This behavior that you find shocking, I find completely normal and predictable.
I think the most common kind of manager-think is some sort of dedication to appear being conservative in judgments; this can be true for any low level supervisor through to the topmost levels of management. This results in two behaviors: 1) you don't go out on limbs and you work to minimize all risk rather than take well-considered risks; and 2) the problems you deal with daily are "safe problems" that everyone from the board to the employees have accepted as facts of life and their existence is unlikely to get you fired or put you in a bad light.... even if it ought. So you don't solve your problems because the solutions may bring unknown problems of their own. Taking risks, and failing occasionally, is simply seen as failure and successes aren't remembered as long as failures (we remember bad news better than good news)... and any new thinking or new action is seen as risk.
My current position is very much like this. They spent months digging themselves into their current hole. Any attempt to replace their shovels with ladders turns into an argument over how long they spent making their shovels.
It's illogical for your use case. But most people use their phone to read web pages, send messages, pay their bills, and FB/SC/etc. They don't need a non-"bad" computer. Plus they don't want to go to the computer; with this one they have it with them all the time.
So it's not illogical for them.
My use case is closer to yours (though I have a smart phone as well) but I recognize that other people have different motivations. Even when I don't quite understand them!
"There's no chance that the iPhone is going to get any significant market share. No chance. It's a $500 subsidized item."
The iPhone was too expensive even when subsidized. I've said this before and will say it again: Jobs' real genius, besides making a smartphone that actually fun to use, was getting carriers to subsidize it to below $200 (up front, of course; they made it up on the mandatory data plans). Turned out that is the price point that people will actually consider buying a smartphone for personal use, and it created a whole new market which had not really existed previously: the consumer smartphone market.
2) Another fact that supports Ballmer's point that the phones were too expensive is that Apple dropped the price by several hundred dollars a few months after launching it.
So, yes, there were two year contracts, but no smartphone was $0 down or close to it at the time.
AT&T may not have been handing Apple cash as part of the deal, but the contract made it more expensive than the price of the phone.
"I wish I'd thought about the model of subsidizing phones through the operators," he said. "You know, people like to point to this quote where I said iPhones will never sell, because the price at $600 or $700 was too high. And there was business model innovation by Apple to get it essentially built into the monthly cell phone bill."
Apparently he didn't realize cell phone companies had been doing that for nearly a decade before the iPhone.