News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday October 29, 2016 @08:35PM (#12827391)
How did the DMCA ever get passed? It's an absolutely insane, ludicrous set of laws.

I'm going to start selling shirts that say "Today I Broke The DMCA". No matter who wears it, it's probably true.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by cmurf on Saturday October 29, 2016 @09:15PM (#12827526)
It's the aftermath from inventing intellectual property. Patents were once called monopolies. What I find amusing is, you get this staunchly anti-government/libertarians who are also incredibly pro-IP. And yet IP is all based on governments granting monopoly power over ideas, with violations enabling the owner to engage in all kinds of punative behavior with the government as the strong arm. Ironic.

I think there's something valid about a government protected temporary monopoly. But in the case of copyright, for example, it's life plus 70 or more years. It is ridiculous, as in, worthy of ridicule. Medical patents are 20 years, which itself is too long, but it's made worse by rather permissive ways in which they can be effectively renewed by barely changing the medicine.

You know what it is? It's a way to get white collar work to continue to pay out more than, and longer than, the actual amount and duration of work on a thing takes. It's an incentive to do that kind of work. But I agree that it's grossly lopsided when you can't do repair or research on that same material - that's one of the original points of patent and copyright law. Put your ideas on paper so that you not only get protection for a while, but others can create derivatives that are better, and thereby we learn more about it all.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by kybernetyk on Saturday October 29, 2016 @11:10PM (#12827944)
>you get this staunchly anti-government/libertarians who are also incredibly pro-IP.

Actually most libertarian are strictly against any form of IP and patents. They prefer trade secrets over state regulation.

But then again I don't know if you mean real libertarians or just crypto-statists calling themselves libertarian because they don't know better...

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:05AM (#12828101)
Granting that the Venn diagram of "libertarian" and "Objectivist" is a contentious matter, Ayn Rand was very outspoken in her support of copyrights and patents, and one of the plots of the villainous collectivists in Atlas Shrugged was to nationalize all patents.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by syshum on Sunday October 30, 2016 @04:42AM (#12828732)
Ayn Rand was also very outspoken about not being called a Libertarian, she create Objectivism to be separate and apart from Libertarianism, one of the differences between Objectivism and Libertarianism is copyright/patents
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by Hyperborian on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:49AM (#12828221)
That Venn diagram has little to no actual overlap at all.

The objectivists just find it to be to their advantage, these days, to make it appear that they might. The controversy that you suggest is as manufactured as the controversy about anthropomorphic climate change.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by cmurf on Sunday October 30, 2016 @03:05PM (#12831596)
I permit others some rope when it comes to labeling themselves. I mean self-labeled libertarians, and it's pretty much all of them that believe completely in IP being literal property to be treated every bit as much, if not more than, real property. Even a couple anarcho-capitalist friend strongly believe in it. They'll all say they don't like the government's involvement, they'll say the Ip owner's insurance company should sure my insurance company if I violate a patent. So it ends up being the same thing in the end.

And I'm aware a sizeable chunk of anarcho-capitalists think IP as a concept is bullcrap.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by alasdair_ on Sunday October 30, 2016 @05:02AM (#12828784)
To be fair, most forms of property come from government-granted rights. The very idea that you can own land is kind of weird when you think about it.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by jasonkostempski on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:11AM (#12829347)
It's not really weird when you think about ownership just being a bunch of people agreeing to mess up anyone that tries to take something you've claimed. It takes a lot of work to maintain such an agreement, so people have to be compensated for it. If they aren't compensated to their liking, they'll take that thing and maybe other things you've claimed and maybe ruff you up for good measure.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by e12e on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:15AM (#12829602)
"A bunch of people agreeing" is what a government is?
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by Fargren on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:55AM (#12830122)
Almost. A governments is a bunch of people agreeing plus the power of those people to punish those who do not agree, without being punished back.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by e12e on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:52PM (#12830781)
I'd argue the "power to punish without being punished back" stems from "being a bunch of people that agree" - ie: a bigger bunch of people than any one sub-group they might want to punish for being in disagreement.

Then there's the shift in power that comes from control over weapons and infrastructure ... but AFAIK the coordinated masses still have power on their side - partly from the assumption that given enough "external" disagreement, some people on the inside are likely to cross over.

Indeed, one could argue that the most terrifying part about the Snowden disclosures on mass surveillance, is that the current government is poised to deploy counter-measures long before any opposition consolidates and organizes. This might take the form of buying out individuals - or "dissappearing" or taking out individuals that are perceived to be in the process of becoming important.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by otakucode on Monday October 31, 2016 @04:44AM (#12835068)
Of course. The only 'natural right' to property is the right to physical control over the things you are presently holding in your hands. As soon as you set them down, you lose every natural right over them and some social system has to step in.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by cmurf on Sunday October 30, 2016 @03:06PM (#12831607)
Right. Or mineral extraction rights, and so on.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by tiglionabbit on Saturday October 29, 2016 @10:54PM (#12827891)
I thought patents were an incentive to invest in research and development. Without patents, anyone who invests in research is at a disadvantage because when they come up with something good, their competitors can copy them at no cost.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by fnj on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:15AM (#12828130)
No, both they and their competitors are equally advantaged once the invention has been made. What paents give them is not freedom from disadvantage; it is an artificial advantage to justify making the investment.

Society/the government is ostensibly afraid nobody will invent if they are not artificially advantaged. Those with working intellect consider that trade secrets are enough of a protection against competition.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by didibus on Sunday October 30, 2016 @02:04AM (#12828399)
I remember reading that the idea behind patents was to improve the knowledge transfer that trade secrets didn't offer. In exchange for a temporary exclusivity right, you are required to make public your discoveries and advancements.

The article went further into how trade secrets allowed a company to have its employees sign non disclosures and actually sue the employee and whoever else used the employer's "stolen" knowledge in criminal court, while patents changed this to be only civil and prevented employees from being sued at all.

As everything in life, a balance between the two is probably the most optimal. So I agree patents might have started going too far one way, but I doubt trade secrets would be any better in addressing OP's complaint that patents prevent the free transfer of knowledge and limits innovation.

While I never lived when trade secrets were the norm, I believe most people supporting it in favor of patents suffer from the same problem a lot of younger programmers suffer from. We keep reinventing the wheel and making the same mistakes over and over. It's all a cycle, we'll go back to trade secrets and then their issues will become more "apparent", people will have forgotten the inherent issues with patents and we'll move back to patents again, repeating the cycle.

So I personally disagree with both, you rarely solve issues by reverting back to older ways which the people before us had already tried in vain. We have to try something else, maybe a hybrid, maybe something totally different.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by ryandrake on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:59AM (#12828380)
It's a good thing too, because as we all know, nobody ever invented anything before patents existed.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by type0 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @05:32AM (#12828861)
Of course not, that's why Einstein worked at the patent office.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by nercht12 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:57AM (#12828373)
Once upon a time, they did serve a purpose for people such as Edison who got ripped off right and left, or so I'm told. These days, it's more about putting money in lawyers' pockets because that alleged "protection" technically isn't free: you have to pay someone to defend it. That's why the little guy still goes under. Not to mention his patent might overlap with someone else's just enough for them to try to sue him for stepping over his bounds, supposing he tries making an "improvement". Patents and copyrights are nothing more than a legal minefield. There's nothing intellectually aiding about them, at least not in this era.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by posterboy on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:40PM (#12831067)
>[Patents] did serve a purpose for people such as Edison who got ripped off right and left, or so I'm told

He didn't work alone, did he? I think he had a company, but you can bet he got a sweet deal with his employees on those patents.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by s_q_b on Saturday October 29, 2016 @11:01PM (#12827916)
>I'm going to start selling shirts that say "Today I Broke The DMCA".

That actually happened with DeCSS.

Many many years ago, in an internet far far away, some clever hackers determined how to decrypt DRM-protected DVDs. They even built a decryption program and named it DeCSS. Several court cases followed, usually based upon WIPO CC, the treaty that the DMCA implements.

In DVD CCA v. Bunner, a California court issued a preliminary injunction against a website owner for hosting DeCSS. As an entirely predictable result, the internet responded by disseminating it far and wide.

Some people even put it on t-shirts: http://www.design-reuse.com/news_img/20080804_1.gif

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by userbinator on Saturday October 29, 2016 @11:04PM (#12827926)
A clear example of the Streisand effect in action.

More recently, this happened with the decryption key that starts with 09 F9...

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by s_q_b on Saturday October 29, 2016 @11:06PM (#12827930)
I'm trying to conceive of a t-shirt that would, merely by reading it, cause the reader to violate a copyright law. That one's difficult.

Maybe one with a custom EULA, "By talking to me you acknowledge that you are agreeing to these terms. Should you not agree, say nothing further."

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by qwertyuiop924 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @06:26AM (#12829024)
With facial recognition, we could make a t-shirt that makes you violats the DMCA: every time a face is detected looking at the shirt, it breaks some sort of "digital lock." I'm thinking we have it decode an ISO of a DVD, but it could be almost anything.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by otakucode on Monday October 31, 2016 @04:50AM (#12835098)
It could be literally anything. The lawsuit by RealNetworks against Streambox over the Streambox VCR software established as legal precedent that one single bit, undocumented, is adequate to qualify as a "copyright control mechanism" and that if you ignore that bit, whose purpose you need not even be capable of knowing, you have circumvented it and broken federal law. (There is some sweet irony in the fact that the DMCA, which the Realnetworks v Streambox suit first established the legitimacy of in the courts (due solely to Streambox running out of money - they won every case until they could not afford to respond to an appeal, handing Realnetworks a default judgement) was later used against Realnetworks when they enabled their users to backup DVD movies.)
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by qwertyuiop924 on Monday October 31, 2016 @06:30AM (#12835590)
really? jeez. That's even worse. And probably enough to put about half of HN into prison.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by jlgaddis on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:51AM (#12829503)
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by rtpg on Sunday October 30, 2016 @03:21AM (#12828586)
So my understanding is that the DMCA introduced safe harbor, which lets platforms like Youtube exist.

You can now run a social network and not get sued into oblivion for users putting up copywrighted content, so long as you're not too complicit in the behaviour. Safe harbor is a win for the internet in my book.

Without safe harbor, Google would be liable for re-distributing movies that people keep on uploading to the site. Takedown requests get a bad rap, but it's not the worst possible scenario IMO.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by syshum on Sunday October 30, 2016 @04:52AM (#12828752)
On paper this is true...

In reality this is only a win if you have the deep pockets of google and are able to implement all the things that Safe Harbor Requires, respond to all of the Automated and primary bogus requests in a timely fashion, and are willing to have to your platform censored to the extreme. YouTube can withstand it because of its inertia, many new platforms have tried and failed.

Safe Habor, as written, ensures YouTube's dominance in online self uploaded video.

Further Safe Habor does not protect you from being sued, it simply gives you a defense should you be sued. See the YouTube vs Viacom case.

AS such one will still have to pay lawyers to defend them, this results in many content platforms being shutdown, or never being created in the first place

No in reality Safe Habor only seems like a good thing on paper, and then only if you are a Copyright Maximalist that believe the current copyright law is acceptable or does not provide enough protection.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by darpa_escapee on Sunday October 30, 2016 @05:08AM (#12828808)
> Safe Habor, as written, ensures YouTube's dominance in online self uploaded video.

If I remember correctly, YouTube originally gained popularity because practically anything could be uploaded on the service. A huge percentage of it was blatantly copyrighted material.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by syshum on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:02AM (#12829320)
You remember what the Major Media companies want you to remember.

It is revisionist history at best.

Yes there was copyrighted content on YouTube, as there is today, but no that is not why is gained popularity.

It gained popularity because it made video accessible to everyone. Before youtube attempting to host your own videos, be it a cat video, or a major movie was EXPENSIVE.

Back then, as today, most of the "violations" are actually fair use.. Copyright Maximalist however believe copyright gives them total control over their work, meaning if a person using a 1 second clip for commentary, or happens to have a song playing in the background while their baby does something cute on video and uploads it to Youtube that is a violation of copyright.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by darpa_escapee on Sunday October 30, 2016 @02:07PM (#12831234)
> You remember what the Major Media companies want you to remember.

No, I remember watching full movies, episodes and seasons of shows on YouTube. I remember music videos, full albums and re-uploads of content from other websites.

I remember reading from multiple sources that in the early days, YouTube willfully ignored DCMA takedowns and allowed infringing content to be shared for the views.

>It gained popularity because it made video accessible to everyone. Before youtube attempting to host your own videos, be it a cat video, or a major movie was EXPENSIVE.

There were a handful of free video hosts around at the time.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by jamez1 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @06:56PM (#12833006)
YouTube gained popularity because of the copyrighted content not because of the random crap like a dancing baby.

Popularity, is about views, not submissions.

It's weird that you've started this paranoid rant about history being re-written, when you're the one who is totally off mark. (and seem to have eluded common sense)

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by qwertyuiop924 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @07:45AM (#12829269)
Yes, that's right. At the time, Netflix streaming was a magical future dream, and Hulu was some weird Hawaiian word, or something. If you wanted to stream video, illegal or no, Youtube was your best bet, being the most convenient way to do it. Past Youtube, there was Bittorrent, but it was less popular by far.

To this day, if you want to watch a weird, obscure series that nobody remembers, and thus was never put on the big streaming sites, Youtube is your best bet.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by izacus on Sunday October 30, 2016 @03:27AM (#12828599)
I don't understand - Google would be liable ONLY because there's another law saying they would be liable. Why not change that law instead of enact another set of crazy laws which demands that you keep proving you've done nothing wrong when some corporation sends a form?
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by rtpg on Sunday October 30, 2016 @04:16AM (#12828683)
If you have the most basic copyright law, then Google is liable, because they are distributing content they don't have permission to.

So tech companies want Safe Harbor. Media companies understand that safe harbor will enable some shadier businesses like megaupload (where the site owners are complicit in the content and hide behind safe harbor). So they say " OK for safe harbor, but we want a bit more protection for us, the content producers, as well." Thus a compromise is formed.

Most laws are comprises to get most people at the table, this seems like one of them.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by syshum on Sunday October 30, 2016 @04:44AM (#12828742)
Compromise: Taking the worst parts of 2 ideas and make an even worse singular idea.....
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by redial on Saturday October 29, 2016 @08:52PM (#12827442)
Only if you don't get sued out of business using the DMCA before even selling your first shirt.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by userbinator on Saturday October 29, 2016 @08:54PM (#12827445)
The power which the pro-DRM industry groups have is immense.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by shmerl on Sunday October 30, 2016 @11:44AM (#12830385)
Corrupted undemocratic policymaking. See here: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/03/ustr-secret-copyright-...