News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by tiglionabbit on Saturday October 29, 2016 @10:54PM (#12827891)
I thought patents were an incentive to invest in research and development. Without patents, anyone who invests in research is at a disadvantage because when they come up with something good, their competitors can copy them at no cost.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by fnj on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:15AM (#12828130)
No, both they and their competitors are equally advantaged once the invention has been made. What paents give them is not freedom from disadvantage; it is an artificial advantage to justify making the investment.

Society/the government is ostensibly afraid nobody will invent if they are not artificially advantaged. Those with working intellect consider that trade secrets are enough of a protection against competition.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by didibus on Sunday October 30, 2016 @02:04AM (#12828399)
I remember reading that the idea behind patents was to improve the knowledge transfer that trade secrets didn't offer. In exchange for a temporary exclusivity right, you are required to make public your discoveries and advancements.

The article went further into how trade secrets allowed a company to have its employees sign non disclosures and actually sue the employee and whoever else used the employer's "stolen" knowledge in criminal court, while patents changed this to be only civil and prevented employees from being sued at all.

As everything in life, a balance between the two is probably the most optimal. So I agree patents might have started going too far one way, but I doubt trade secrets would be any better in addressing OP's complaint that patents prevent the free transfer of knowledge and limits innovation.

While I never lived when trade secrets were the norm, I believe most people supporting it in favor of patents suffer from the same problem a lot of younger programmers suffer from. We keep reinventing the wheel and making the same mistakes over and over. It's all a cycle, we'll go back to trade secrets and then their issues will become more "apparent", people will have forgotten the inherent issues with patents and we'll move back to patents again, repeating the cycle.

So I personally disagree with both, you rarely solve issues by reverting back to older ways which the people before us had already tried in vain. We have to try something else, maybe a hybrid, maybe something totally different.

Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by ryandrake on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:59AM (#12828380)
It's a good thing too, because as we all know, nobody ever invented anything before patents existed.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by type0 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @05:32AM (#12828861)
Of course not, that's why Einstein worked at the patent office.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by nercht12 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:57AM (#12828373)
Once upon a time, they did serve a purpose for people such as Edison who got ripped off right and left, or so I'm told. These days, it's more about putting money in lawyers' pockets because that alleged "protection" technically isn't free: you have to pay someone to defend it. That's why the little guy still goes under. Not to mention his patent might overlap with someone else's just enough for them to try to sue him for stepping over his bounds, supposing he tries making an "improvement". Patents and copyrights are nothing more than a legal minefield. There's nothing intellectually aiding about them, at least not in this era.
Re:DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on yo... by posterboy on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:40PM (#12831067)
>[Patents] did serve a purpose for people such as Edison who got ripped off right and left, or so I'm told

He didn't work alone, did he? I think he had a company, but you can bet he got a sweet deal with his employees on those patents.