News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by zwegner on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:45PM (#12913907)
First off, when did "blockchain" become an uncountable noun? "blockchains" or "blockchain technology" sounds much more natural.

Anyways, I wish more people in the media would differentiate between the Merkel tree, providing the immutable ledger part, and the proof-of-work distributed consensus algorithm, which provides some degree of trust through burning an ever-increasing amount of power. Most of the benefits the author lists would be true of just the Merkel tree without needing the wasteful proof-of-work consensus system, if it's used between trusted parties. Also, even if there's not complete trust, it would still provide an audit trail so that appropriate actions could be taken against bad actors.

When the author later talks about governance boards, that just underscores the incongruity even more. While I'm sure governance boards could be shoehorned into some DAO-like system over distributed consensus, it seems a lot easier to just get rid of the whole distributed consensus altogether and give some digital signatures to the governance board that can sign/bless the Merkel tree.

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by grubles on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:01PM (#12916679)
>First off, when did "blockchain" become an uncountable noun?

When the businessmen/marketers/cryptocurrency-illiterate got their hands on it and tried to distance themselves from the only useful blockchain in existence: the Bitcoin blockchain.

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by countingteeth on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:54PM (#12916993)
You've overcounted useful blockchain (lol) by one.
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by kylebenzle on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:03AM (#12920409)
LoL, as I sit here trading $10s of thousands online with no permission from any government or depending on a private company I need to trust. Your pound, dollar and yuan dropping like rocks, yeh, lol is right!
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by tdb7893 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:57PM (#12922607)
Yeah but that's the problem with bitcoin. It seems to be mainly just a speculative currency.
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by Animats on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:11PM (#12914160)
Most of the benefits the author lists would be true of just the Merkel tree without needing the wasteful proof-of-work consensus system, if it's used between trusted parties.

The parties don't have to be trusted. It's the opposite. A good blockchain needs mutually mistrustful parties who are not anonymous. If somebody tries to tamper with the ledger, all the other parties can easily tell who did it. It takes collusion of all parties to change history invisibly. Thus, you want parties who are not entirely cooperative.

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by EdHominem on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:19PM (#12914771)
> The parties don't have to be trusted.

Actually, zwenger was right. Without a proof of work, they do.

What's a blockchain? It's a data structure with a cryptographically strong CRC mechanism. But there's nothing stopping me from writing a new set of data into a new chain and passing it off as the original.

Sure, you may notice, but you can't prove my new chain is forged. I'll say the backup chain you're using as proof is the forgery...

It takes a proof of work to make the chain effectively uneditable. (Uneditable without paying for the work, which has been selected to be too expensive to be practical.)

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by schoen on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:34PM (#12916882)
> Sure, you may notice, but you can't prove my new chain is forged. I'll say the backup chain you're using as proof is the forgery...

If the items in the chain have digital signatures, you can prove that the people they're signed by contradicted themselves (or lost control of their signing keys). In Bitcoin people have felt that this wasn't good enough by itself, perhaps because there's not necessarily recourse against a counterparty who double-spends money, but you can still show that the double-spend attempt happened and who (in the sense of a signing key/address) was responsible for it.

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by EdHominem on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:03AM (#12918109)
If the signatures are enough, you don't need the chain. If the signatures aren't enough, you need the chain and a proof of work.
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by zmanian on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:57AM (#12918550)
You can use a "blockchain", an enforcer of security deposit against double spending rather than as the raw double spend prevention mechanism.[0]

[0] https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/1033

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by schoen on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:59PM (#12923146)
"Soothly we live in mighty years!"

It looks like the underlying mechanism that they use for this was described in

https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?doid=2810103.2813686

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by schoen on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:49AM (#12918518)
I'll try to think of a counterexample, but your observation may well be right in all or almost all cases.
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by kushti on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:23PM (#12914808)
"A good blockchain needs mutually mistrustful parties who are not anonymous" - in opposite, blockchain is a good solution for open system with anonymous participants. For other settings, there are more efficient solutions(e.g. PBFTs)
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by wmf on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:25PM (#12915354)
PBFT is considered blockchain now.
Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by paulcole on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:20PM (#12917431)
>First off, when did "blockchain" become an uncountable noun? "blockchains" or "blockchain technology" sounds much more natural.

Good to see we're focusing on what matters.

Re:How Blockchain Will Change Your Life by dozzie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:13AM (#12919166)
You may want to revise your view on who invented the data structure. It wasn't Merkel (Angela?), it was Ralph Merkle. You use incorrect name too consistently for it to be just a typo.