Edit to add qualification: It isn't/wasn't my intent to turn this into a Thiel/Gawker thing like the many we've had on HN over the past weeks. It was only to float the idea that it isn't necessarily all that odd for the same lawyer to be involved in similar lawsuits. Nor to gaslight (a term that I've recently learned after reading enough comments here on HN). Like I said, I'm really ignorant about all of this and should have done more research to see what's actually been said. No more from me on this.
[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20120306204240/http://gizmodo.co...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletio...
They settled; no precedent is set. Except perhaps that if you sue a company that no longer exists, they won't pay for very good lawyers. But we probably already knew that.
A simple Google search renders this untrue. Ayyadurai has denied several times his lawsuit has any connection with Thiel:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-03/the-other...
(Or not, too late)
It does seem like a questionable result on its face, but not for 1st amendment reasons.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._Sullivan
The Sullivan case does not only apply to the critique of government officials. Jerry Falwell tried to sue Hustler for depicting him as an incestuous drunk; the Supreme Court ruled against him, 8-0.
PS: It's not may make no law, except the kind that let's politicians sue people.
And I don't believe Hustler Magazine v. Falwell was in regards to whether Hustler could mock him on religious grounds. From the Wikipedia entry:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustler_Magazine_v._Falwell
> Hustler Magazine, Inc. v. Falwell, 485 U.S. 46 (1988), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that the First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit public figures from recovering damages for the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED), if the emotional distress was caused by a caricature, parody, or satire of the public figure that a reasonable person would not have interpreted as factual.
Just as the government may not suppress the right to speech by threat of jail and direct confiscation of money it also cannot provide a venue for other citizens to do so.
Pretending that the first ammendment and libel/defamation/slander don't intersect is a gross misstatement.
Please see
http://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/civil-litigation/defamat...
https://debmcalister.com/2011/06/03/7-things-you-cant-claim-...
http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/libel-defamation
That said this was settled out of court for good for ill so its moot.
I am not claiming that the 1st amendment and libel law do not intersect. They are quite intimately entwined! Libel laws exist for a reason: because a person has a right to maintain his or her good name in the face of false allegations. The ability to bring suit is one of our legal system's methods of protecting that right. Libel laws (which provide truth as an absolute defense) have been found to be constitutionally valid in multiple court cases over the years.
I am a bit puzzled why there was even a settlement at all. Had this gone to trial, there are enough living witnesses to the creation of email as we know it in the early 70s that the case should likely have been dismissed as without merit.
There's clearly something going on here that's not in the article, but it's not first amendment shenanigans.
Ayyadurai would likely be a "limited public figure", under the Gertz v. Welch standard, given his public promotion of himself as the "inventor of email."
On a tech level, this is just shameful. Neither Thiel or Ayyadurai will say if Thiel paid for this lawsuit, that it's just a coincidence that he hired the same lawyer at around the same time when Thiel hired him for the Hogan case. After Tomlinson died, Ayyadurai immediately went on the offensive and blogged, "Correction: The Inventor of Email is Still Alive"
http://fortune.com/2016/03/07/who-really-invented-email/
Edit: a more in depth story here from 2012 when the debate first broke out; MIT apparently highly disagreed with Ayyadurai's version of history and cut off ties with him http://www.bostonmagazine.com/2012/05/shiva-ayyaduri-email-u...