First, name-calling potshots like this don't belong in HN comments; you should be editing them out, not in. The topic is inflammatory enough without getting meta-snarky.
Second, you've broken the HN guideline that asks you not to start flamewars (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). There are interesting things—in HN's sense—that could have been discussed about this article; by posting the most predictable of all responses ("I can't help but think how the inverse would sound"), you created the most predictable of all flamewars. Then you kept it going by posting way too many comments. Flamewars should be starved, not fuelled.
I don't at all think you were ill-intentioned, but doing these things lowers the quality of discussion and makes HN the sort of place we're hoping to avoid becoming, so please don't do them here.
But they already are. These things aren't created in a vacuum where we pretend racism is already over. It would be nice if we could all forget about race, but doing so would be ignoring all the racism that has and continues to exist.
When you make an American history museum, you'll find that basically every important figure is white. Is that just random chance? Is it ok to cover your eyes and say "I'm colorblind, this is just an exhibit about the most important historical figures regardless of race"?
I'm sure you're not racist, but you can't ignore the people and institutions that still are, and you can't ignore history. Ignoring a problem doesn't make it go away.
There are exhibits on this stuff in existing American history museums, but it's a very big topic. For any historical topic, if you can fill an entire museum, trying to fit it into a few exhibits is just impractical.
Also, surely you can see the shortfalls in trying to solve today's racism with treating one race over another, right?
Surely?
Do you not think slavery, Jim Crow, civil rights, etc. is a worthwhile topic? Is it not clearly an extremely important area that deserves an entire museum, rather than a couple exhibits here and there?
And finally, imagine a hypothetical country where we enslaved black people for 100 years, and then ceased all slavery and racism completely. One day there were slaves, the next slavery is abolished and nobody is racist. Is the problem solved? Are black people now equal to everyone else? No, because history didn't disappear, they still used to be slaves. They have no money, no land, no friends in power, no education, etc. Their lives still suck, no matter how impartial everyone else is. Again, you can't solve a problem by ignoring it. Pretending black people have no disadvantages and can be treated exactly the same as white people is just naïve, and impractical. It is not racist to acknowledge existing racism, and try to counteract it. There is a line, and it's completely possible for racism to negatively affect white people, but building a black history museum does not come anywhere near that line.
Slavery was very widely popular in China, south east asia, and most notably the middle east during that era.
I've also heard there's still as many slaves today in Africa as there were in the 1800's America:
> Forced labor in Sub-Saharan Africa is estimated at 660,000. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_contemporary_Africa
Maybe it's a good thing Americans are so interested in the subject, as everywhere else that legacy, and in the case of modern Africa the reality, is not being confronted. But at the same time I feel like there are risks of seeing it as a uniquely American issue rather than a human one that the majority of the earths population's has had some connection to in the past.
The larger narrative about Jim Crow laws and state sanctioned racism in the modern era is still somewhat unique to the US though - at least in the western world.
Otherwise this is largely the consequence of America being the dominant media and news engine for the world. It gets the greatest amount of inward reflection regarding their responsibility for the guilt of past human failures.
It is undeniable that some slave-owners owned slaves in order to keep them as workers, and they weren't necessarily "mistreated" more like they were safer as slaves and couldn't be released anyway.
And what were slave-owners trying to protect slaves from? If slaves had it so good under slavery, why did thousands and thousands attempt to flee at great risk to their own life? Why did they overwhelmingly vote for the Republican Party after reconstruction, again at great cost to their own lives? Why did so many who did flee write about the evils of slavery, and campaign against it, and no free black wrote for it? All slaves were owned to extract economic value of them, they were huge capital investments.
[1]http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/celia/celiaacc...
I think it's good that some slaves were treated well, but I'm not sure how that's relevant here. They were still slaves.
That proves the reason for the existence of a black history museum then, because there are people that are overlooked. Do they not deserve to have their story told? Because that's the point of a museum.
Stating that act of creating a museum for black history is racist towards white people makes as much sense as a museum for wooden boats being an affront to the metallic boats.
It's very easy to see that there would be value in having a black history museum in a country where the majority of people are white.
You can say the same for a "white history" museum in a country where being white is not the majority. However, what you'll find is that a lot of countries have a colonial history that ties into their history significantly. Where white Europeans came along and by force conquered them.
Anyway, did you even read the article? It gives plenty of context for the museum. I don't see you arguing against it however, instead you've just latched onto it being a "Black" History museum.
You should have asked your friends why a black person can't be racist, because to most white people it's an absurd proposition. So allow me to explain a bit here.
Racism, unlike what we mostly think, is not a state of mind or an emotion. Racism is a sociological system that transcends the intentions of any one individual. In case US history is not forefront in anyone's mind: 150 years ago, a black person had the same legal status as a pig; 100 years ago, it was illegal for a white person to marry a black person; 60 years ago, it was illegal for a black person to drink at a water fountain.
Today, the likelihood that you'll be shot by a cop if you're black is astronomically higher than if you're white. If you have a black sounding name, you're less likely to have a company respond to your job application.
These things are institutional. When we say a black person can't be racist -- we don't mean they can't be prejudiced. They can, just like all people. But the privileges and paved roads that a white person enjoys simply aren't there by default for a POC, so they can't benefit from institutional racism.
TL;DR - false equivalency. "Black X Thing" is in the context of a historically disenfranchised people overcoming an entire country hellbent on keeping them disenfranchised. "White X Thing" is ridiculous because it's redundant: "Thing" is already White by default.
This is not true. Not only is there no astronomically higher probability, there is no higher probability.[1] Other studies found that officers hesitate longer before shooting an armed black suspect than they do white or Hispanic suspects.[2]
1. http://www.nber.org/papers/w22399 2. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1745-9133.12187/a...
https://www.ft.com/content/89b97964-b88a-11e5-b151-8e15c9a02...
Also I'm not driving to anything. I'm pointing out that research, as opposed to narrative, shows that blacks are not shot by police at astronomically higher rates.
This, however, is absurd. In economics, there's a crucial distinction between historical processes (e.g. accumulation of wealth or economic development) and general economic processes (e.g. the pricing of a good) in that historical processes are not mean-reverting. They're subject to certain rules (e.g. preferential attachment, positive feedbacks, increasing returns) which make them generally path dependent[0]. As a result, initial differences will perpetuate themselves for an indefinately long time.
For example, a familial lineages might remain poor or rich for an arbitrarily long time purely through inheritance. New York might remain more populous than Dallas for an undefined amount of time since the economic benefit of moving into any of those two cities is a function of their population (through economies of agglomeration[1]). And Peru might remain much poorer than the United States for an eternity, because how much capital and labor countries draw to themselves if proportional to how much innovation going on there, which is itself a function of those variables.
History, even as completely blind process, will still produce self-sustaining inequalities. But none of this has anything to do with "racism", but with the fact that the past matters and we live in a world of crucial events. In a mean-reverting world, in all likelihood, there wouldn't even be such a thing as an European colonization of America. In a sense, you might be right in thinking that non one wants all this. But calling these process a result of "racism" is beyond stretching the meaning of the word.
There's no way to maintain a reasonable expectation that different entities (nevermind races) should attain equal outcomes unless the "Just World Hypothesis" is assumed.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_dependence
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration
I think that's a rather ambitious definition of racism. Racism is the discrimination of some person/group due to their race. You are either denying that being white is a race (Caucasian more specifically), or you are denying the global definition of the word. Both are wrong.
Anyway, onto your pseudo-fact opinions, since these are always sad to see purported as facts on HN:
> Today, the likelihood that you'll be shot by a cop if you're black is astronomically higher than if you're white.
...Because black crime is 4x greater, not from any mass cop bias. False correlation. Also, "astronomical" is a totally inappropriate exaggeration. Please, look at statistics before hurling words at screens.
> so they can't benefit from institutional racism.
But, that is not even "racism". That is an expansion of the term that is not the term itself. It's irrelevant. Also, have you seen US University GPA requirements? I think you'll find that it favors POC more than anybody, and makes it hardest for Asians, then whites. So. That's not universally correct right off the bat.
> "Thing" is already White by default.
Another exaggeration.
Regardless, I definitely do disagree with your general opinion that negative past events towards POC should mean they are treated specially now. Like in another comment, don't you think that trying to "revenge" on historical racism by being racist again with opposite races, is a little, well, stupid? You can already see that it doesn't work by how dissatisfied white people are with this mindset.
Why is that? Why is it that every voice like yours stops the analysis there. "Black crime commit more crimes, end of story". Ask the 5 why's! You don't think there are institutional and socio-cultural (history driven) issues that lead to this?
You have all sorts of terrorist groups like BLM that are telling, instructing, pleading all black people to commit crimes. That's definitely not anecdotal.
Museums like this try to capture some of it. But really, America should be looking to Truth and Reconciliation commission type of platforms that has worked in other places. Finish what was started in the Reconstruction-era, or continue to suffer from this wound.
That's actually false and it's an impression being carried out by the media. When interacting with the police, you are more like to to be shot if you are white than if you are black.
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/12/upshot/surprising-new-evid...
They're looking at P(shot|stopped by police and white) and P(shot|stopped by police and black) not P(shot by police|black) and P(shot by police|white).
Have you been to a museum?
If everything you know about black people is from the internet, TV, rap music, and pop culture in general, you are missing a lot of what being black in America is really about, and at how much interesting culture and history there is in black communities.
The black history museum is not supposed to represent the "parent country" it's supposed to represent black people in America. A white history museum would do the same.
That seems surprisingly narrow minded and makes me wonder whether you feel that there is a particular narrative that needs to be followed. European/white descended people and organizations have done some pretty amazing stuff in Africa. And continue to do so.
One might ask how much time must pass after an event before it is considered history? Given that the Smithsonian African-American includes sections on Barack Obama and Anita Hill, as well as photos and memorabilia relating to sports stars, including LeBron James, it seems that the necessary time must be quite brief. As such I would expect an honest White History Museum in Africa would include the many significant positives.
Believe it or not, there is a coherent shared cultural identity of American black people, most of whom are descended from slaves brought here from Africa who had their original cultures stripped from them, and who belonged to a community segregated against legally into the 1970s. That those people came from several different countries on the continent of Africa is of little meaning, because their culture was deliberately cut off from its roots, and was built largely anew in the United States.
Your inclination is to assume that if "black culture" is a thing, then "white culture" must also be a thing. No, that is not the case. What there is in addition to "black culture" is:
* Irish-American culture, which has a museum, parades, and a holiday,
* Italian-American culture, which has a museum, parades, and a holiday,
* German-American culture, which has a museum and parades,
* Polish-American culture, which has a museum, parades, and a holiday
I can go on.
The notion that there is some notional "white culture" is artificial, a lie begun in earnest in the 20th century. No, really. Before "white culture", the Anglo- and Germanic-American communities in the US targeted Italians, the Irish, and the Polish (as well as Catholics of all nationalities). When the writing appeared on the wall for end of Jim Crow, "white culture" emerged as a solidarity movement among those people prejudiced against blacks and black culture.
This is a big part of why talking about "white history museums" generates so much flak. It's ahistorical, doesn't make much cultural sense (the Irish and Germans do not in fact have a huge overlap in music, art, language, or food), but is very much connected to 20th century racism. It's an Occam's Razor problem: the simplest thing to conclude someone would be talking about with a "white history museum" is racism.
People can hardly be blamed for wondering aloud about this stuff. After all: practically every government form you fill out asks your race, and has "white" as an option. These forms aren't all designed to perpetuate racism --- in fact, most of the forms that offer you the option of declaring yourself "white" have the opposite intention. But the concept of "whiteness" actually does derive from racism (again: the concept of "Irish-Americanness" does not!), and while the concept of "blackness" does as well, black people really do have an important, coherent, complex, historically rich culture built inside that racist framework we forced them into.
Worth checking out, also because it's just kind of amazing that you can: the Baldwin/Buckley debate:
For some reason it excludes Egypt, big part of South America and other African countries ;-)
And, okay, to really shut this one down, what would you say to a "White History Museum" in Africa? That's a real exception to your hypothesis!
Who has the authority to establish that threshold? Seems quite arbitrary and problematic. White History Museum in South Africa? What about Zambia? DRC? All have a white historical presence, and in places like Zimbabwe, an argument could be made that the culture has suffered a certain persecution (I am not taking a side on this argument here).
Black history museums are interesting because they offer an insight into the achievements of a transplant group in a country where they are a minority. It's not really about their history prior to immigrating. It's about their history after they've gotten into this new country, and the story of their integration.
I don't think it has anything to do with race, it's a cultural thing - groups that identified with a common history in a strange land.
For example, in the UK, despite being also predominantly white, I'm sure there would be a remit for a polish history museum, or even an irish history musuem.
You seem not to be aware that these things exist. They very much do. African-American museums celebrate the community of Americans descended, primarily, from people brought here as slaves from Africa. They have an immense shared culture and heritage, stemming in large part from the way the law of this country segregated them until just a few decades ago, and thus have a cultural identity here more coherent than those of (say) Irish-Americans (who do indeed have a museum, and most of whom couldn't name 3 cities in Ireland or tell you what Gaelic is).
b) If you read past the headlines into the correlation and probability theory of each study, you'll find that the reason why there is the difference is because of education and lower ambitions and goals of black people. You could say there is no real racism, only perceived racism, which then mentally affects the perceiever, and dissaudes them from getting better qualifications and therefore worse job prospects.
That is not in itself racism. That is a false perception of reality ends up affecting reality later on. I think it's called the self-fulfillment fallacy.
The social sciences suffer massive publication bias. Results ranging from failure of the study to support the hypothesis to the gathered data having being politically incorrect lead to research being abandoned.