News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by olegkikin on Friday December 02, 2016 @09:53PM (#13094002)
> can you think of any other investment available to the general public which has ever returned anything like this?

It's not easy to find, but it exists.

NHTC stock went up from $0.09 to $51.46 (+57178%) in less than five years (Dec 03 2010 -> Nov 13, 2015).

INSY stock went up from $0.073 to $44.92 (+61534%) in around 5 years.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by chucksmash on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:16PM (#13094073)
As someone holding 0 BTC, 15,400% makes me smack my forehead so hard you can barely understand.

That said, for people with 0 BTC who are licking their lips: "beware, past performance is no guarantee of future results" is a truism in finance. Make sure you understand everything you invest in.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by AtheistOfFail on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:39PM (#13094141)
So, here's the general thought for BTC investing.

If we wanted to give every person on earth some Bitcoin, you would end up with 0.00217700 which is roughly $2 dollars.

If you purchase a full BTC and it becomes huge, you could make your money back easily, but even if you purchase a 1/10th at $70, you would be well off.

I personally set up a weekly buy of like $10 and just move it from an exchange to a wallet I own. You do not need 1000 BTC, 1-2 would be a worthwhile investment if you're up for it.

Source: http://bitcoinsperperson.com/

Warning to anyone doing this: Bitcoin can be addictive, you buy your first half, then you want one, then you want two, then you want five and then you get ten... and then you sell your house.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by drcode on Saturday December 03, 2016 @12:07AM (#13094418)
The problem with this logic is that it assumes that Bitcoin mining security is still sufficient once we're close to the 21 mil limit- This is starting to become a tenuous assumption and likely some sort of currency demurrage will need to be instituted within the next decade.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by AtheistOfFail on Saturday December 03, 2016 @01:47AM (#13094689)
If I'm alive by 2140, I will personally be there to help the process along.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by koolba on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:46PM (#13094163)
Your logic makes no sense. You'd be better off buying $10 of Mega Millions tickets every week.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by AtheistOfFail on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:54PM (#13094192)
Explain why you believe my logic makes no sense.

I did not say Bitcoin would take off or be worth millions. I merely said the only bad time to buy Bitcoin is after every person on Earth has some, at that point, it may be too late.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by koolba on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:04PM (#13094235)
Your investment philosophy is based on the hope that Bitcoin soars in value, possibly driven by some type of global uptake. Neither of those is going to happen.

Why would everyone on earth have Bitcoin? The vast majority of people don't have any non-cash assets, and many don't have any cash assets either.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by AtheistOfFail on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:12PM (#13094269)
> on the hope that Bitcoin soars in value

faint hope.

> Neither of those is going to happen.

Yes, because a digital method of making payments will never take off. Paypal would like a word with you as well.

> vast majority of people don't have any non-cash assets, and many don't have any cash assets

Think about it, it's a currency that behaves like cash virtually. You can transfer it anywhere that internet exists. Western Union would like a word here too. There's thousands of people around the world that are unbanked because of many reasons.

> Why would everyone on earth have Bitcoin?

They wouldn't.

Bitcoin settlement is 10 minutes. Try transferring money to another country and having it "ready to go" in 10 minutes with lower fees than Bitcoin. The business-to-business remittance market is worth Billions and that's not even counting customers.

> CXO at Fortune 500

I never subscribed to the whole 'It's going to take over the world', because it won't. However, the technology's upside cannot be denied and you should have the tools to analyze them as a CEO, CFO or CTO. The reason for "my logic" was to point out that there is no "bad time" to throw $5 into Bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by koolba on Saturday December 03, 2016 @07:34AM (#13095445)
> Yes, because a digital method of making payments will never take off. Paypal would like a word with you as well.

I didn't say there wouldn't be a future digital method of payment. I'm talking specifically about Bitcoin.

Slightly off topic, Paypal is due for a challenger as well. It's aging gorilla in that space.

> Think about it, it's a currency that behaves like cash virtually. You can transfer it anywhere that internet exists. Western Union would like a word here too. There's thousands of people around the world that are unbanked because of many reasons.

There's no reason that has to be Bitcoin. In fact, Bitcoin has a number of problems that make it unworkable as a "world currency".

> They wouldn't.

You specifically said, "Before everyone has one."

> Bitcoin settlement is 10 minutes. Try transferring money to another country and having it "ready to go" in 10 minutes with lower fees than Bitcoin. The business-to-business remittance market is worth Billions and that's not even counting customers.

There's no reason a better platform won't arrive that works both within the borders of a country and across it's borders. Ten minutes per confirmation is a long time. For anything more than a pack of gum you probably want more than one confirmation as well (say at least 5 or 6 for an international wire transfer). That combined with the block size issue, global DDOS vulnerability, and history of Bitcoin companies either fleecing customers or getting fleeced by hackers means it's going to be a long road.

> I never subscribed to the whole 'It's going to take over the world', because it won't. However, the technology's upside cannot be denied and you should have the tools to analyze them as a CEO, CFO or CTO.

Being blind to the downsides and limitations is arguably much worse.

> The reason for "my logic" was to point out that there is no "bad time" to throw $5 into Bitcoin.

Throwing money in a bucket because "Something good might happen" is generally a bad idea. Larger amounts of money make it a bad idea at a larger scale. Being "Only $5/week" doesn't make it a better idea, it just limits the damage. If you're writing off the $5/week as a total loss and consider this pure speculation, then sure go nuts. But I wouldn't preach this as a long term investment recommendation to anybody.

Also, early December 2013 would qualify as a particularly bad time to buy Bitcoin though dollar cost averaging would handle part of that.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by AtheistOfFail on Saturday December 03, 2016 @02:43PM (#13097183)
> For anything more than a pack of gum you probably want more than one confirmation as well

Actually, if it's a trusted partner, 1 confirmation is enough. Hell, if it's someone you do regular business with, 0 confirmations may even do it. Businesses that regularly transfer thousands across borders could do use this to settle transactions every night.

> There's no reason that has to be Bitcoin.

There's no reason it doesn't have to be Bitcoin.

> global DDOS vulnerability,

You can't DDOS the network since it's so far spread out.

> history of Bitcoin companies either fleecing customers or getting fleeced by hackers means it's going to be a long road.

There is an incentive to scam your users and for your company to be attacked. You get money immediately by just packing up and running or attacking a company that holds customer funds.

> You specifically said, "Before everyone has one."

Yes, the best time to purchase Bitcoin if it's in your "list" would be before everyone has one.

> early December 2013

There was only one Bitcoin sold at the high price of 1024. Current price is 700ish. Once we pass that 1024, there will be no time where it was a bad time to buy bitcoin.

> wouldn't preach this as a long term investment recommendation to anybody.

Depends on your definition of long term. I consider mine to be 5-10 years but I'm less risk averse than that the average investor.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by LAMike on Saturday December 03, 2016 @12:34AM (#13094498)
>Why would everyone on earth have Bitcoin?

"Why would everyone on earth have Internet?"

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by kalleboo on Saturday December 03, 2016 @08:14AM (#13095534)
"Why would everyone on earth have a Slinky?"
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by koolba on Saturday December 03, 2016 @07:09AM (#13095396)
> "Why would everyone on earth have Internet?"

Bitcoin ≠ Internet

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by _coldfire on Saturday December 03, 2016 @04:05PM (#13097486)
You are comparing an investment with an expected value of -30% to another which could go either way. I'm struggling with the logic of how minus thirty is the better choice here.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by arrel on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:45PM (#13094158)
It's tempting to describe bitcoin as "investing", but it's really gambling. I could say I bought $30K in lottery tickets and ended up making a few million off it, but I wouldn't call it investing.

It might sound like semantics, but too many people mistake gambling for investing and end up losing their shirts.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by IsaacL on Saturday December 03, 2016 @07:59AM (#13095490)
I made this mistake. Bought £1500 worth of btc a couple of years ago, and they've appreciated nicely. I didn't feel so clever during the year-long downswing, though. I've started putting most of my money in an index fund and only a small amount in gold each month (I'll probably start splitting my gold budget between gold and bitcoin at some point). I learned that investing isn't about making speculative bets but figuring out where your money needs to go to best fit with your life goals.

I was reading lots of perma-bear/libertarian bloggers, the type who predict impending financial apocalypse. I still think they have a case, which is why I still sock away some of my monthly savings in gold/btc. But I also now realise that you can't bet your entire future on one possible outcome, hence the bulk of my money going into the index fund. If I save up enough that it becomes worthwhile I might look into the Buffet strategy of individual stock picking (he says with a small amount to invest you can make superb returns in well chosen small-caps).

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by kbaker on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:01PM (#13094226)
Why can't it be both? Isn't "investing" in the stock market also gambling?

Bitcoin is a pretty great investment asset actually, since there is a finite, limited supply, and any sum can be transferred nearly instantaneously.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by arrel on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:48PM (#13094362)
The difference is in expectation of return. In retrospect, bitcoin is a great "investment," but looking at the hundreds of other failed cryptocurrencies it's clear that early buyers of bitcoin got extremely lucky.

It's the same as seed stage startup "investing," which is likewise really gambling, and you either have to diversify heavily, get very lucky, or have the ability to influence the outcome yourself to win in the long run.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by pmarreck on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:01PM (#13094227)
How is it "gambling" any more than, say, stock is? Because stock prices vary based on actual real events? Well, bitcoin prices vary based on actual real events as well.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by tempestn on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:12PM (#13094268)
Buying stock is buying interest in a company. Buying an individual stock certainly does have a significant speculative element, but in aggregate companies are expected to make money, and so stocks are expected to either increase in price or pay dividends.

Buying bitcoin as an investment is more like forex trading (in fact, that's almost literally what it is), which is zero-sum.

Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by arrel on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:49PM (#13094366)
I would argue that buying a single stock is gambling, but buying into a fund, or taking the time to research and invest in hundreds of stocks, is investing.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by pizza on Friday December 02, 2016 @09:44PM (#13093980)
A taster of the kool aid ye may be, but a part of me says try not to make yourself be known as a whale/mark ;)
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by user837387 on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:08PM (#13094045)
I'll bite, what do you mean?
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by imaginenore on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:23PM (#13094090)
I think he means you have to be careful with that kind of bitcoin wealth, especially if you store your bitcoins yourself. All it takes is one criminal to find this out, and there will be all kinds of people trying to get it. It's pretty trivial to break into someone's apartment and torture you till you give up your bitcoins.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by acdha on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:27PM (#13094103)
Torture? It's possible but I'd lay long odds that in most cases a targeted phishing or malware attack would be both easier and cheaper — and far less likely to get a serious law-enforcement response. Someone being held captive for money would make the national news and the perpetrators would have a tough time heading for the nearest country without an extradition treaty; “rich guy shouldn't have clicked on that link” might not even make the local news.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by zwily on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:06PM (#13094249)
Given his background with bitcoin, I'm guessing (hoping) he keeps his coins in a way malware can't get at them.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by acdha on Saturday December 03, 2016 @10:53AM (#13096124)
Given the number of high-profile embarrassing security failures in the bitcoin world, I would not make that assumption. Defending against a skilled attacker is hard and there aren't many targets where someone can make that kind of money with as high a likelihood of success or little personal risk.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by joshontheweb on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:21PM (#13094083)
Whales (large btc owners) can become targets for hackers or even home invasions if the wrong people get wind of who you are.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by therein on Saturday December 03, 2016 @12:19AM (#13094453)
People may target him if they know he has money.
Re:Bitcoin Beat the Trough of Sorrow by SturgeonsLaw on Friday December 02, 2016 @09:59PM (#13094016)
Congrats on the excellent returns. I'm just a spectator/occasional BTC user, but I love the crypto world.

We're in the middle of a shadow war/revolution being fought by many different actors using technology, legislation and ideology, and it's by and large happening under the nose of the everyday public without many of them realising. Fortunes, freedoms and lives are being won and lost, and underpinning it all is mathematics and computer science.

Every now and then I'm hit with a sudden feeling of living in the future, and it's things like this which trigger it.