News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by elchief on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:18PM (#12924458)
Apple, maybe, actually fights for your privacy, while Lenovo definitely exploits it for money.

Is there a secure enclave chip in Lenovo? Do you really trust their firmware?

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by cyrus_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:23PM (#12924504)
Lenovo's malware scandal should certainly give you pause, but do note that it was only installed on its consumer laptops. Thinkpads were unaffected.

Moreover, Apple is far from the cleanly ethical choice you seem to think it is. It blocks or impedes the installation of software that it has unilaterally decided is against its interests + takes a ludicrous percentage of revenue via the App Store.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by voidlogic on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:26PM (#12924541)
>Lenovo's malware scandal should certainly give you pause, but do note that it was only installed on its consumer laptops. Thinkpads were unaffected.

And would not matter if you were installing Linux per this thread...

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by vardump on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:47PM (#12924728)
Operating system doesn't matter much when the malware is in BIOS or firmware code.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by tinus_hn on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:21PM (#12925604)
The 'malware' used a Windows misfeature that allows the BIOS to supply an executable that is run during startup. So the malware was in the firmware but only runs on Windows.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by voidlogic on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:48PM (#12925300)
>Operating system doesn't matter much when the malware is in BIOS or firmware code.

Are you insinuating that was the case here? Source please, I'd be interested to read about that.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by Figs on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:28PM (#12925672)
Here are three news articles on what happened:

http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/08/lenovo...

http://www.techrepublic.com/article/windows-and-uefi-anti-th...

http://www.pcworld.com/article/2969365/security/lenovos-serv...

This should really only affect Windows systems as far as I know -- Windows is running an executable stored in the firmware at boot (a rather dubious feature, in my opinion, but it's intended as an anti-theft measure). Lenovo used that feature to try to circumvent removal of their crapware when someone reinstalls the OS.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by vardump on Friday November 11, 2016 @12:28AM (#12928212)
For example SMM (system management mode) code is certainly loaded and executed under any operating system. You have to just trust the mainboard vendor.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_Management_Mode

I'm not insinuating anything. All I know is that Lenovo broke our collective trust before, thinking they can get away with it.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by voltagex_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:10PM (#12925494)
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by betanumerical on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:38PM (#12925771)
It gets copied from the firmware and runs pre OS. But the executable only runs on windows from what I can tell, so its technically its cross platform but it wont run on both platforms.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by pritambaral on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:25PM (#12927362)
The executable runs on Windows because Windows loads it and runs it. The executable doesn't force itself on Windows.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by eridius on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:52PM (#12924776)
> It blocks or impedes the installation of software that it has unilaterally decided is against its interests

What software are you thinking of? Apple maintains editorial control over what's in the App Store, but I can't think of any case where Apple has blocked software distributed outside the app store. The closest I can think of is the fact that the default settings of the computer require apps to be codesigned with an Apple certificate, but Apple doesn't maintain editorial control over who gets certificates, anyone with a developer account can get one (and of course you can even bypass this requirement with right click -> Open, or by changing the security settings on the computer).

> takes a ludicrous percentage of revenue via the App Store

The App Store is completely optional. All software that's published on it can be distributed outside of it. And I don't see how the percentage Apple takes from their completely optional App Store is even remotely connected with ethics.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by loopbit on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:43PM (#12925251)
> by changing the security settings on the computer

Sierra has disabled the "install from any source" option (although you can re-enable it with some terminal magic). How long until they disable the identified developers option too and leave a system like the iphone?

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by tinus_hn on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:38PM (#12925762)
If the user cannot be trusted to make reasonable choices because he doesn't understand or want to read security popups, you have to make the choice for them. That's what Apple is doing and so is Microsoft. It's the only way to go if you want a secure system. And guess what: people appreciate a stable, secure system that makes it difficult to distribute malware. They appreciate it more than fear-mongering about theoretical issues.

Apple is never going to completely lock down the Mac because it can't be a development platform if it is locked down. Besides, why would they even want to?

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by jpetso on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:52PM (#12926723)
> If the user cannot be trusted to make reasonable choices because he doesn't understand or want to read security popups, you have to make the choice for them.

I would bring up a libertarian argument to counter this view, but unfortunately I don't politically lean that way do it wouldn't be authentic. Somebody definitely should make that point, though.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by userbinator on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:05PM (#12927651)
Somebody definitely should make that point, though.

Like Richard Stallman?

https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by eridius on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:06PM (#12926437)
> How long until they disable the identified developers option too and leave a system like the iphone?

Never. That would literally kill the platform. And nothing Apple has done has indicated that they even want to go this route. For example, against all expectations, they haven't been expanding the set of sandbox exemptions for apps, which means there are still large classes of apps that cannot be distributed on the App Store as they need functionality that isn't available in the sandbox.

Removing the "disable Gatekeeper" option from the UI does not indicate that Apple wants to force everybody on the App Store, it means that Apple wants everybody to codesign their apps. But, as you already mentioned, you can easily re-enable it from the CLI, and anyone who isn't capable of finding out how to do that is almost certainly not qualified to judge the security implications of making that change.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by nicky0 on Friday November 11, 2016 @03:36AM (#12928964)
Actually they haven't. You can still install from any source by right clicking and choosing Open.

Also one of Sierra's new features is adding support for non-MAS apps to use iCloud features. If they were planning to freeze out non-MAS apps, why would they do that?

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by cyrus_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:57PM (#12925937)
An Apple developer account costs $99/year.

The ethical problem on macOS is that Apple is imposing artificial technical barriers to push people to pay Apple what amounts to "protection" money.

On iOS, there is no reasonable way to bypass the app store for the vast majority of users.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by eridius on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:13PM (#12926475)
The fact that you apparently don't understand the security implications here and the reasons why Apple is pushing for codesigning does not mean that Apple is putting up artificial barriers out of greed. That's a pretty ludicrous claim - do you really think the $99/year Apple gets from developers (who aren't already paying for iOS) even registers as a blip on their balance sheets?

The next time you see something you don't understand, your automatic reaction shouldn't be "those greedy bastards", it should be to actually educate yourself as to why it's being done. You may find that in a lot of cases there are actually really good reasons for it. And even if you decide that you don't agree with the reasons, that doesn't make it appropriate to accuse someone of being greedy or doing "evil" things (e.g. artificial technology barriers to extract money), and it's rather offensive for you to do that.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by imtringued on Friday November 11, 2016 @03:13AM (#12928873)
$99 every year is enough to be a barrier to entry for individuals but low enough to for malicious actors to obtain the ability to sign code.

It doesn't matter how much it costs. Even if it only costs $0.01 a year it would offer the same level of protection.

The only thing the fee does is limit the number of developer certificates to one per bank account.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by cyrus_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:08PM (#12926817)
I suspect it is you that doesn't understand the security implications -- if all it takes is $99/year to gain the ability to sign arbitrary code, then there is no security benefit whatsoever. Pure security theater.

Obviously, the $99/year isn't making Apple a lot of money. But what it is doing is creating a culture of acceptance around Apple-as-gatekeeper. The iOS app store is most certainly making Apple a non-trivial amount of money (yes I know its a small percentage of their total at the moment.)

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by megablast on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:43PM (#12924686)
> takes a ludicrous percentage of revenue via the App Store.

Do you know what it was before the Apple App store came along? You were handing over about 70-80%, and that was if you could convince a publisher to take your app, which was a very hard sell.

Then Apple came along offering EVERYONE the ability to publish apps, and at a very reasonable cost.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by mikeash on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:19PM (#12925042)
You could throw up a web site and an online store and sell directly for nothing close to that. If you used a full-featured sales service, you might pay 8%. If you put in the work to run your own store that works with a merchant account, you could get it down to maybe 3%.

The alternative to the App Store isn't selling through a huge publisher who takes a huge cut, it's selling directly and keeping almost all of the money.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by cyrus_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:48PM (#12925860)
No, then _the internet_ came along, offering EVERYONE the ability to publish apps, at an actually very reasonable cost.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by givinguflac on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:49PM (#12924743)
Please provide one example of Apple blocking an application from running on MacOS. What's that, you don't have an example? Because this is false.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by cyrus_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:47PM (#12925850)
First off, I didn't say that Apple was blocking apps on MacOS. I mentioned it because the OP was disparaging Lenovo as a whole because of unethical behavior in one product line. As such, it's only fair to do the same for Apple.

Second, Apple most definitely does "impede" the installation of apps downloaded independently by requiring you to perform an obscure dance to execute them.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by rarepostinlurkr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:06PM (#12926434)
> "It blocks or impedes the installation of software ..."

You didn't?

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by cyrus_ on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:16PM (#12927305)
You're aware that iPhones and iPads run software I assume.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by nicky0 on Friday November 11, 2016 @03:41AM (#12928990)
You only have to to the "right click and Open" dance if app is unsigned.

Even for unsigned apps, I don't thing two clicks instead of one is all that obscure.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by gruez on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:20PM (#12924473)
I don't see how that's a relevant point if you're going to do a fresh install anyways, unless you think lenovo is going to use something like vpro to spy on you without the OS.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by givinguflac on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:43PM (#12924690)
They do. They've modified BIOS in the past to keep the spyware going.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by jkestner on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:22PM (#12924495)
You're funding spyware, even if it's not on your own computer.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by gruez on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:30PM (#12924582)
if you're referring to the superfish scandal, that piece of software wasn't developed by lenovo, it was developed by a third party, who paid lenovo to install it on their windows images. so i don't see how buying lenovo is "funding spyware".
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by tedunangst on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:46PM (#12924714)
More like Lenovo is taxing spyware, if you're going to install something other than Windows. Superfish only loses money on that transaction.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by jkestner on Friday November 11, 2016 @01:27AM (#12928462)
Well, that makes me feel better. Let me rephrase: By buying Lenovo, you're supporting a company that exchanges the privacy and security of unwitting customers for profit.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by na85 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:38PM (#12924654)
It goes both ways. By buying Apple you're funding walled gardens and anti-choice design patterns, abusive labor practices including child labor and sweatshop conditions at their prime contractors, and collusion with NSA et al via PRISM.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by givinguflac on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:46PM (#12924719)
This comment is just ridiculous. Apple does more than ANY manufacturer to improve working and supply chain conditions, anywhere, and most OEMs use the same facilities so blaming Apple specifically is doubly silly. How is the Mac even close to a walled garden or anti choice??? They allow Windows and any app you want to be installed.. What are you talking about? And please, do provide a source for your "collusion with NSA" accusation as every other statement and action by Apple shows the opposite.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by na85 on Friday November 11, 2016 @09:28PM (#12936246)
Wow bud, sorry to have insulted your favourite company.

They did in fact participate in PRISM, sorry to get you so worked up.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by xorxornop on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:05PM (#12924912)
Hmm, let's see: can't run OSX and variants thereof except on Apple hardware (despite acceptable to flawless hardware compatibility), can't build software for OSX and variants thereof except on a Mac (despite being perfectly workable), can't use a different app store on iOS...
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by rarepostinlurkr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:17PM (#12926492)
Wasn't this very post about clear hardware incompatibilities with the latest laptops and linux? Despite appearing to be the same, it's clearly not, otherwise it would simply 'just work'.

The idea that a constrained team spent the time to intentionally 'break' some 'standard' functionality to prohibit linux from working is laughable as well.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by grzm on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:43PM (#12924684)
I'm not arguing a defense of Apple here. Honest question: Are there differences between computer manufacturers in these regards that you're aware of?
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by 234dd57d2c8db on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:13PM (#12924983)
Err, Apple was a willing participant in the NSA's PRISM program.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by rarepostinlurkr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:18PM (#12926500)
Someone adding a companies name to a slide is not proof of being a willing participant in anything.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by 234dd57d2c8db on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:37PM (#12926987)
Alright, why don't you tell me all the proof you have that Apple was not a participant in the programme?

The NSA talks about them in internal documents, that they have absolutely zero incentive to lie on, that Apple is a part of PRISM. Why would the NSA lie about that on an internal document.

Don't you think there would be documents saying "We tried to get Apple to cooperate, but they didn't. Until they do, these are the steps, techniques, and hacks we will use against their technology." I don't remember seeing any such documents.

Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by discordance on Friday November 11, 2016 @02:09AM (#12928633)
My guess is most of the companies (Yahoo excluded) on the PRISM slide were not complicit with the PRISM or the NSA. More likely, they were pwned by the NSA without their knowing.
Re:Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux by orthecreedence on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:40PM (#12927474)
As much as I dislike Apple, I actually really doubt they were willing.