Re:Don’t talk to aliens, warns Stephen Hawking
by andreyf on Sunday April 25, 2010 @03:10AM
(#1292318)
On the other hand, should we encounter sentient life, it certainly is not difficult to imagine hostility or callous indifference
Just because we can imagine something doesn't make it at all possible. We're speculating the probability of something having seen it occur once...
Re:Don’t talk to aliens, warns Stephen Hawking
by koanarc on Sunday April 25, 2010 @04:09AM
(#1292383)
So we should not speculate at all? That's a rather dull outlook.
I certainly agree that our dataset, re: "life as we know it", is horribly limited. Likely to the point of uselessness. But hypotheses are the foundation of any science, after all, and what little we do have to go on suggests that competition/predation, rather than cooperation/symbiosis, may be a more reasonable expectation.
But perhaps not. In which case, we'd be very lucky to encounter such an enlightened species.
And yet if you get struck by lightning, you'll probably start being afraid of storms, despite the vanishingly small chance of being struck twice.
Re:Don’t talk to aliens, warns Stephen Hawking
by Psyonic on Sunday April 25, 2010 @03:26AM
(#1292341)
Actually, after you've been struck by lightning once, your chance of getting struck by lightning again is the same as getting struck by lightning in the first place.
Depends on how you got struck :).
On the other hand, should we encounter sentient life, it certainly is not difficult to imagine hostility or callous indifference -- from either party. Particularly if said encounter is not on our terms.
And as profoundly exciting as the prospect of meeting alien life would be, I'd much rather it occur sometime after we've grown up a bit, ourselves.