You could imagine an antithetical essay "I, police" involving a lawless village in which each person trains extensively in martial arts and marksmanship in order to protect themselves. Then each realizes it is more efficient to focus on their own vocation and hire a private security guard. Then a few neighbors realize it is more efficient to pool their money and hire just enough security to protect their block, and finally the whole village realizes it is most efficient to pool their money into just enough security, at which point they realize they have formed a government with taxes and police force. The story could end with "It is a fact most astounding that the forces of an unencumbered free market lead directly to an inevitable centralization into a collective governing whole."
Of course this story does not prove that all affairs should be handled by the government; but the pencil doesn't prove the opposite either.
The point is that the simple things in our society are the product of very complicated networks of activity that nobody understands. And this is pretty universal, whether you are talking about pencils or police.
Of course this complexity is not the only consideration that determines how things should be done. But it is a consideration that is usually ignored when people seek to regulate an industry.
Your village police story OTOH is made up.
If such a high profile and somewhat controversial essay was wrong on the details, I think we'd have heard about those errors.
I'm sure there are many 'origins of the police' narratives, but one I know is the Metropolitan Police of London were developed explicitly to curtail the dock workers from exercising their customary right to take small amounts of the goods they were unloading home with them. To generalize from this (a dangerous game, I know, but this seems to be the flavor of the thread), institutions are constructed to protect the interests of one class from another
The article makes the point very well - and it's something that definitely should be taught more in school.
I think it's very easy for kids to grasp 'top down' control in government, teams or organizations - it's something so intuitive it does not need explanation.
The concept of 'free markets' and their ability to facilitate amazing things is in some ways counterintuitive, and needs to be learned.
So I think the point is fair.
I don't think anyone is implying that all systems must operate in this manner.
Games are full of Man-with-a-hammer examples, like "bluff all the things" (eg. poker), "sacrifice all the things" (chess) or "never run to win the race" (backgammon). This inevitably leads to failure, but economy being what it is, the failure is too vague, too diffuse and too erratic to acknowledge them in the case of "free market all the things".
It just assumes that trickle down economics works, and repeats this "lesson" ad nauseam chapter after chapter.
However, it is very clear historically that trickle down economics does not work, and that completely unregulated markets lead to human rights abuse.
Picketty is much more enlightening.
Economics In One Lesson is an exercise in logic, showing that many popular economic policies are flawed or will necessarily have non-obvious side effects.
EIOL is also deliberately written to be an easy read.
It's hard to compare the two.
(In the unlikely case anyone cares, my personal take on Piketty: wealth inequality doesn't matter unless you think jealousy is a matter of public policy. Wealth inequality is an inevitable consequence of progress. What matters is whether the wealthy can loose their wealth due to their own mistakes, and whether wealth inequality implies legal inequality. Private profits and public risks, bailouts, legislation a la tete du client, bribes, lobbying, monopolies, special tax agreements, propping up markets, complicated laws, ... that's how the 99% get screwed. Taxes allow the government to function. They cannot "counterbalance" the legal privileges of the 1%.)
From wikipedia on Trickle-down economics:
> A 2015 report by the International Monetary Fund argues that there is no trickle-down effect as the rich get richer:
>> [I]f the income share of the top 20 percent (the rich) increases, then GDP growth actually declines over the medium term, suggesting that the benefits do not trickle down. In contrast, an increase in the income share of the bottom 20 percent (the poor) is associated with higher GDP growth.[19]
The one thing they have in common is both being pretty polemical in tone.
Just like “I Pencil” delivers the crucial, uplifting insight that complex economic cooperation spontaneously emerges everywhere. This order will exist prior to and regardless of any political system.
Keeping these broad insights front and center at all times, does not imply that you have to reject every proposed intervention a priori. But if you know that every intervention will have side effects and can backfire because of the sheer complexity of the order, even when meaning well, you will naturally be much more careful and skeptical.
Which in my opinion is really a very, very, very good thing. Especially in this day and age, where the spontaneous order is more complex than ever and where government is once again very big, technocratic and e.g. willing to "clamp" macro economic variables.
I also quite simply disagree that EIOL is “beneath simplistic”. If the kids are interested in economics, they should obviously read much more than just these texts.
Lawmakers are sort of masterminds, especially when defining the founding principles of the law. They don't have pencil production, and usually any particular production, in mind.
The beauty is that a general principle allows almost any business to flourish; the lawmakers need not know what specific business it might be. This makes such laws reasonably future-proof.
I don’t think the author wanted to write a reference work on all aspects of its subject :-)
Here’s what I personally get out of its perspective: contentment and inspiration. It provides glory to the seemingly mundane tasks of everyday economic life. Comparing prices, finding customers and suppliers, solving small problems, settling disputes. This is what the invisible machine is composed of.
It also shields my mind, like a lode star that guides me away from many popular beliefs about what “needs to be done to boost GDP”.
I am not sure that a mind shield is a good thing.
The shield/lode star thing: let's not go full politics. I'm not narrow minded... Let's just leave it at that :-)
"There is a fact still more astounding: the absence of a master mind, of anyone dictating or forcibly directing these countless actions which bring me into being. No trace of such a person can be found." This is one of the beautiful miracles of our kind, a fact that remains unknown to most of us. Including many who figure themselves at the commanding heights.
Every attempt to make this fictional mastermind more powerful makes our fate worse.