News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by kleigenfreude on Sunday November 06, 2016 @08:14AM (#12884921)
I'm still waiting on the Flybo Total Electric, a 4-speed manual electric car:

http://auto.indavideo.hu/video/En_ettol_felek

Seriously though, think of all of the additional torque you could get with a quad motor Tesla and a clutch. Electric manufacturers are wimping out by saying it's enough already, and it would be hella fun.

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by JshWright on Sunday November 06, 2016 @08:28AM (#12884957)
For some niche "fun" car, sure. For a mass market vehicle, they would be nuts to increase the number of moving parts by a factor of 4 or 5.
Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by kleigenfreude on Sunday November 06, 2016 @09:34AM (#12885226)
The reason that carmakers dropped manual was not the number of moving parts or that they wore out quicker. If anything, the car wearing out faster sells more cars and service. Instead, it was because not enough customers wanted manual:

http://www.autoguide.com/auto-news/2015/02/why-lamborghini-t...

For a more in-depth analysis of this, see:

https://www.quora.com/Why-is-the-market-for-manual-transmiss...

However, there are still many that prefer manual, despite things potentially wearing out more quickly. And- you don't have to design a clutch that allows the driver to wear out things more quickly. You could still allow the driver to select the level of torque but only adjust for that in a way that would not cause damage.

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by JshWright on Sunday November 06, 2016 @01:24PM (#12886337)
This is not a manual vs automatic situation. It's "multiple gear ratio transmission with a clutch, etc" vs "single fixed gear ratio". The fact that electric motors have their highest torque at extremely low RPMs, which falls over fairly linearly as power increases means that multi-speed transmissions simply aren't necessary.

Why add a bunch of unnecessary complexity? It's just more stuff to break (not to mention more up front cost).

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by kleigenfreude on Sunday November 06, 2016 @02:26PM (#12886607)
> Why add a bunch of unnecessary complexity?

1. By adding an additional lower gear to an electric truck/4x4, it could provide even more torque at low gears to allow it to carry more load and go up steeper inclines.

2. By adding an additional higher gear to a car, it could go faster and accelerate faster at the top RPM end(s). For example, see how the acceleration drops quickly. That wouldn't happen if you were to keep switching to higher gears:

http://static4.consumerreportscdn.org/content/dam/cro/news_a...

The reason they didn't do this in the Tesla was a technical problem, but that could be remedied:

https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/adding-second-gear-spe...

"The roadster originally was developed using a two speed gear box. However, they had problems getting it to handle the massive instantaneous torque that the motor could produce, so they went for a single speed."

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by JshWright on Sunday November 06, 2016 @02:37PM (#12886667)
Like I said... It's a reasonable thing to do for niche vehicles. For a mass-market vehicle it is completely unnecessary, and only adds complexity and cost.
Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by kleigenfreude on Sunday November 06, 2016 @03:29PM (#12886889)
> only adds ... cost.

Note: while I think this is probably true for electric vehicles that don't offer this option, this is inaccurate for gas vehicles. Manual transmission cars are still cheaper currently and are sold by major manufacturers. Major manufacturers will typically pass on additional cost to the consumer.

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by JshWright on Sunday November 06, 2016 @04:55PM (#12887288)
Manual transmissions are not cheaper than a single fixed ratio power-train.

The comparison is not between an automatic and a manual transmission. It is between _any_ transmission and "no" transmission.

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by kleigenfreude on Sunday November 06, 2016 @10:28PM (#12888597)
When I was comparing cars in the last year, the manual transmission variant of a car was cheaper than the automatic variant. Why would they continue to make a car that cost more to build and charge less? I think maybe your experience and knowledge in this is specific, but you're generalizing? Otherwise, large automakers are doing non-sensical things...
Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by JshWright on Monday November 07, 2016 @09:00AM (#12891013)
This is a conversation about _electric_ cars... I don't understand why you keep comparing automatic and manual transmissions... Obviously the manual is cheaper in that comparison. That is completely irrelevant when talking about electric cars. The properties of an electric motor make a multi-speed transmission of any sort unnecessary for 'normal' use (for a _very_ wide range of 'normal').

Yes, a manual transmission is cheaper than an automatic, but both are more expensive than "no" transmission[1], which is why electric car manufacturers aren't bothering with them for mass-market vehicles.

[1] Obviously there is still gearing transmitting power to the wheels from the motor, but in the case of electric cars, it can be a single fixed-ratio set of gears, rather than multiple sets of gears and one or more clutches...

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by IshKebab on Sunday November 06, 2016 @09:37AM (#12885240)
It's also regional. 90% of cars in the UK are manual. I don't know why exactly, but I guess it is mostly momentum and the fact that they are cheaper to buy and maintain.
Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by Nullabillity on Sunday November 06, 2016 @10:28AM (#12885472)
It's also much nicer and far more consistent to drive a manual.

With an automatic, the "meaning" of the gas pedal will vary wildly depending on previous state. On a manual you can feel/see the setting, and more importantly, you can set it and thus anticipate exactly when it changes meaning.

Re:Chevy starts manufacturing the Bolt by IshKebab on Sunday November 06, 2016 @09:35AM (#12885227)
Why would you ever need a clutch in an electric car?