News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:22AM (#12967681)
> There should be no reason that "Black X thing" and "White X thing" should be perceived any differently

But they already are. These things aren't created in a vacuum where we pretend racism is already over. It would be nice if we could all forget about race, but doing so would be ignoring all the racism that has and continues to exist.

When you make an American history museum, you'll find that basically every important figure is white. Is that just random chance? Is it ok to cover your eyes and say "I'm colorblind, this is just an exhibit about the most important historical figures regardless of race"?

I'm sure you're not racist, but you can't ignore the people and institutions that still are, and you can't ignore history. Ignoring a problem doesn't make it go away.

Re:A Black History Museum by kj01a on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:09PM (#12969026)
So the answer is more racism and segregation?? If we want inclusion, why not build an exhibit that includes all races? Or why wasn't this exhibit added to the already existing one? How can these two exhibits be equal to one another if they are separate from one another?
Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:18PM (#12969132)
We have many museums and exhibits that include all races. And I imagine this one does too, although I haven't been there yet. You can't talk about slavery and civil rights without talking about white people, in both negative and positive roles.

There are exhibits on this stuff in existing American history museums, but it's a very big topic. For any historical topic, if you can fill an entire museum, trying to fit it into a few exhibits is just impractical.

Re:A Black History Museum by SamUK96 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:34AM (#12967798)
But read my reply further. I'm okay and I'm sure most are with an "African Museum", or something like that. That museum would be dominated by POC, just like an "American History Museum" would be dominated by White people. It's not racist. It's history.

Also, surely you can see the shortfalls in trying to solve today's racism with treating one race over another, right?

Surely?

Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:43AM (#12967915)
Highlighting black people does not place them "over" anyone. We are not replacing another museum with this one. There are plenty of African exhibits in the Natural History museum and elsewhere and those are great, but it's not the same.

Do you not think slavery, Jim Crow, civil rights, etc. is a worthwhile topic? Is it not clearly an extremely important area that deserves an entire museum, rather than a couple exhibits here and there?

And finally, imagine a hypothetical country where we enslaved black people for 100 years, and then ceased all slavery and racism completely. One day there were slaves, the next slavery is abolished and nobody is racist. Is the problem solved? Are black people now equal to everyone else? No, because history didn't disappear, they still used to be slaves. They have no money, no land, no friends in power, no education, etc. Their lives still suck, no matter how impartial everyone else is. Again, you can't solve a problem by ignoring it. Pretending black people have no disadvantages and can be treated exactly the same as white people is just naïve, and impractical. It is not racist to acknowledge existing racism, and try to counteract it. There is a line, and it's completely possible for racism to negatively affect white people, but building a black history museum does not come anywhere near that line.

Re:A Black History Museum by dmix on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:21AM (#12968429)
Considering the US wasn't the only country with slavery, I'm curious if other countries have museums dedicated to the subject? It seems whenever someone brings up slavery everyone automatically thinks of America.

Slavery was very widely popular in China, south east asia, and most notably the middle east during that era.

I've also heard there's still as many slaves today in Africa as there were in the 1800's America:

> Forced labor in Sub-Saharan Africa is estimated at 660,000. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_contemporary_Africa

Maybe it's a good thing Americans are so interested in the subject, as everywhere else that legacy, and in the case of modern Africa the reality, is not being confronted. But at the same time I feel like there are risks of seeing it as a uniquely American issue rather than a human one that the majority of the earths population's has had some connection to in the past.

The larger narrative about Jim Crow laws and state sanctioned racism in the modern era is still somewhat unique to the US though - at least in the western world.

Otherwise this is largely the consequence of America being the dominant media and news engine for the world. It gets the greatest amount of inward reflection regarding their responsibility for the guilt of past human failures.

Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:27AM (#12968513)
I agree, slavery should be documented and confronted everywhere. I do think other countries have museums, which is good. There's a fairly well known one called House of Slaves in Senegal, for example. I'm sure there are many more elsewhere.
Re:A Black History Museum by SamUK96 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:03AM (#12968196)
But, do you think that black people really still suffer from such "post-racist-society" effects nowadays, like in your hypothetical country? I doubt.
Re:A Black History Museum by pj_mukh on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:17AM (#12968380)
Great question! Why don't we ask Black people? :) After all there isn't really an "objective" measure of oppression, its simply the sum total of people's experience, which museums like this try to capture.
Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:20AM (#12968417)
Yes, I do. This is easy to see with studies of job applications, loan applications, etc. We don't have to guess.
Re:A Black History Museum by michaelbuddy on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:08AM (#12968257)
you forget given all the race mixing done during the period of slavery, there were plenty of people from the beginning of slavery that really just did these things because it was part of culture. Many many african americans have european blood in them. And many of them are descendents of people who were in loving yet secretive relationships.

It is undeniable that some slave-owners owned slaves in order to keep them as workers, and they weren't necessarily "mistreated" more like they were safer as slaves and couldn't be released anyway.

Re:A Black History Museum by aomurphy on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:46AM (#12968743)
And many were raped. Repeatedly. In a culture where this was thought of as normal. How can a relationship be consensual and loving when one partner literally has the right to order the other, to harm the other in any way, to literally kill the other? If there were so many consensual and secret relationships, why did white slave owners talk so openly about rape of black women (and white women actually, read William Byrd Carter II's diary, it's a shocking horrible thing), and speak so strongly against any sort of liason between white women and black men? Black slaves lived in a world where killing your rapist would get you found guilty [1]. Surely there were some loving relationships (people are diverse), but just as surely the majority were not.

And what were slave-owners trying to protect slaves from? If slaves had it so good under slavery, why did thousands and thousands attempt to flee at great risk to their own life? Why did they overwhelmingly vote for the Republican Party after reconstruction, again at great cost to their own lives? Why did so many who did flee write about the evils of slavery, and campaign against it, and no free black wrote for it? All slaves were owned to extract economic value of them, they were huge capital investments.

[1]http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/celia/celiaacc...

Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:24AM (#12968472)
This is kind of a weird comment. Racism and prejudice work off of skin color, not DNA. Having "European blood" does not help you. Having "loving" ancestors is not helpful either.

I think it's good that some slaves were treated well, but I'm not sure how that's relevant here. They were still slaves.

Re:A Black History Museum by legodt on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:39AM (#12967862)
This opinion is extremely naive and ignorant. White people controlled history through imperialism and colonialism for centuries, and the histories were all written by white people. Of course all the other museums feature white people only, because in the western world white people were the dominant, oppressive class. It is important to preserve these stories and histories that would have otherwise been lost in a white narrative
Re:A Black History Museum by mooseburger on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:46AM (#12967955)
While I agree that these stories and histories are worth preserving, I would rather they were integrated into current historical accounts and current museums, creating more complete picture, rather than the racial segregationist approach this museum represents.
Re:A Black History Museum by legodt on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:49AM (#12967999)
Fair, but there is a lot of institutional racism in the art world and academia, so progress on these counts is extremely slow moving. Also, some would argue that as a result of how history is written, that it is important to have black owned institutions with black curation because the narratives and histories between black and white Americans is so vast that it is important that black people get to control their narrative and history to prevent cultural erasure. A post racial world is ideal, but simply not possible
Re:A Black History Museum by mooseburger on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:08AM (#12968268)
My concern with this approach is that it seems it will only keep old resentments alive, as opposed to celebrating their culture. If every nation, race, and culture in the world held on to every atrocity committed against them, the planet would be covered in perpetual war...
Re:A Black History Museum by michaelbuddy on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:10AM (#12974810)
There's definitely a lot of institutional racism in academia. Outright favoritism for people of color for no other reason than their skin color. In Admissions programs, hiring practices, scholarships as well as many instances during normal campus life. Campuses go out of their way to not be racist to the point where they are racist. Absolutely ridiculous. And it really hurts the self-esteem of people to be given special treatment b/c of their color.
Re:A Black History Museum by burkaman on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:04AM (#12968207)
I think that's just kind of impractical. There are slavery and civil rights exhibits in American history museums, but the full topic is just too expansive for a couple exhibits. It's the same concept of having a Thomas Jefferson museum, or a suffragette movement museum, or any individual topic.
Re:A Black History Museum by Jonnax on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:33AM (#12968581)
So you're saying that standard museums of history are majority white in the US/UK and that is fine because it's the truth.

That proves the reason for the existence of a black history museum then, because there are people that are overlooked. Do they not deserve to have their story told? Because that's the point of a museum.

Stating that act of creating a museum for black history is racist towards white people makes as much sense as a museum for wooden boats being an affront to the metallic boats.

It's very easy to see that there would be value in having a black history museum in a country where the majority of people are white.

You can say the same for a "white history" museum in a country where being white is not the majority. However, what you'll find is that a lot of countries have a colonial history that ties into their history significantly. Where white Europeans came along and by force conquered them.

Anyway, did you even read the article? It gives plenty of context for the museum. I don't see you arguing against it however, instead you've just latched onto it being a "Black" History museum.

Re:A Black History Museum by alooackbar on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:41AM (#12967884)
There already is a White Museum. It celebrates empire and it's called the British Museum.