News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by kowdermeister on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:23AM (#12836069)
The equation is not bad, however I have an improved version of

    Startup = idea + execution + product + team + luck
I'd rather say:

    Startup = idea * execution * product * team * connections * money
Each multiplier should be limited to 0 .. 1 range and thus the closest the left hand is to 1, the better the chances are you'll succeed.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by fnbr on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:17AM (#12836406)
Sam Altman has given a speech a few times (I heard it most recently in "How to Start a Startup") where he uses the same equation, but adds luck, where luck is a random variable going from 0-1000:

    Startup = idea * execution * product * team * connections * money * luck 
I think that's a very accurate assessment of the situation. You need to work hard, have a good team, etc., etc., but without luck, you won't be successful.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by kowdermeister on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:14AM (#12836839)
I think luck has two meanings. One is the traditional sense, when you buy a lottery ticket and you end up $1M richer. That's luck by pure chance. Luck on the other hand can be more deterministic and people still call it that. For example you start a chain of events that end up hugely in your favor. If you don't know what caused it, you might call it luck, but in fact you put yourself on the course to make that happen.

For me the other meaning of luck is when opportunity meets potential/preparedness. If you are 100% capable of going live next day and you bump into a reporter it's much more likely that they will feature you. And you can put yourself into situations when it's more likely to meet reporters if that's what you think need next. From the outside it will still look like "oh Zifffify was so lucky that they got featured on XY".

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by jakewins on Monday October 31, 2016 @03:44PM (#12840222)
I think luck here is referring, mainly, to risk taking - a giant corporation is not going to be the company on something that has a 0.5 probability of happening, but a startup might.

For instance: All these startups around self-driving vehicles. There's a non-zero chance the publics current unsettledness swings to full on majority disapproval, leading to gov't regulation killing self driving cars.

You can set yourself up to maximize the chance of that not happening, but but you cannot bring the probability to zero. Hence, these startups all rely on being "lucky".

Meaning, unlike what I felt you are implying in your comment here, startups are often and in many variables betting on probabilities that they are not in control of, aka luck in the exact same sense as a lottery ticket.

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by warbiscuit on Monday October 31, 2016 @03:19PM (#12840018)
One phrase I really liked was "success is preparedness plus opportunity". In that case, the equation would be...

prepareness = idea * execution * product * team * money

opportunity = connections * random-chance

success = preparedness * opportunity

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by kowdermeister on Monday October 31, 2016 @03:48PM (#12840257)
I like this breakdown too. If we want to add luck, random-chance as * ( 1 + random-chance ) where it can be anything between -1 and 1. It can be both negative or positive or no effect at all.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by throwawayReply on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:39AM (#12836554)
Given it's all multiplied it doesn't matter if the luck is from 0-1000 or 0-1, it has the same effect on the outcome.

a * (b * 1000) = (a * 1000) * b

Sorry, I hate bad maths, I realise it is just trying to imply that luck is more important, but in that case it should be * luck^n.

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by BigMan555 on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:14PM (#12838760)
How does it have the same impact on outcome? You're talking about the associative property of multiplication but he's saying the luck factor can either reduce your success to 0 or multiply the outcome of your endeavor by 1000. It obviously does have an impact (note: the results of .9 * .9 * 1000 and .9 * .9 * 1 are different numbers).
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by throwawayReply on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:37PM (#12839017)
They're different numbers, but it makes no difference in terms of how far along the possible scale you are.

If I score money as 0-1 and luck as 0-1000, then I have a possible overall score out of 1000.

If I score 0.3 on money and 600 on "luck" then I've scored 180 out of 1000, or 18%.

Or if both are 0-1 then I'd have scored 0.3 and 0.6, and overall scored 0.18 out of 1, which is still 18%, it's just the absolute number that has changed.

But the absolute number isn't important in a scale which doesn't have meaningful units.

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by BigMan555 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:15AM (#12844129)
I understood the absolute number to be of significance as the goal (eg. the absolute number is however many millions $ you'll make as outcome). But point taken, I don't think this was thought through :)
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by ketzu on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:51AM (#12837229)
But luck in [0,1] would even make less sense as luck^n (as it goes to 0), while as luck in [0,1000] could scale a successful startup by the factor of up to 1000.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by throwawayReply on Monday October 31, 2016 @11:31AM (#12837661)
What I meant by 'n' was a weighting. I wasn't clear.

Let's say you have 4 factors a, b, c, d.

If we are summing them then we can just sum them straight:

score = a + b + c + d

If we want to place more importance on some of them we weight them, with (constant) weights w, x, y, z by doing this:

score = w * a + x * b + y * c + z * d.

If it's a multiplicative relationship however then we multiply straight:

score = a * b * c * d

If we tried add weighting in the same way:

score = w * a * x * b * y * c * z * d

Then all we've done is scale the previous score by (w * x * y * z) which is constant, so hasn't actually affected any ranking.

To weight a multiplicative relationship requires the weights to be exponents:

score = a^w * b^x * c^y * d^z

The scores can be in [0..1] or [1..N], the increased weights still increase relative power of the input parameter.

If you take logs it's clear why.

log(score) = w * log(a) + ... + z * log(d) which is our weighting when summing again, and log is monotonic (proof of which is left to the reader), log(S1) < log(S2) implies S1 < S2.

Edit: Fixed formatting, it thinks * is italic.

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by nawitus on Monday October 31, 2016 @11:03AM (#12837358)
It doesn't matter if you're comparing "0.001" success to "1" success or "1" success to "1000" success.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by amelius on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:33AM (#12836115)
There's a reason people speak of the "factors" that determine success, instead of the "terms" that determine success :)
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by wlievens on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:41AM (#12836576)
In all seriousness I've often wondered if there is anything multiplicative in the semantics of the situations where people use the word "factor".
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by otoburb on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:01AM (#12836737)
It is exactly for that reason that I often prefer the term "force multiplier"[1] when the situation requires people to understand a multiplicative factor is in play.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Force_multiplication

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by _RPM on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:51AM (#12837234)
+ Privilege You can't leave that variable out.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by burkaman on Monday October 31, 2016 @11:04AM (#12837377)
I think that's covered by connections and money.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by archagon on Monday October 31, 2016 @02:11PM (#12839403)
Not necessarily. There's also the issue of systemic prejudice. Also, things like poverty are a lot more corrosive than just two variables.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by _RPM on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:12PM (#12838733)
Possibly. Even though I'm down voted, it's true. People just don't like to admit it.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by xenobioticants on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:08AM (#12836336)
Nope. A large part is being at the right place in time (and location), which is pure luck.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday October 31, 2016 @11:39AM (#12837753)
I'm not sure this applies. Your particular idea may only be successful at the right time and place. But for any arbitrary time and place, there most likely exists a set of potentially successful ideas that you could execute on.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by Perixoog on Monday October 31, 2016 @12:47PM (#12838523)
where does timing fit in?
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by grzm on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:17PM (#12838787)
If you can control the timing, I'd say execution. Otherwise, luck.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by chongli on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:34AM (#12836126)
thus the closest the left hand is to 1, the better the chances are you'll succeed

If that is the case, then shouldn't money and connections come right after idea? Tons and tons of ideas people have every day are abandoned immediately for lack of money and connections.

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by mipmap04 on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:39AM (#12836142)
He's saying the left hand side of the equation. The order of the items on the right hand side does not matter.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by mangeletti on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:42AM (#12836171)
Can an interpreter shirt curcuit a multiplication if the left side is 0? In Python, for instance, is the following:

    a * b * c * d
computed like this?:

    ((a * b) * c) * d
Or is it computed like this?:

    a * ((b * c) * d)
If the former is the case, then the chongli optimization could help, right?
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by palunon on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:20AM (#12836424)
If you have IEEE compliant floats, you can't, because the right side may result in Infinity, making the complete product NaN.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by mangeletti on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:02AM (#12836744)
Interesting.

We're talking integers here, though (re: Python).

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by nayuki on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:16PM (#12838781)
No, an interpreter cannot short-circuit a zero multiplication. This is because the expressions could be functions that raise exceptions.

e.g. 0 * (0/0)

e.g. f() * raise_some_exception()

Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by mangeletti on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:46PM (#12839123)
Ah, of course. In hindsight, I now feel pretty silly even asking that.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by chrisseaton on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:32AM (#12836508)
Short circuiting means branching, which is likely to be slower than running operators that you know to result is zero.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by kowdermeister on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:38AM (#12836140)
The order doesn't matter :)
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by chongli on Monday October 31, 2016 @09:55AM (#12836679)
It doesn't matter mathematically but it does matter in real life. In real life you don't have all of the terms of the equation simultaneously, you acquire them in order. People generally have money and/or connections before they have a startup idea. Obviously, they also have an idea before they have a team, execution, or a product.
Re:Things I will tell my kids if they become entrepreneurs [... by kowdermeister on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:16AM (#12836864)
Sure, it does matter in real life, but since it probably varies from project to project I wouldn't go that far setting a "correct" order.