It's the trouble with people making equivalences between "a particular person calling themselves an economist" and "economics". There are hundreds of thousands of people with economics degrees, it is trivially easy to find one who says what you want to hear. But then, that economist's words are often taken to reflective of economics as an entire field of study - regardless of the reasoning behind it, or how many other economists actually agree. So most economists may have totally sensible reasons for supporting Policy A, but when one dissenting economist supports Policy Not-A, the "consensus view" gets ignored. I don't know why this is. Maybe because people feel competent to judge economic reasoning in a way that they don't with other fields (and which might lead them to seek more opinions.)
As an example, I have a Computer Science degree, however I can't imagine anyone taking what I have to say about Computer Science to be reflective of the greater industry. I'm just a schmuck with a degree.
Of course this phenomenon does happen in other fields too - think of how often there's an article where "science says x!", when in reality it's just one paper with a tentative conclusion. It just seems particularly common for people to misunderstand economics.
Economists are not intentionally supporting multinationals interests over people's interests. They do so as a side effect of their belief in the correctness and practical relevance of microeconomics and neo-classical theories. This behaviour is in turn encouraged and rewarded by multinationals and investment banks, leading dissenting voices to be marginalized. Of course there are notable exceptions, Stiglitz, Krugman, Rodrik, and a few others. But the general point is that if you want to get an economics PhD from a red brick university you will have to support this viewpoint.
You highlight Stiglitz and Krugman as exceptions - but the fact that they won Nobels for their academic work suggests that economic theory itself does not directly lead to policy recommendations.
Regulation is inefficient, markets could be more efficient if they were markets with supply, demand and competition (which is clearly not the case in the emission markets at least not where I live)
> They favor open immigration policies because it brings flexibility to the job market. Leading to less job security for low skill workers and more profits for multinational companies.
This only happens if you start with an imbalanced market to begin with. If there is competition between the multinationals, then they are forced to decrease prices.
In other words, lower salaries result in lower prices which in turn benefit everybody, including and especially those low skilled workers that keep their job.
One way to make everybody richer is to decrease prices but this is basically overseen today and called the "deflation monster" even though it's a natural process due to tech advances.
> Economists are not intentionally supporting multinationals interests over people's interests. They do so as a side effect of their belief in the correctness and practical relevance of microeconomics and neo-classical theories.
Yes and these theories are IMO very misled and make no sense at all. Take even Krugman (the one I'm most familiar with) - he favors printing money to resolve an economic crisis caused by printing money. If that were the solution, we could all be rich by just printing our money and living happy ever after. See the problem?
Most economists today don't know what a market is and why it's superior, otherwise they wouldn't be in favor of a central bank. A Central bank basically practices price fixing for the market of money.
Which means that when economists have theories that fly in the face of what people believe (like pretty much all of science), people get more annoyed.
To me (like you), that suggests that GP is telling a just-so story about why we can ignore economists.
There's also the matter of the "rational actor" theory of human behavior, the a priori assumption of classical economics. It describes a being which is basically non-existent among flesh and blood humans. But corporations can form themselves in the image of this mythical economically rational being. And so, if classical economics does objectively describes the world, corporations are the uber-mensches of such a world and poised to dominate it in perpetuity - a clear incentive to capture and control the field, lest dissident economists succeed in espousing a revision of their core assumptions.
There are also interesting differences in how economists view themselves compared to other humanities, see this (biased) paper: Fourcade et al, the Superiority of Economists http://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.29.1.89 Economics tend to be a more insular and hierarchical discipline, and views itself as non-normative.
Economists broadly want to eliminate the mortgage interest deduction, corporate interest deductions, and reduce the corporate income tax, want employers to stop providing health insurance as an employment benefit (http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/tax-reform, http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/healthcare), and broadly disfavor rent control (http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/rent-control). Yet before we go off accusing economists of being right-wing shills, they also broadly want carbon taxes over income taxes (http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/carbon-taxes-ii) and favor open immigration policies (http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/high-skilled-immigrants).
None of these are particularly politically-fashionable positions to take, with the possible exception of the CIT issue, which plays well with one half of the electorate and is broadly viewed as liquid evil by the other half.