News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by tasuki on Thursday November 24, 2016 @05:40PM (#13033250)
Not just plausible, it's pretty damn sure.

Still, major props to Hideki Kato, who's developing cutting edge AI at the age of 62. I wish to have his drive at that age!

Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by gcp on Thursday November 24, 2016 @05:43PM (#13033259)
Not just plausible, it's pretty damn sure.

Your certainty is based on what data?

Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by cybertronic on Thursday November 24, 2016 @06:37PM (#13033477)
Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by gcp on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:07AM (#13036131)
A rating based on 3 games has a pretty high (read: enormous) error margin.
Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by WilliamDhalgren on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:15AM (#13054297)
A rather similar hardware with a recent version of the same program plays on the KGS server. Seems to be about what would be 10d and is among the top players on the server (was 1., now seems to be 3.).

You can see the graph of its playstrength; its quite impressive to see the gains Zen got from implementing ValueNet (and previously with PolicyNet) really.

https://www.gokgs.com/graphPage.jsp?user=Zen19K2

Hardware for ZenK2 was given on computer-go mailinglist:

Zen19K2's information is

------------------------------------- Computer program Zen running on KURISU server provided by DWANGO.

CPU: Xeon E5-2623 v3 x2 GPU: GeForce GTX TITAN X x4

http://computer-go.org/pipermail/computer-go/2016-October/00...

author of Zen gave the hardware behind this match, in a post to the same mailinglist as:

http://computer-go.org/pipermail/computer-go/2016-November/0...

CPU: 2 x Intel Xeon E5-2699v4 (44 cores/2.2 GHz) GPU: 4 x nVidia Titan X (Pascal ) RAM: 128GB

So rather similar.

~10d is way way lower than what AlphaGo had to be to play on par with one of the top players of Go. Pro ranks start around or just above the KGS 9d (which is around what a 7d rank would be for regular amateurs in most world amateur organisations). A rough approximation is that you can take 3-4 pro ranks for each dan rank/stone of handicap (well, to the extent one can even approximate strength by the rank, as a rank once won is kept for life, so as you age and young pro players pass you by, your rating is getting inflated). So apriori you could expect Zen to play around middling pro ranks, and maybe around the strength of the v13 of AlphaGo, the one that beat Fan Hui, and described in the Nature paper. And that's about what his play with Chikun indicates as well.

Cho Chikun's rating is 3239, while Lee Sedol's is 3508. so around 300 elo difference, which seems a conservative estimate of the difference scale (and the results of the two matches do indicate, if weakly, that the actual difference is even larger). A 230 point gap corresponds to a 79% probability of winning.

For comparison, distributed AlphaGo v13, the one that played vs Fan Hui is 250 elo points stronger than a single machine version of the same version of AlphaGo.

Also if that would carry any weight with you, you could just take it on the say-so of Myungwan Kim 9p, who was doing commentary on both DeepZen and AlphaGo matches. Really the difference in strength seems rather obvious to such a strong go player, as you can see in the way he criticized some DeepZen's moves, and how impressed he was with so many of AlphaGo's.

Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by zump on Thursday November 24, 2016 @06:38PM (#13033479)
What is the key to remaining agile at that age?

So many of my coworkers seem to have lost intellectual curiosity as they have gotten older.

Re:Go master Cho wins best-of-three series against Japan-mad... by chris_st on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:54AM (#13036368)
My own personal opinion is embodied in the phrase, "You don't stop playing games because you get old, you get old because you stop playing games."

I'm fairly close to retirement, and have friends who are getting there (or retired already). I really enjoy programming, and intend to continue indefinitely; most of my friends tolerate it as a job, and look forward to not doing it when they retire.

So it's the old "follow your passion" thing, again, I guess... I have that curiosity about such things, they don't.