News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by lawpoop on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:18PM (#13019958)
This call seems problematic.

Doctors suffer from a kind of bias-- not sure the name of it-- but they only see people when they have problems. The only time doctors encounter the human experience of LSD, magic mushrooms, etc. is when something has gone wrong.

Unless the doctor has spent a lot of time at music festivals, burning man, etc. they

Sure, alcohol is a very dangerous drug, and causes all kinds of ill health, chronic conditions, emergency room visits, accidents, etc. But, because most doctors have had a typical experience with alcohol, from trying it as a teenager, binge drinking at college, and now social/casual drinking, they think it's safe, because they've had lots of experiences that didn't end with someone going to the hospital.

I'm not sure what the best route is for this, but asking doctors to take lead on this doesn't seem like an effective campaign.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by themgt on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:30PM (#13020028)
By the same token, doctors are better equipped to understand (to the extent we can) the neurochemical reactions being caused by drugs and how they act on the brain. I would imagine a doctor who e.g. understands how many anti-depressants work by targeting the serotonin system would find it interesting the way many psychedelics also are serotonergic - people are basically just dumping analogues of their own neurotransmitters into their brain.

Similarly, look at the relationships chemically between sumatriptan (used to treat cluster headaches), psilocybin and DMT. Or the opioids, stimulants ... substances like coca and kratom that have been used for hundreds or thousands of years and analogues of which are used in medical settings all the time.

The argument that these are crazy, dangerous substances with zero legitimate medical value pretty instantly falls apart to anyone who understands how closely related nearly all of these substances are to pharma drugs widely understood to have legitimate medical value.

I'd in fact be interested to hear which "drugs" have the least relation to any recognized western medicine. Salvia divinorum?

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by skissane on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:56AM (#13020430)
> By the same token, doctors are better equipped to understand (to the extent we can) the neurochemical reactions being caused by drugs and how they act on the brain.

I'm not sure how true that is. The amount of knowledge of (bio)chemistry required by most doctors in their day-to-day work is actually quite limited. A few years out of medical school, and many of them have already forgotten most of what they were taught in medical school, and the medical school curriculum really only gives a high-level overview of the topic.

I'm not a doctor, but my mother and brother are. My mother despite being a doctor will admit her chemistry knowledge is quite limited, but to be fair to her she doesn't need to know much chemistry at all to do her job–you don't need any detailed knowledge of biochemistry to prescribe an antidepressant or perform a caesarian section. My brother by contrast knows a lot about chemistry, but that's not due to medical school, that's due to majoring in chemistry as an undergrad.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by threatofrain on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @04:42AM (#13021346)
This sounds like you at least want to have policy experts or domain statisticians involved. Doctors aren't really in a place to understand whether a policy has failed, but they are in a place to lend credibility as a community that has fostered the currency of credibility. I think you'd be surprised how many doctors don't understand the empirical aspects of medical literature, or any empirical literature.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by dfraser992 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @04:26AM (#13021278)
From a scientific standpoint, salvia should be researched as it operates on the k-opiod receptor and ought to be useful in gaining more insight into consciousness (as anyone who has taken it would attest) [1] There are other opiods mentioned in the Wikipedia article in the same class that are used as pain medication.

From a medical standpoint, I believe there has been some research into salvia's potential use as a anti-depressant, but that might just be anecdotal, I can't recall right now.. [1] points to some clues how this might be the case. Now I remember some research into depression and how it is related to the pain centres in the brain in some fashion - "Tylenol appears to reduce activity in a region of the brain called the “dorsal anterior cingulate cortex,” which research has tied to physical pain and social rejection and ostracism, Randles explains. It’s likely that dampening activity in this brain region accounts for the study participants’ weakened sense of anxiety, though Randles says it’s too early to prescribe Tylenol as a cure for existential distress."

From a psycho-spiritual viewpoint, oh boy. I could go on forever about that and the need to really start getting a handle on this topic (re: transpersonal psychology). But my own experiences (i.e. kundalini, reliably) and what that is like... what is going on, from a scientific standpoint, even if it's all in my head, is very interesting. The brain/mind connection is a lot more complex than we can even think of...

I haven't read the article yet, so I don't know if it promotes the medicalization of psychoactive substances, which is a concern of mine. Lumping everything under "drugs" (but leaving out alcohol) is really idiotic. There are all these facets, along with sociological aspects, that each substance needs to be considered individually when figuring out a rational way to deal with the problems while utilizing them in some fashion to improve society.

So, no, salvia does have some relation to western medicine.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%9A-opioid_receptor#Conscio...

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by kem on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:44AM (#13020389)
I sympathize with the OP, although my concerns are slightly different.

I worry that physician groups are trying to shape this narrative in a way that just shifts government-sanctioned power from one group to another. Physicians are not disinterested parties in this, because they have huge financial benefits to gain from official policy being that drugs are a "medical" issue. Once this happens, if nothing changes about the way that the medical system is organized, you'll just have a different group sucking up money and controlling individuals wholesale without sufficient justification.

I agree with you up until a very critical point. Doctors are better equipped to understand the neurochemical reactions being caused by drugs than criminal justice professionals. However, they are not necessarily better equipped to understand the neurochemical reactions than other scientific professionals, nor are they better equipped to understand the economic, social, or legal consequences than criminal justice and other professionals.

This is what is happening with the medical rhetoric: you have a group of experts in area X, who are currently legally designated as either the only people truly qualified, or in control of those qualified, arguing "drugs are an issue of X." In doing so, they put themselves in control of decision-making in this area, with all the financial benefits that accrue to them, and, more dangerously, simultaneously take control of discourse away from others, because then they become the ones who are only, or who are most qualified to make decisions about whether or not it is an issue of X. Once society deems drug use a "medical disease," then physicians become the people who are only truly legally qualified to make decisions about drug use, and also the only people truly qualified to make decisions about drug use policy. It's an entirely self-serving vicious circle.

This line of reasoning is also dangerous, because there is no end to its logic. Given that humans are fundamentally biological beings, any state of human suffering can ultimately be seen as "medical" in nature.

Reading this sounds conspiratorial, and I don't mean it to be, but it's frustrating to me that society doesn't recognize the ethical conflict of interest created by current medical certification and licensing systems.

Don't get me wrong: the current system for handling drugs is woefully broken. But I worry that labeling drug use as a "disease" will only shift the problems from one area to another, unless that system is also reformed to foster a more competitive, less hierarchical health care community. Drug use problems are a complex, social, biological, psychological, legal, economic problem set that is outside the purview of any particular professional community. The best approach is to just deregulate it, and treat it as a form of human suffering that requires a multifactorial approach.

I'm deeply skeptical this will happen, though, given our recurrent need to oversimplify everything.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by nradov on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:51AM (#13023840)
Except that no one really understands why SSRIs have an antidepressant effect in some patients. We have some hypotheses but the underlying neurochemical mechanism is still somewhat mysterious and unproven.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by kolinko on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @04:46AM (#13021363)
Well, a doctor who studied serotonin extensively, but never took MDMA is like a virgin read all the online tutorials about sex.

He may have the knowledge, but I'd question his understanding.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by anexprogrammer on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:26AM (#13021525)
The full editorial itself is reasonably neutral and well stated. They may be overstating their ability to "build pragmatic and rational policy".

For your assertion however, I can only yell "NO". I can't emphasise that strongly enough. Just gives supremely high chance of poor opinions heavily biased by the over confidence effect.

This is probably controversial, so bear with me, while I try and explain as it'll probably take some space. I'll apologise for length and poor explanation before I even start!

Let's look at a different neurotransmitter a moment - dopamine. Amphetamines markedly affect dopamine receptors. If most people take recreational doses they'll be stimulated, motivated, and sociable. If I take it I get no effect on motivation, and chill out. I'll probably sit and binge watch TV, work or read a book for eight hours straight. I won't be bothered to be sociable as I'd be delighting in the chilled calm. You may not be surprised to learn I have ADHD.

I fought for years with doctors "knowing" drugs and how they act on the brain in trying to get diagnosed with ADHD. Took years to not be dismissed out of hand. I don't find most doctors any more aware than the general public much of the time. That's not a function of where I live - time hanging around the assorted ADHD forums that have come and gone show all countries have had similar issues and hundreds of people struggling to get a diagnosis or referral because of horribly poor doctor, psychiatric or specialist awareness. Often those doctors are responding as though the patient is a normal brain merely seeking recreational drugs (which of course happens too), but it's entirely opinion. It's not uncommon to get misdiagnosed something else, perhaps with lasting and damaging consequences. (You don't typically ever get "undiagnosed" of mental disorders).

For many only when learning the field extensively themselves is real progress made. It's quite sobering to realise just how many have had to start studying and reading research themselves prior to being able to get diagnosis.

Minds are more difficult as we tend not to be able to diagnose anything like as easily as a broken bone, germ or viral illness. There's a need to rely solely on self reporting as we can't, yet, throw someone in a scanner and identify them as having depression, ADHD, Asperger's or LSD addiction. In the case of recreational drugs and use there's going to be little in the way of studies of their effects on healthy minds. I seem to remember quite recently LSD had the first study in 50 years. Anti depressants often seem to have suicide and suicidal ideation as side effects - the same medicine can have dramatically different mental effects in ways not often seen with say paracetamol.

The main difference then is a doctor is more likely to be believed and have opinions acted upon without any real understanding. They may have better understanding, if and only if the correct studies are there. For the most part they won't be. Yet.

Doctors are well placed to advise on studies and contraints as health impacts arise from legalisation however.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by tudorw on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @04:15AM (#13021240)
look at which companies make large acquisitions in pharma nutrition
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by roel_v on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:53PM (#13020148)
There are several policy areas where doctors feel they have more to add than they actually do: tobacco discussion, whether or not bicycle helmets should be legally required, euthanasia/abortion issues (the moral aspects of it, not the technical ones), ...

I think it's a remnant from when doctors were part of the 'upper class' of the village (or even city), along with the priest, the school teacher, etc. Whereas today, in more educated circles at least in my observation, doctors are just body mechanics. They derive most of their status from their pay. (Much less so e.g. in the small town I'm from, where doctors are still respected just for being a doctor - but are paid less).

Edit to add: I'm not going to modify my comment above because that invalidates all the responses, but it seems like all responses are taking the wrong message from my post: I'm not making some sort of moral judgement on the work of doctors, what I'm saying is that doctors aren't any longer so special that they're part of the intellectual elite (and hence are consulted on topics being their expertise) just for being a doctor. Sure most doctors do work that's beneficial to many people, but so do teachers, and I don't think anyone is going to claim that teachers have high status in society (because of it, or at all).

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by wfunction on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:20AM (#13020283)
> today, in more educated circles at least in my observation, doctors are just body mechanics. They derive most of their status from their pay.

...WTF? Is it even possible to write a more egotistical comment? Most doctors (especially surgeons, etc.), along with firefighters, police, etc. derive their respect in "educated circles" not from their pay (that's some of the worst nonsense I've heard this week) but from the kind of work that they do: saving other people's lives, especially in situations where one small mistake on their end can prove fatal for one or more parties involved. That's quite sufficient to deserve a ton of respect just by itself....

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by roel_v on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:50AM (#13020411)
Yeah, way to quote out of context.

"Most doctors (especially surgeons, etc.), along with firefighters, police, etc. derive their respect in "educated circles" not from their pay (that's some of the worst nonsense I've heard this week) but from the kind of work that they do: saving other people's lives, esp"

Ah yes, the 'everybody deserves a medal' mentality. Let's not forget the garbage man, without whom we'd be choking on our own garbage! Praise his selfless sacrifice!

In the mean time here in the real world, those firefighters and policemen you talk about are (in the case of firemen) replaced with volunteers, and paid a very basic wage (yes yes because of political/union dynamics some of that group in some US states are paid well with early retirement yadda yadda yadda - I'm talking in general). Way to show status and respect, society!

In the mean time you're spinning a straw man of how I supposedly look down upon doctors, where my actual point is that doctors aren't that special intellectually speaking. Most people reading this could be doctors if they wanted to. Does that mean we look on them? No. But it does mean we don't put them on some pedestal as if they're so smart - which is what used to happen when the majority of people had no or very little education.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by omegaham on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:49AM (#13020407)
> one small mistake on their end can prove fatal for one or more parties involved

This right here is why I respect the hell out of doctors. Every morning, they wake up with the knowledge that today, they could kill someone through inattention or ignorance. I'm sure that they don't think about it that way while brushing their teeth or whatever, but that's an awesome responsibility.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by Johnny555 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @01:19AM (#13020509)
Do you share the same respect for airline pilots, bus drivers, crane operators and all of the other occupations that can kill multiple people through inattention or ignorance?
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by makingithappen on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @02:06AM (#13020717)
I do respect those people, but the comparison to my profession is ludicrous.

Here's what happened just today at work for me:

Before noon, I received two patients in septic shock. Both required intubation and central lines. One required a chest tube. Early in the afternoon I had my finger directly compressing a carotid artery that was spraying across the room as my staff tried to call in the vascular surgeon. Around 1800 PM I got a rapid GI bleeder who died spilling blood out both ends. Because it happened within 24 hours of an admission, the medical examiner had to be involved. She was young. One other existing patient in the ICU died of septic shock around 2000. I stayed until well past midnight talking to families, putting out fires, dealing with loose ends and spending time with the floor residents to make sure they know how to handle events like this without having a breakdown (not that I've figured it out yet). I just got home and will have to go back in about 5 hours from now and face who-knows-what. My friend, a neurosurgeon, is still in the neuro-ICU at this hour (it's about 0100 local time). Oh and flu season is coming up; that's when shit really hits the fan.

I realize that isn't a typical day for most doctors (nor is it a routine day for me; but not a rare one either), but it is demeaning to suggest that the emotional impact of this kind of work or the relationships developed therein could be even remotely comparable to that of an airline pilot with his/her passengers.

Oh, and I don't get paid a dime extra for being there 18 hours and assuming a bunch of extra risk. If the patient who's neck bled all over after surgery at another hospital decides to sue, I'll get added to the lawsuit, even though we saved his life.

My point is not to demand "respect" or elevate myself above anyone else; I come from a pretty humble family and stayed that way for the most part. I simply don't think anybody has a comparable work environment, especially the emotional side, which is very hard to describe to other people.

As for the parent post: opioid prescribing is complicated and is going to get worse as our "performance" becomes tied to patient satisfaction surveys. Won't affect me much, but will be a very difficult balance for primary care doctors.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by roel_v on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:40AM (#13021577)
Paramedics/first responders save lives too, in scenes just as dramatic or more as yours. Is being a paramedic 'high status'? No it's not. Look I'm not here to tell you or anyone anything about how useful or stressful their jobs are; hell I mean I sit at a desk all day writimg code that'll be run by 10 people ever if I'm lucky. What I'm saying is that status doesn't depend on any of that, or on how hard you work, or on how hard you studied. I'm not making any claims about whether that's right or not either, just describing reality.

Or how about this - does your boss still do the things you describe? If your hospital is medium sized or bigger, he spends half his day pushing paper and the other half controlling petty infighting between the surgeons. Yet is his job lower status than yours? Would getting his job, for you, be a demotion or a promotion? Seems to me the answers are pretty obvious.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by digler999 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:58AM (#13023890)
My hat goes off to you for working so hard and being so dedicated. It sounds like you had an awful day, and I'm sorry.

Please dont take this as criticism, because I respect everything you do. But consider this:

> I don't get paid a dime extra for being there 18 hours

Why do you have to be there for 18 hours ? What if medical school weren't so difficult to get into, that there were enough doctors for each of you to work 4 hour shifts ? You could then do 4 hours of intense-pressure, saving lives. An hour lunch break, return and do 4 hours of paperwork/damage control, etc. Then go home and relax like everyone else ?

For the amount of money those patients are being charged ($10k+ per night in ICU), there's adequate money going around to hire 5 more of you to allow 6 separate 4-hr shifts of trauma coverage.

I dont know where the bottleneck is. But I'm concerned that there's an artificial scarcity somewhere, perhaps in medical school. Perhaps in the board certification. Maybe there shouldn't be a 15-year educational requirement ? Maybe a nurse with 6 years' experience could be qualified for a "micro-practice" in a limited capacity ? No, not a PA (see, now we're dealing with status/prestige ), a doctor, responsible for pt's for 4 hours/day.

I dont know where the problem is, but maybe we are just over-regulated ? We put so much care into making sure the wrong people dont get in, that now we're overworking those who do get in. In that 18 hour shift you described, do you really think you are as alert at the end of the day as you were that morning ? Overworking people undoubtedly leads to lower quality, and a there has to be a breaking point where it's going to be better to let more people in than it is to burn out the few people who do make it past the barriers.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by angersock on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:43PM (#13024227)
That's a lot of sepsis. How much of that was acquired during the stay in the hospital, one wonders?

How effective can you actually be pulling 18 hour days?

I appreciate that you feel like a hero, but everywhere else in the civilized professional world we've learned that keeping such hours and being in permanent firefighting mode leads to sloppiness and inefficiency.

Then again, when we're sloppy and inefficient, we don't kill anyone.

(I've worked on software for use in ICU and other clinical environments, and frankly am utterly unimpressed at the systems doctors and administrators allow to persist at the expense of patients so that they can either feel like heroes or retain talent.)

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by erelde on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:58AM (#13022292)
> My point is not to demand "respect" or elevate myself above anyone else; I come from a pretty humble family and stayed that way for the most part.

I think you can demand "respect". It's not about being humble.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by cmdrfred on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:17AM (#13022019)
Ask someone who served in Iraq about his time there, it would make your day look like puppies and sunshine. Should we defer to jarheads on all matters of domestic policy?
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by mej10 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @09:28AM (#13022842)
You don't think ICU nurses or PAs (especially at big hospitals) have a comparable work environment?
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by Pyxl101 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @02:27AM (#13020812)
What causes that kind of rapid GI bleeding?
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by makingithappen on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @02:41AM (#13020875)
Almost certainly an ulcer in the stomach or duodenum, especially given her medication use. If the ulcer erodes an artery, it can be catastrophic. Just not common to see it someone as young as she was. About 5-10% of "lower" GI bleeds are actually rapid upper GI bleeds. Easy to miss.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by lr4444lr on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:30AM (#13022117)
Yikes. What medications are known to have this side effect and what early warning symptoms of it can one heed?
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by truth_sentinell on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @01:47AM (#13020629)
Hell, even software programmers can kill a lot of people by letting a bug slide. But I agree that in general, doctors have a bigger and more direct responsability in that matter.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by angersock on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:53PM (#13024313)
One might note that the respect due to "police" is in decline, as people are wising up to their thuggery and lack of expertise and morality.

> saving other people's lives, especially in situations where one small mistake on their end can prove fatal for one or more parties involved.

Which is why their incompetence has risen to the third-leading cause of death in the United States ( https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2016/0... ).

There are a lot of doctors (and especially nurses!) that provide valuable care every day. That said, we can't just blindly assume they know what they're doing and give them respect that they haven't earned--especially when the healthcare system is as fucked as it is today and they refuse to take an active role in fixing it.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by prklmn on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:23AM (#13020300)
The status you speak of for physicians in general is derived from saving lives - generally thought to be pretty honorable. Also, doctors who work in more rural areas are trending towards making more than those in cities and already do make more when cost of living is accounted for.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by coredog64 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @08:18AM (#13022410)
Not going to say a dermatologist or podiatrist can't save lives, but I think they get most of the respect granted doctors who do without the same effect on society.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by digler999 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:20AM (#13023634)
My pet peeve is the "cosmetic surgeon", making obscene amounts of money and wasting valuable medical resources to pursue a practice of enabling vanity.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @08:21AM (#13022426)
Public Health doctors get the least respect/money? And arguable do the most societal good of all, essentially saving all of us from epidemics etc.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by germinalphrase on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:58PM (#13020173)
I feel like this is a narrative for which I am nostalgic despite being too young to have ever really experienced even though I grew up in a small town. I wish that those in my community who serve their neighbors in an important way were more respected socially. Sure, the local paramedic - Sam - doesn't make a lot of money, but everyone knows he's a good guy you can rely on. Everything feels so transactional.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by ryuker16 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @01:27AM (#13020547)
many paramedics work for a private company for peanuts.

Public figures are still respected. I suppose it's less so because education is more common. The Gulf between a medical doctor and your average citizen was huge

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by enraged_camel on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:05AM (#13020199)
It completely depends on the type of doctor. If we're talking about GPs, then sure, their work is mostly standard and they refer anything non-standard to a specialist. But specialists are definitely held in very high regard in their social circle. Surgeons especially.

>>They derive most of their status from their pay.

No, they derive it from the insane amounts of education, training and hard work they have to put in to get to where they are at. It's basically "crunch time times two" all the time from the moment they start med school until they complete their residency, and only slightly lessens afterwards.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by roel_v on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @01:00AM (#13020451)
You know who also works hard? Juanita the single mom illegal immigrant who works one job in the chicken factory during the day and another cleaning motel rooms in the evening to feed her 4 children, and still barely scrapes by. How much status does she have?

I'm not dismissing how much doctors study, or how hard they work (outside of GP's and some specialties like dermatology). Many of my friends and family are doctors. While I agree that I might have phrased my comment a bit more carefully, it's awfully lazy to just conclude from what I said as 'doctors are only after the money'.

My real point was - being a doctor no longer (by itself) makes one an intellectual. Knowing quite a lot of doctors myself, I can tell from firsthand experience that many of them are just as (un)informed and (dumb|smart) as the, say, smartest 1/3th of the population. Doctors have lots of highly specialized knowledge, yes; that doesn't make them better on issues that go beyond medical technicalities than a mathematician or lawyer.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by naveen99 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:32AM (#13022125)
As a doctor, you are partially right.

There are some doctors who look at their job as technicians for money.

However there are some who really do go out of their way and give a 100% at the loss of their own family. But, probably so do some politicians...

i agree with your point, that people's qualifications in one field don't necessary entitle them to a respect from authority in another field.

tbe reason they are asking for doctors help in this is, to reduce the political fallout from people who respond to authority. They may as well also ask for help from teachers, firefighters, priests, airplane pilots (I believe Air Force even uses methamphetamines) ...

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by digler999 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:35AM (#13023726)
you seem to be garnering a bunch of hostile responses, so I want to say I agree with you. And I think a lot of their "prestigious education" is somewhat "prestige theater". I believe it's artificial scarcity, either to keep the prestige high, or (somewhat cynically) to keep wages high.

Yes, there has to be a rigorous QA process to get your medical license and keep practicing. That's already covered by a state board of medical examiners. Where I think the artificial scarcity comes in is medical schools. There shouldn't be this "interview" process and excessive scrutiny, 6-figure tuitions, and do-or-die levels of pressure to simply learn how to practice medicine. I think this manufactures prestige.

There should be enough medical schools for virtually anyone who wants to get in. If idiots go they will flunk out at exam time. No need to screen them at the door. No need to ensure they have "straight-A's". What they need is the willingness to learn. It should be "to be a doctor, you need to learn topics {A,B,....Z}, and once you do, and demonstrate that to the board, you are a dr."

You should be able to start out emptying bedpans and have a ladder you can climb to get to physician. I can't think of someone who would make a better dr than one who has already worked 10 years in a hospital. Go from orderly/CNA, to nurse, to practitioner, to dr. And structure the education to work around this! Once you get to nurse, allow a 3 day-work, 2day school schedule. Even if it takes you 8 years, you have an MD with basically an entire clinical rotation completed. And (theoretically) no debt! Now this person doesn't need a $200k salary to pay back their tuition loans. Ultimately this could lower medical costs for everyone.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by robbiep on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:43AM (#13020385)
Doctors, in my experience, are the biggest drug fiends on the planet, behind perhaps rockstars and crack addicts
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by omegaham on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:46AM (#13020399)
I'd be doing amphetamines too if they stuck me on 36-hour shifts.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by akiselev on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:29PM (#13020025)
That may have been true in the past but the situation has rapidly changed over the last decade. Amphetamine and opioid abuse stemming from over-prescription is becoming far too common and doctors are now experiencing the full spectrum from people genuinely in pain to high-risk heroin addicts. When the latest public health scare is a drug abuse epidemic attributed to the medical system instead of the black market, it's far harder to ignore the futility of the war on drugs.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by ajb on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @03:53AM (#13021179)
Mods: sibling comment by 'icantdrive55' is 'dead' for no clear reason.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by kefka on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @06:43AM (#13021848)
That's hellbanning for you. It's also a good reason to look at your user page via a private session in your browser every so often, esp if you have no comments to you.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by greglindahl on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:47PM (#13020121)
So you're saying that doctors are only capable of evaluating personal experience, and not evidence collected by others? That puts a whole new spin on the medical profession.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by Something1234 on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:49PM (#13020130)
No, he's stating that they have a cognitive bias. One that is not easily realized.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by tremon on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:09AM (#13021464)
Doctors suffer from a kind of bias-- not sure the name of it-- but they only see people when they have problems.

Only half on-topic, but it's called selection bias.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by Beltiras on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @03:33AM (#13021083)
It's even worse than this. Every panel of experts called to testify on this contains doctors from the treatment/prevention sector and that subgroup of doctors holds even harder on to this bias than a regular practitioner.
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by disordinary on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @02:27AM (#13020811)
The thing is that doctors are hypocrites, they smoke, they drink, they eat junk food, they don't exercise, they do hard drugs and help themselves to unneeded prescriptions, they don't drink enough water, they don't sleep enough, etc.

They know what's best for people, but they also know that people can make informed decisions, they certainly do.

Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by martinald on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:57AM (#13021635)
You think doctors don't experiment with drugs at university the way they do with alcohol?! At my university the medical students were renowned for their extra curricula "drug research".
Re:The war on drugs has failed: doctors should lead calls fo... by shshhdhs on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:48AM (#13020403)
Perhaps a good way to explain the bias that you mentioned is "tunnel vision"?