News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by physcab on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:50AM (#13037510)
Thank you for writing this. When people talk about these issues it becomes easier and more acceptable to society and it helps lessen anxiety stigmas.

As someone who suffers from anxiety and who regularly seeks therapy, I can say that the rituals that have helped me are:

- Realizing that anxiety isn't who you are, but more like a disturbance that will pass

- Eating, sleeping, exercising, and practicing mindfulness go a long way

- Knowing and dealing with the physiological reactions helps. Realizing that anxiety is a fight or flight response and is often based on fears of the future, which causes heart to race and breath to shorten. Therefore, simply forcing yourself to take large breaths and being mindful about the state of your body helps bring you back to the present and not let your mind get into "rabbit holes"

One piece of advice I have for you is to not take on the role of mental health professional in your relationship. This isn't your problem and you can quickly tire yourself out. All you have to do to support is help your wife accept her current state, and help remind her of living in the present. If her condition is severe enough, encourage her to see a psychiatrist in addition to a therapist too. It may help greatly.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by Broken_Hippo on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:10PM (#13038153)
"One piece of advice I have for you is to not take on the role of mental health professional in your relationship"

So much this. My first husband was schizo-affective. I often felt I was in the role of caregiver and part-time mental health professional, all while trying to work to supoprt us both. And this was while he had medications to help him and very regular psychiatrist appointments.

Looking back, I should have insisted that I was ill-prepared to do all the stuff. I should have insisted on some therapy for myself as well, and asked for more help from the mental health services, possibly wellness checks and other such things. It is so much easier to say this stuff now in my late 30's than it was in my early to mid 20's, however.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by xahrepap on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:40PM (#13038395)
> I should have insisted on some therapy for myself as well

Yes. So much this. I suffer from pretty serious anxiety. And just a few months ago I was fighting through the worst of it. Looking back at how much my wife was doing and how stressed she was... I feel like she could've benefitted from therapy almost more than me.

I wish we as a culture can get over the therapy stereotypes. Both my kids see a therapist on a regular basis and have been for years (adopted through foster care. Lots of trauma). We've been trying to help them learn how helpful it is. It's fun to see them ... brag(?) ... about going to therapy. They are excited when I ask them after work about their day and how they got to see their friend, the therapist.

When talking to other people who feel like they need therapy but are too embarrassed, and just tell them about my kids. Ask them if they would judge them for going. Talk about how much they love it.

One day therapy will be more common!

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by Broken_Hippo on Friday November 25, 2016 @01:17PM (#13038744)
I actually hope that regular mental health checks are as common as physicals. One way to reduce the stigma, anyway. Until then, suggestions to folks that are intersecting the system would do well - on top of actually having enough trained professionals to do so.

The last bit might be one key to it: Sometimes folks have trouble even finding an free practitioner. The problems get even worse in the US if you are low-income since not everywhere will take medicaid.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by jsprogrammer on Friday November 25, 2016 @01:13PM (#13038707)
My problem with "therapy" is that the word is woefully undefined.

Sticking an ice pick up a person's nose, into their brain, and just moving the pick around has been counted as therapy.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by freehunter on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:41PM (#13039299)
Yeah and leeches used to be called "medicine" but if you shy away from doctors because of what the profession practiced in the past (things that are illegal now) you're not exactly doing yourself any favors.

Therapy these days does not mean lobotomies.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by jsprogrammer on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:22PM (#13039936)
Ok, so therapy has moved from lobotomies to...

As I said, therapy seems to be devoid of any real definition.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by digler999 on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:42PM (#13040077)
psychotherapy is a form of treatment for many psychological disorders as defined by the DSM-V. The treatment varies based on the therapist's style and patient preference, but it always centers around talking to a licensed professional about the patient's feelings, behaviors, thoughts, dreams, fears. Through talking, the therapist can spot patterns of harmful and destructive beliefs and thought patterns. To use a bit of jargon, they can deconstruct a patient's defenses and suggest changes in thoughts/actions that - if followed - may often alleviate some or all of the symptoms. Perhaps the thing that bothers you is that it's an inexact science ?
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by lisper on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:49PM (#13041039)
I upvoted you, but I would like to say that I think jsprogrammer's remarks being downvoted into oblivion is not warranted. He (she?) may have made his (her?) point inartfully, but it is a valid point: what is the basis for believing that "therapy" (whatever it may mean at this particular point in time) actually works, that it is anything more than a placebo?

For example, this to me is a yellow flag:

> talking to a licensed professional

Why is licensure such a key feature? Licensure can be as much an indication of political corruption and protectionism as scientific validity.

[EDIT: Just for the record, I actually do believe that therapy works, and I have advocated for it myself. That doesn't make it any less valid to ask the question: what is the basis for this belief?]

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by digler999 on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:52PM (#13041259)
> jsprogrammer's remarks being downvoted into oblivion is not warranted.

he's making loaded statements out of ignorance because he wont bother to google psychotherapy's definition. There is a therapeutic process to talking and learning to manage emotions and cope with defenses.

Licensure is a key feature so you prohibit people from making fake therapeutic claims or quackery. Or to limit taking advantage of emotionally vulnerable people (it still happens, but licensure requires insurance). Same reason you or I can't call ourselves doctors and claim to cure physiological illness. Do you disagree with that "licensure" too ? Why can't you and I open up a back and spinal clinic ? We could probably make a lot of dough.

I dont know why its acceptable to denigrate the field of psychology. Is the 'engineering way' the only way to solve problems ? Should they just "stop it" until they have humans figured out down to a schematic/circuit ? Then they can treat all the anxiety/depression from our overworked consumerist lifestyles and make us into the perfect capitalist cattle ? Is psychology bullshit because Apple doesn't yet sell iPsychometers with USB-C interfaces so we can patch our brains with the latest "update" and all be perfect?

Humans aren't machines and healing or treatment for psychological pain and mental illness isn't done by running a script. It's done by interviewing patients, classifying symptoms, taking surveys, attempting (and often failing) treatments, doing double blind trials. Things that aren't deterministic, which is also the nature of reality. Why can't you face that ?

edit: let me give you specific examples of why you need a license to practice:

* patient comes in and says they were raped. and the alleged rapist is still doing it. unlicensed quack might be scared to report it to the police, might avoid helping the patient at all because it's "too difficult", or might try to exploit abuse victim for his own sexual pleasure.

* elderly suicidal patient divulges financial info to therapist, who then tips off a dirty lawyer/estate planner into contacting the patient and stealing /exploiting him.

* husband and wife go to therapy. Husband knows he's getting divorced but doesn't want to pay half. So he pays off the therapist to give biased testimony in court blaming the wife for false actions.

* therapist was personally harmed by a particular person earlier in life. now they take joy in intentionally misleading/upsetting other patients who look/act like the one who hurt them.

I hope this is enough to see why the field is regulated.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by lisper on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:57PM (#13041442)
> Why can't you face that ?

What makes you think I can't? (And why are you getting so defensive?)

> I dont know why its acceptable to denigrate the field of psychology.

Don't confuse denigration with legitimate criticism. Jsprogrammer's comments may have been loaded and ignorant, but they were not wrong: lobotomization was in fact considered a legitimate therapy in the not-so-distant past. And Psychology has a very checkered history, e.g.:

http://jeffreymasson.com/books/final-analysis.html

And a current replication crisis:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis#Psychology

So some skepticism of the profession's claims is not entirely unwarranted.

BTW, but for the defensive tone, I think your response was very good, and exactly the sort of thing that is needed in this discussion. I upvoted you again.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by digler999 on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:25PM (#13041541)
I apologize, yes I was defensive. Probably because I need more practice having my ideas challenged. Thank you for bringing this to my attention and I will work on it. (and thank you HN for somehow cultivating a community where we can have such a forum).

Absolutely, I agree that the field is not perfect. Let me address the link you sent (I haven't read the book): Psychoanalysis (also called the psychodynamic method) is but one of several prominent forms of therapy. I've never undertaken it, as I cannot afford to go 3hrs/week for a year or more, so I cannot talk from experience. I have read quite a bit about it from textbooks and I see a lot of merit to at least the theory. Merit, I say, because it appeared to corroborate with anecdotal evidence from my own life. I have seen the pattern in people, over and over again, who re-enact the behaviors they learned during their youth. You particularly hear about it with domestic violence: girls that grow up seeing mommy getting beat up (somehow) (very often) seem to become attracted to violent men and repeat the cycle. Boys who grow up seeing daddy beat up mommy (tend to) become aggressive toward women when they are adults.

So I don't personally think the entire field of psychoanalysis is bullshit. The books I've read said that a good psychoanalyst can shake the patient to their core. It sounds like they are trained to sniff out the patient's malignant / self-defeating behaviors and show them how they are reenacting them in the therapeutic relationship. From there, I don't know exactly how they motivate change, but once they break you down on such a primitive emotional level, once your defenses are removed and layed before you, it makes sense that you would be weakened enough to consider making a change.

So that's my case for psychoanalysis. Now, of course someone could take advantage of that. Maybe a patient is simply bipolar and their problems have nothing to do with reenacting their mom's abuse cycle. An unethical therapist could take advantage of that and milk the patient for 3 years' therapy and then say "oh yeah actually you just need to be on meds". It's malpractice and I'm sure it goes on every day in the medical field. MD's milking medicare. experienced dr's running unnecessary tests "just to be sure" when they know exactly whats wrong. Doing an X-ray in the hospital instead of an outpatient clinic so they can charge 3X more. Malpractice will always be around both in medicine and psychology.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by lisper on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:44PM (#13041761)
> I haven't read the book

You should. It's an eye-opener.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by randomdata on Saturday November 26, 2016 @05:39AM (#13042878)
> Licensure is a key feature so you prohibit people from making fake therapeutic claims or quackery.

Here in Canada, diary farmers need to be licensed to sell dairy products, as do poultry producers (chicken, turkey, eggs, etc.)

Not because anyone is worried about someone selling fake milk or trying to claim ducks are chicken (quackery, get it?). If they were, they'd be equally worried about farmers producing other kinds of food, whom we do not require licensing from. Rather, the story behind it is much simpler: The government at one point found it important to disallow competition to give the people operating in these markets an advantage to help them remain viable, for similar reasons as to why the US has provided farm subsidies over the years.

Anyway, the point being that regulation does not necessarily legitimize a profession. It may simply be an indictor of what interests lobbied hard enough to get economic protection.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by digler999 on Saturday November 26, 2016 @05:26PM (#13046280)
I dont doubt that regulation enables regulatory capture, but what if assholes started selling dairy products that weren't up to sanitary code ? Say, like, a food truck. One day it's there, one day they're gone (conveniently after selling 50gal of tainted milk that sickens dozens). what do you do about that ?
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by vivekd on Sunday November 27, 2016 @02:25AM (#13048167)
Well it's certainly a good thing that we never see such incidents of malpractice with licensed professions like medicine and law.
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by randomdata on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:03PM (#13057171)
Treat them the same way we treat the unlicensed farmers who have just as much ability to taint their products...?
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by atsaloli on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:54PM (#13040445)
BTW, NIMH has turned away from the DSM due to "lack of validity ".

https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2...

If it's that inexact, I wouldn't call it science.

There's presently no standard objective laboratory test for Anxiety, Depression, or similar.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by digler999 on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:12PM (#13040562)
> There's presently no standard objective laboratory test

I don't know what's so special about a "laboratory". Is there a name yet for this fallacy "because a machine told me, it must be true." ? Should we name it the "calculator fallacy" or the "internet fallacy" ?

from your link: "That is why NIMH will be re-orienting its research away from DSM categories." Its research, it doesn't do any good to toss DSM for treatment of mental disorders. I believe thats why they revise the DSM every year (?), is to keep up with changes in diagnosis. If a new classification system comes along, then replace "DSM" with whatever they call theirs.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by jsprogrammer on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:37PM (#13040718)
As astaloli said, the DSM is not valid.

If changes in diagnoses are changing yearly...the NIMH seems completely correct in rejecting the book.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by digler999 on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:05PM (#13041298)
> the DSM is not valid.

that makes treatment easy then. POOF! all mental illness disappears because the book is "invalid". FYI you're using a defense called denial[1] when you do that :)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denial

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by atsaloli on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:34PM (#13041587)
We do actually need valid treatment.
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday November 26, 2016 @05:10PM (#13046184)
That's going to be hard to organise if no one is sure what they're supposed to be treating.

It looks like you're using a God of the Sciences argument - because we don't have a full and complete model of mental anguish and self-defeating behaviours, nothing we currently believe about them can be useful or true.

This turns out to be inaccurate. Therapies are tested regularly. Some score better than others, and statistically the results are at least as valid as the result of clinical drug trials.

It would be useful to have a complete Theory of Mind, but no such thing is likely to exist for a while.

Luckily it isn't needed to make a difference. The most useful therapies are results-oriented rather than process-oriented, and the most consistent results come from behavioural reinforcement techniques (where "behaviour" includes "persistent emotional states.")

This doesn't mean other kinds of therapy are useless. But they are less reliable - which may be because they can be more challenging for both sides, or because they don't work, or for all kinds of other reasons.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by echlebek on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:23PM (#13039181)
They're talking cognitive behavioural therapy.
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by dom0 on Friday November 25, 2016 @01:43PM (#13038926)
Wasn't that done through the eye socket?
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by dominotw on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:20PM (#13039162)
>One piece of advice I have for you is to not take on the role of mental health professional in your relationship. This isn't your problem and you can quickly tire yourself out.

This is precisely the opposite of what happened in the post in question. Cause of anxiety was wanting to live a lifestyle and not wanting to work a stressful job. Marriage and "permission" to quit solved the issue immediately. None of the therapy stuff did them any good, she didn't need therapy as soon as the underlying problem was identified and solved by them. No amount of sleeping, exercising or eating kale would have solved that.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by michaelkeenan on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:46PM (#13039338)
I get a different impression from the post. Rather than quitting and marriage solving the problem immediately, I think she still has anxiety, because he wrote: "She still has anxiety, and I imagine she always will. But we are able to deal with this in a much more productive way. Sure, there are times where it all gets a bit too much"

I don't think it's correct to say "None of the therapy stuff did them any good" because therapy isn't mentioned in the post. If you meant counseling, he mentioned that positively, in the context of the useful decision to quit the job: "we found a private counsellor who could help get to the route of what was causing some of this anxiety — we then discussed a lot of these sessions and reflected on them and tried to put into practice some of the advice we were receiving. We also made big and brave decisions like my wife quitting her exhausting job up in London"

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by dominotw on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:52PM (#13039375)
>She still has anxiety, and I imagine she always will.

Wouldn't it be strange for a human being to have no anxiety ?

>we found a private counsellor who could help get to the route of what was causing some of this anxiety 

I understood this as the counsellor putting a rubber stamp on what they already knew, so that the decision could be made guilt free.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by skybrian on Saturday November 26, 2016 @01:23AM (#13042049)
Feeling anxious sometimes and suffering from anxiety attacks are different things. Most people (I assume) don't suffer from anxiety attacks like described here. The people who do get anxiety attacks would like it to stop.
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by NumberCruncher on Saturday November 26, 2016 @04:20PM (#13045929)
>> Cause of anxiety was wanting to live a lifestyle and not wanting to work a stressful job. Marriage and "permission" to quit solved the issue immediately.

I am goin to play the devil's advocate but it would solve all of my problems if I would marry someone ritch who pays my bills while I quit my stressfull job and follow my passion. And she should also write a blog post about it.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by theparanoid on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:38PM (#13040039)
By switching jobs I went from anxious and uncertain to happy and outgoing. It's not complicated.
Re:Married to someone with anxiety by NumberCruncher on Saturday November 26, 2016 @04:29PM (#13045973)
>> This isn't your problem and you can quickly tire yourself out.

This is totally right.

>> All you have to do to support is help your wife accept her current state, and help remind her of living in the present.

And this is totally wrong. I lived 4 years long together with someone having anxiety like the wife of the OP. We could literally never go out just like other joung couples because she was afraid of crowded places. Guess who did I met on the overcrowded dancing floor 3 months after breaking up? She and her friends.

People sometimes only need the opportunity and free space to take the responsibility for their own conditions and to take care about their own shit. With great responsibility comes great power.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by tmalsburg2 on Saturday November 26, 2016 @06:50AM (#13043047)
> Realizing that anxiety isn't who you are, but more like a disturbance that will pass

This is the right attitude during an anxiety attack, because while it is happening there isn't much you can do but to remind yourself that it's going to pass. However, my personal experience is that anxiety is not a random infliction but something that can have very concrete causes that need to be worked on. Identifying these causes can be a long process, though. In many cases anxieties arise when we have deeply rooted unhealthy habits that seem so much part of our lives that it doesn't even occur to us that they could possibly be changed. OP writes that his wife had to commute four hours a day which in itself will affect mental well-being but which may also point to career issues. Fixing that was apparently part of the solution.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by hashmp on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:22PM (#13040271)
"- Realizing that anxiety isn't who you are, but more like a disturbance that will pass"

Absolutely. Roll with it, it will pass, there is no question of this. Keep going, if you can, and wait for it to lift.

Re:Married to someone with anxiety by superdude on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:35PM (#13040976)
Yes, good point to try to keep in mind.