News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by ChuckMcM on Monday November 21, 2016 @03:51PM (#13009085)
How is this any different than Google whining at me that I should really make them my primary search engine in the browser because they are better than any alternative. There are literally billions of dollars at stake here, he who controls the gateway to the Internet, controls the universe (with apologies to F. Herbert).
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by tweakz on Monday November 21, 2016 @03:59PM (#13009152)
FTA: "We’re already used to Google’s search engine pushing Chrome, Yahoo linking to Firefox, and Bing recommending Edge. This year, Microsoft has upped the ante in the browser war with Windows 10."

One could make the argument that making the push from the OS is a different level than from the website.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by guelo on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:33PM (#13009412)
Google Search is more of a monopoly than Microsoft Windows.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by acomar on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:03PM (#13009644)
There's less of a lock-in effect though. The only thing stopping you from using a different search engine is that you're more comfortable with Google, it provides better (catered to you) results, etc.. That is, competitive advantage.

When people leave Google Search (and they will, nothing lasts forever), they'll leave fast.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by addicted on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:43PM (#13009939)
That may be true of Google search, but Gmail? Or Google Accou ts, for that matter? Almost certainly not. It's far easier to switch from Windows to a Mac or Chromebooks or even Linux than it is to switch from Google and its associated services.

Further, because of mobile, there are significantly greater number of Google users than there are Windows users.

I guess I am annoyed because as someone who uses Firefox as their primary browser, it always frustrated me that there was t more outrage at Google pushing people away from Firefox. But the moment MS started doing it, it became an outrage.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by acomar on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @04:26PM (#13017817)
The account would be by far the hardest thing for me to walk away from. Email is federated and I can export the mail out of Gmail without too much hassle. I don't because I like the interface they provide (for now). Calendar, same deal. I'm there for the convenience, not because another calendar application wouldn't work for me.

Accounts would be the hard part because that's my phone login, and there's no standard account service I could migrate to that would give me a functional replacement.

The real thing keeping me on the Google platform is the convenience of having these things tied together. But that's not exactly a strong lock for me. I can and do hop services while sacrificing convenience. This might be a stronger hold on others but it's still not Microsoft's you-can't-do-work-in-any-organization level of hold between Office, Windows, Exchange, etc..

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by flukus on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:36PM (#13010615)
Google has lock in, it's just less obvious. Other search engines might not be as good because they don't have access to my search history* and email data for instance.

* This has actually been annoying for me lately. The results favor the things I've already clicked on which is often exactly not what I'm after.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by acomar on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @04:29PM (#13017840)
I'm not saying there's no lock-in, just that it's not as rigid or strong. Better search results (for you) is exactly the kind of reason you want to be using one search engine over another. If another search engine started providing better results, you'd be able to swap, and the only effect would be the psychological disorientation from the change interface (I struggle to use DuckDuckGo because my eyes scan the wrong part of the screen while trying to take in the results).
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by aq3cn on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @08:34AM (#13013974)
Have you tried these search engines? These are proxy to Google's or other's results. You will not feel lock in with this for sure because it is bare bone.

https://www.startpage.com/

https://duckduckgo.com/

http://ixquick.com/

https://searx.me/

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:15PM (#13009284)
I think it's a poor argument. The difference between OS, application, and web-level content is blurring more and more each year. We have web apps built into OSes, OSes built on top of web browsers, etc.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by heinrich5991 on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:03PM (#13009195)
In the example you mentioned, I think that there actually is a difference.

1) You use Firefox, and Microsoft tells you that you should use IE instead. 2) You use Google Search, and Google tells you that you should use Google Search more often.

The first is similar to Google somehow placing notes in Bing Search that Google search is better, the second is similar to Microsoft telling IE users that IE is better than Firefox in [this metric].

I think 1) is ethically more questionable than 2).

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by vmarsy on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:18PM (#13009301)
> You use Google Search, and Google tells you that you should use Google Search more often.

Actually when you use google search, google tells you that you should use Chrome. The exact popup says:

    Google works better with Chrome
    Yes, get Chrome now
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by yellow_postit on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:20PM (#13009316)
Same 'notice' with Gmail. Inbox refuses to load in Edge, not sure about Firefox or Opera
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by acomar on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:00PM (#13009618)
Works fine in Firefox.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by CobrastanJorji on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:12PM (#13009705)
"Google works better with Chrome" is the same as any other page's "this site designed for Netscape Navigator" button, a perfectly acceptable practice for the last couple decades. Your operating system popping up a warning that "Microsoft Edge is safer than Firefox" is an entirely different ballgame.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by 21 on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:20PM (#13009762)
Every single time I login into Gmail with Edge I am presented with a banner to switch to Chrome. I dismiss it, next time it's still there. I've seen this banner many many times. You would think that eventually they would give up.

If I login with Firefox, no such banner (I think because it would cause an uproar within the dev comunity).

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by addicted on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:45PM (#13009953)
I used to see it with Firefox every time.

The psychological burden of having to mentally validate my choice of browser every time I used Google was a factor made me switch away from Google, so maybe they've stoppped doing it now?

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by tn13 on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:32PM (#13009397)
I would love to replace the Google Now on Android with something else. Till then I think I dont blame MS here.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by nitrogen on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:37PM (#13009451)
"Tu quoque" is not a very strong argument, and this distracts from one problem by bringing up an unrelated one.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by tdkl on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:12PM (#13009700)
Let's see how the EU Android trial will finish and hope for the best.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by petre on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:29PM (#13009822)
That's one of the main reasons I installed Cyanogenmod. To get rid of Google Now and finally remove tgat annoying text input from my desktop.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by vurpo on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:11AM (#13015036)
You can just disable Google Now in the Google settings, and install a different launcher like Nova Launcher, if you want to get rid of Google Now entirely. Modding your phone is not necessary for this.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by douche on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:07PM (#13009234)
Google tries to insist that I should use Chrome on my old Surface RT. Only problem is, that isn't a product that exists...
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by olyjohn on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:36PM (#13009435)
So because Google sucks, that makes it okay for Microsoft to suck too? And because billions are at stake for these companies, it's somehow okay to screw over the public?
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by NTripleOne on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @03:05AM (#13012477)
Sorry - I must have missed something - who exactly is getting screwed over here?
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by tdkl on Monday November 21, 2016 @03:57PM (#13009140)
Probably because some people actually paid for the OS and still have to see this dumb shit.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by spacemanmatt on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:09PM (#13009239)
We might not all pay Microsoft, but we all pay the costs
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by daxelrod on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:41PM (#13009484)
It's slightly different because Google has not had a court find that they abused their monopoly position to push their own browser and crush competition.

I am not suggesting that this current action violates the terms of Microsoft's settlement, only that there's relevant historical context here.

To be clear, I think both companies' whining is tacky and annoying.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by ChuckMcM on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:33PM (#13009852)
https://www.ft.com/content/3f290294-0627-11e6-9b51-0fb5e6570...

I agree that Google has not had a court find them an abusive monopolist, but I would add "yet." As someone who watched the Microsoft case start out in the tech press, then move to the mainstream press, and then finally become indictments the similarity to the process with Google is pretty interesting. If you follow the dollars, you can see how much money Google is paying for search traffic which squeezes out organic growth of competitors and were it not for Microsoft's warchest of cash probably would have killed off Bing before it became operationally profitable. And they use that search engine dominance to push the browser of their design which favors their products? That feels very much like Microsoft using their dominance in the OS space to push their browser which favored their products and technologies.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:33PM (#13009847)
Almost twenty years ago. And while Google hasn't yet been ruled against (outside of Russia), they're under investigation for "tying", the same anticompetitive practice Microsoft was found abusing, in almost every major first world nation.

And while Google bundles it's browser, like Microsoft did, it also bundles almost twenty applications now, which in most cases cannot be removed by the user.

So, yeah, twenty years ago, Microsoft did some bad things, but Google is doing much worse right now.

Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 21, 2016 @03:53PM (#13009106)
Mostly that people have, for years, default-assumed Google was a public good, and Microsoft was an inherent evil. It's really not different at all, each company is utilizing their most prevalent platform to push their other product.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by dogma1138 on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:13PM (#13010511)
The difference here is that this might be actually "true" advertisement, Edge has atm better protection against social engineering attacks, and since MSFT moved to run it in an isolated VM which in effect acts as a sandbox it's also better protects the user against browser exploits.
Re:Windows 10 informs Chrome and Firefox users that Edge is ... by startling on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:41PM (#13009922)
It's different because Edge is emphatically not more safe.