Presumably the experience at management level (i.e. the price - you get what you pay for) made up for it, or they wouldn't sell anything. (Admittedly, if the drivers just work then documentation is less important, too. Compare to other fields like the state of Linux GPU drivers. I wouldn't say Broadcom drivers are without problems, though :-)
However, I think a lot of issues was due to documentation not being written at all (or being in very bad shape).
The BCM283x series has a good mix of features, but it is far from being the only solution for set-top boxes.
For example, if you want a full-featured chip for building an AP, there's maybe three companies capable of giving you one - Atheros, BCM, and Marvell. And that last only sells to Cisco. So you're stuck between two companies with drivers that are awful in slightly different ways, and only a year into working with one or the other do you discover the firmware bugs.
If you want previous-generation-equivalent chips there are more suppliers available, and some of them probably have decent drivers, but they're uncommon in developed-country markets.
Price, performance, availability, driver quality, etc may look competitive to the competition and affect a few million users.
If you sell a few million of these, saving 5 cents on the Wifi chip pays at least for 2 engineers full-time to deal with whatever issues Broadcom gives you.
It may still make sense if the maintenance burden is high and upstreaming has benefits, but that's not always the case.
.... and that's what I spent cumulatively about a year of my life on. Ugh.
Mind you, Broadcom doesn't care about this at all — I was never a significant customer volume-wise for them, and as you wrote this is their strategy. They simply will not work with small companies.
[0] http://articles.latimes.com/2008/jun/06/business/fi-nicholas...
Just to see an scant datasheet for their old BLE chip one needed to the following.
1. Contact a Broadcom Sales rep. Ask if they are willing to sell to you. 2. Sales Rep then comes to your office with a PPT and makes a presentation clearly aimed at Management. Sales rep tries to understand your business and volume. If you pass a magic test, then you are now qualified to buy their product. 3. Sales Rep then asks who in your team will work on BLE. Takes their email addresses, phone numbers. 4. Sales Rep enables doc access. The team member gets an email and then can access datasheet for exactly that one single part. Plus that datasheet is watermarked that it's to be read by only that specific team member.
And no, this isn't 1995. Plus, if you want to change parts or explore a different part, you can't. Before Cypress bought BRCM's IoT business, if you had a problem with anything, the standard answer was - use WICED. BRCM's docs sucked so bad that they even hid information about UART and I2C. Think about it for a moment. Imagine buying a chip and you don't get programming information about UART and I2C. Instead you have to believe that WICED magically solves every problem.
Cypress buying and opening up BRCM's documentation is the best thing that's happened to documenting those parts and supporting customers who are small, medium volume.