There are notable ceasefires still in effect in the middle east, eastern europe, and asia that have been going on for years (if not tens of years).
Of course, ceasefires, like medication for a psychological illness, are merely a treatment of symptoms and not a cure for the cause. But they do create stable living conditions for the civilians in an area.
And, perhaps equally as importantly, they open up the opportunity for diplomacy to find that cure that will lead to a longer, more lasting peace.
I'm not saying ceasefires are great but there are plenty of examples where ceasefire treaties have ended wars. The dataset is extremely skewed.
_glorified ceasefire with a Nuclear Power!_
So I hope that one works..
I don't mean to make any assumptions about the politics of the parent here (and apologies if this paints you in an unreasonable light), but personally, Israel is the last example I would use for successful cease fires[0]
[0] one of many examples, hopefully this one is non-partisan enough: http://carnegieendowment.org/sada/54341?lang=en
Because some of Israel's ceasefires have not been successful the successful ones shouldn't be used as examples of successful ceasefires? I'm not sure I follow the logic there....
This makes a lot of sense.
Extremely good defense stops wars before they start.
What on earth was the author of this article thinking?
If you filter your dataset to failed ceasefires, why would anyone expect it to show that they work?
What I think the data the author used shows is "Of the ceasefires that failed, it would have generally been better not to have had a ceasefire at all".
Which is an entirely different thing from "You shouldn't try to have ceasefires at all."