News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by gcr on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:15PM (#12990138)
> If anyone who does that is a bigot, then boy, everyone is a bigot sometime - and the distinction is meaningless.

Nah. Different races are different, sure. In-group and out-group. But there's also a power element that you're not considering. Black vs white is in-group and out-group, but one of those groups is disenfranchised. That's where the racism comes in. It is anything but meaningless.

Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by m_mueller on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:30PM (#12990246)
I truly think that if this thinking prevails, then liberalism in the US is doomed.

Sorry to become preaching here, but for the love of science, stop caring about race, gender snd ethnicity so much, instead care about class. There are at least as many white folks with no means to get ahead than black folks - and we haven't yet considered the other major ethnic groups. What you should care about is the 'glass ceiling' installed for a whole class of people who cannot offer their sons and daughters the chance to move up anymore. Liberals need to get back to tackling issues, not identities, that make the American nation such a divided one. And the obvious one to me is education. Forget about affirmative action, make high quality education accessible for any capable resident. Having less in-group vs. out-group thinking will follow automatically when people start thinking that everyone gets a fair chance again.

Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by nickbauman on Friday November 18, 2016 @10:37PM (#12991937)
I'm all for doing whatever works. But white people aren't getting arrested for being white. They aren't getting redlined for bad loans. They aren't having their schools having resources getting directed away from them because the student body us predominantly white. It doesn't just cleave along lines for some. It cleaves along matrices.
Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by m_mueller on Friday November 18, 2016 @10:53PM (#12991985)
Tbh. it's hard for me to imagine how the government can fail so hard as to have racist resource allocation for education. How hard can it be? You have state level funds for public schools right? Divide by nunber of pupils, have some budget controlling, done. How can resources even be redirected, if not for everyone in the state? Who's deciding this? Are they relying on sponsorship? If that's the case then get rid of that and raise taxes and public funds accordingly. I firmly believe that schools need to be egalitarian, everyone deserves the same resources and care at the start of his/her life, with the only exception being special care students.
Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by tomp on Friday November 18, 2016 @07:08PM (#12991085)
> instead care about class

my hero!

Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by Kalium on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:38PM (#12990290)
One of the key points in this article is that when you divide people into identity groups, some of those groups are going to feel neglected. As you get at, some of those groups that feel neglected are groups you and I would consider privileged and protected.

Yet... other people don't vote based on what you and I think or feel. They vote based on what they think and feel. If people are treated in a way that makes them feel like they are out-group, regardless of structural power, those people will tend to act like an out-group instead of a powerful in-group.

tl;dr: You can tell people that they're an enfranchised in-group, but if they don't feel that way it might backfire.

Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by jshevek on Friday November 18, 2016 @07:29PM (#12991173)
> You can tell people that they're an enfranchised in-group...

This is not (and should not be) very meaningful for the individual.

Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by throwanem on Friday November 18, 2016 @10:04PM (#12991841)
Many disagree. Consider the possibility that they might not be wrong in so doing.
Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by Kalium on Saturday November 19, 2016 @04:18PM (#12995744)
You're right! Many people rightly consider this very relevant to the lives of individuals. This is something that should always be considered.

Yet, the issue remains - if you tell someone that they are an enfranchised member of an in-group and their lived experience seems to contradict that, two things are likely to happen. First, they will tend to favor their lived experience over your carefully considered claims. Second, they will tend to discount and disregard anything further you might say, as you have damaged your credibility by invalidating their lived experiences.

So, please, consider the possibility that what one expects to be meaningful to a person's life and what that person considers meaningful to a person's life may differ in potentially significant ways.

Re:The End of Identity Liberalism by throwanem on Saturday November 19, 2016 @04:31PM (#12995805)
Sorry, I wasn't clear. My intent was precisely in accord with what you say, and I appreciate you clarifying the point in the way which I should have but did not.