to stop projecting your strawmen on me.
Also Ive had to give identity checks and credit checks before renting, so maybe your the one who needs to reevaulate why you believe people dont need id cards.
India went out of its way to ensure its populace had ID or was able to get ID. They go out of their way to place polling locations where they are accessible to remote and disenfranchised population (example: putting polling locations on sides of mountains, while we close the polls two hours after people get out of work). Polling locations were mandatory every 2km from where people lived in India.
In America, we enact voter ID laws, then close 31 DMV locations immediately [0].
The difference is that in America, much like a poll tax or test, these initiatives are implemented to prevent certain people from voting, otherwise there would be a sweeping reform to _ensure_ every eligible voter had an ID card. That isn't the case and courts agree [1] [2] [3] [4].
97% of India's population was given a voter ID (EPIC) card. Indians without an EPIC card have over 12 options for identifying documents which they can present at polls.
[0] https://www.splcenter.org/news/2015/10/02/planned-dmv-closur...
[1] http://www.cnn.com/2016/08/31/politics/supreme-court-north-c...
[2] http://www.citylab.com/politics/2016/07/why-voter-id-is-raci...
[3] http://abcnews.go.com/ABC_Univision/News/supreme-court-strik...
[4] http://www.governing.com/topics/elections/gov-voter-id-rulin...
Also for the cost of the recounts, we could do something very close to the indian model.
According to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on July 20th, 2016 with regards to Texas' voter ID initiative (SB 14) [1]:
> Some of the dissenting opinions argue that the majority opinion holds the Legislature “liable for racial disparities [it] did not create” by failing to show that the statistical disparity in ID possession among different races is caused by a State policy, as opposed to socioeconomic and historical conditions. In fact, as discussed above, the district court found that SB 14 creates a racial disparity by requiring the use of certain IDs to vote that minorities disproportionately lack. Certainly the passage of SB 14 did not cause fewer minorities to possess certain IDs (like driver’s licenses or concealed handgun licenses). Rather, the district court found that socioeconomic and historical conditions contributed to this disparity in ID possession, which demonstrates why historical evidence of racism is relevant to the Section 2 analysis.
> But SB 14 itself caused minorities to disproportionately lack the documentation that is required to vote by dictating that the documents and IDs required would be those that minorities disproportionately lack. We cannot ignore that in passing SB 14, the Legislature carefully selected the types of IDs that would be required to vote. In doing so, the Legislature selected IDs that minorities disproportionately do not possess and excluded IDs that minorities possess in greater numbers, without providing sufficient justification for those choices.
> The fact that this occurred on a landscape where minorities are less likely to possess certain forms of ID or be able to obtain those IDs, at least in part as a result of past instances of State-sponsored discrimination, does not absolve the Legislature of responsibility. Accordingly, the district court’s conclusion that SB 14 created racial disparities in the possession of IDs required to vote is supported by the record.
It's a little odd how, when voter ID laws are passed in certain states, 31 DMV locations are immediately closed[0]. It's almost as if those pushing for the policy don't want people to get an ID and vote, because people without ID tend to be in a certain demographic that doesn't vote for your party.
[0] "Planned DMV closures in Alabama adds urgency to push to restore the Voting Rights Act" - https://www.splcenter.org/news/2015/10/02/planned-dmv-closur...
[1] "Why Voter ID Is Racial Discrimination, for the Record Republican supporters of voter ID laws have been more than candid about how they help their political chances." - http://www.citylab.com/politics/2016/07/why-voter-id-is-raci...
[2] "Court: North Carolina Voter ID Law Targeted Black Voters" - http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/court-north-caroli...
[3] "Getting a photo ID so you can vote is easy. Unless you’re poor, black, Latino or elderly." - https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/getting-a...
Does any one have real objection to ids beyond difficulty to get it?
We made it illegal for black people to vote. Then they were given suffrage. So we had a poll test, pushed because people knew black people were less likely to be able to read. And we had a poll tax, pushed because we knew black people were less likely to be able to afford the tax. Those were made illegal. Now we have voter ID laws, pushed because a certain party knows it will prevent certain demographics from voting. Those are being made illegal in the states that they've been passed in.
We need to look at these laws in a historical context.
> So why cant we do what india did for over a billion people ?
That would defeat the purpose of voter ID laws in America. I agree, if these laws were being promoted in good faith, there would be a well-funded initiative to get every single eligible voter a voter ID like there was in India. We wouldn't be closing down 31 DMVs in a state that just passed a voter ID law.
But these laws aren't being pushed in good faith, they are being pushed for their downstream effects: less people will vote and, more importantly, less people in demographics who tend to vote for a certain party will vote.
Literally all of my citations are from page one on Google. It took 5 minutes.
It concerns me that you are having this discussion and are not used to things like citations backing up arguments.
> just some random schmoe perusing unrelated threads on HN?
Hi. Want a link to my GitHub or personal website?
> he most likely works for CTR or some other PAC
I am a software developer and contractor. I work for myself, thanks.
The level of tinfoil hattery in this post is off the charts.
I'm not sure the privileged HN crowd understands how this works for regular workers who do retail or whatever: you ask for the day off, they say "sure you can go ahead and take it off, and if you do then don't bother coming back the next day, because you'll be fired. And don't try to collect unemployment either because it'll be for-cause". We have a lot of leverage and flexibility allowed because we are skilled workers. Regular people don't have that.
Regular people can't afford to spend weeks and weeks bouncing between government offices and fighting it in courts. They just don't vote because they don't have the documentation. Which is the whole point of the voter restriction laws in the first place.