Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by xkcd-sucks on Saturday October 29, 2016 @01:20AM
(#12822744)
LawBot:
Hi, I'm LawBot, a robot lawyer designed to help you through this situation. Please tell me your name or say anonymous if you would rather not.
You:
i was arrested for public urination
LawBot:
Nice to meet you, i was arrested for public urination. I can help you understand if you have been the victim of a sex offence, a property offence, physical or psychological injury, or harassment. If you don't understand what I am saying, just say so and I will explain. If you don't understand a word, just ask me about it and I will give you a definition. Would you like to get started?
You:
i was arrested for public urination
LawBot:
Please describe briefly in one sentence what happened to you. Try to use words that people usually use when speaking about this issue to help me understand you.
You:
i was arrested
LawBot:
Sorry, could you try to explain that in a different way? Maybe be more specific about the incident?
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by drinchev on Saturday October 29, 2016 @04:27AM
(#12823161)
I barely understand the chat bots hype around these days. They all remind me of Clippy [1] and are especially ineffective when it comes to complicated interaction.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by jondubois on Saturday October 29, 2016 @04:42AM
(#12823190)
It's not even a lawyer; it sounds more like a police prosecutor.
Saying that it's 'the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer' sounds like an outright lie in every way. It only helps plaintiffs, not defendants - It's a prosecutor.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by gnicholas on Saturday October 29, 2016 @12:59AM
(#12822700)
> LawBot
Too much recursion in AIML
I got this several times, once when asking about the definition of a term ("psychological injury") and again when trying to get information about harassment crimes. Seems more like an alpha so far...
The chatbot should probably make clear up-front that all information provided (1) does not constitute legal advice, and (2) is all based on the laws of a certain jurisdiction (presumably somewhere in the UK). Otherwise people might think that the information provided is relevant to them when it isn't actually. I don't know if it provides disclaimers later in the process because I kept getting errors before any advice was given.
Lastly, this looks to be run completely by law and other students. They should probably have some actual lawyers involved to make sure that (1) their analyses are correct, and (2) they aren't running afoul of laws regarding providing legal advice. It would probably also make people feel more comfortable using the tool.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by dilemma on Saturday October 29, 2016 @01:24AM
(#12822752)
Services like this are 100% useless because it is impossible for the user to verify that the software has (1) accurately interpreted the question and (2) accurately answered the question.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by antirez on Saturday October 29, 2016 @05:13AM
(#12823242)
When you try for some time, it eventually does what it should try to do since the start, given that NLP is not easy and not needed in this case: it starts to ask you questions with a fixed set of possible replies in order to narrow the case to a set of pre-existing possibilities.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by paulcole on Saturday October 29, 2016 @12:42AM
(#12822676)
I tried "I got arrested for drunk driving" 3 or 4 times in a row and never got any reasonable response. If a lawbot can't help with "DUI" or a more common phrasing, it should at least recognize it.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by tdeck on Saturday October 29, 2016 @12:53AM
(#12822695)
I'm surprised it's not illegal for them to claim this bot is a "lawyer". Usually it seems like people are very careful about that, and clearly the bot wouldn't pass any bar exam.
Re:Introducing the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer
by J-dawg on Saturday October 29, 2016 @04:29AM
(#12823165)
I've seen several articles recently saying that chatbots are The Next Big Thing. I just don't get it. Every chatbot I've ever used reminds me of playing those text-based adventure games, where you need to rephrase your question several times to get the outcome you want.
I find it hard to imagine a situation where a chatbot would help me find the information I need faster than a nice structured menu layout or a good search engine.
You: i was arrested for public urination
LawBot: Nice to meet you, i was arrested for public urination. I can help you understand if you have been the victim of a sex offence, a property offence, physical or psychological injury, or harassment. If you don't understand what I am saying, just say so and I will explain. If you don't understand a word, just ask me about it and I will give you a definition. Would you like to get started?
You: i was arrested for public urination
LawBot: Please describe briefly in one sentence what happened to you. Try to use words that people usually use when speaking about this issue to help me understand you.
You: i was arrested
LawBot: Sorry, could you try to explain that in a different way? Maybe be more specific about the incident?
1 : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_Assistant
Saying that it's 'the World's Most Advanced Chatbot Lawyer' sounds like an outright lie in every way. It only helps plaintiffs, not defendants - It's a prosecutor.
I got this several times, once when asking about the definition of a term ("psychological injury") and again when trying to get information about harassment crimes. Seems more like an alpha so far...
The chatbot should probably make clear up-front that all information provided (1) does not constitute legal advice, and (2) is all based on the laws of a certain jurisdiction (presumably somewhere in the UK). Otherwise people might think that the information provided is relevant to them when it isn't actually. I don't know if it provides disclaimers later in the process because I kept getting errors before any advice was given.
Lastly, this looks to be run completely by law and other students. They should probably have some actual lawyers involved to make sure that (1) their analyses are correct, and (2) they aren't running afoul of laws regarding providing legal advice. It would probably also make people feel more comfortable using the tool.
AIML is an old framework for writing rule-based chatbots. It's a generalization of Eliza.
You: crime
LawBot: A crime is anything that a person does that will lead to a criminal conviction.
The sass.
hmm, 2 comments in and I'm confused...
I find it hard to imagine a situation where a chatbot would help me find the information I need faster than a nice structured menu layout or a good search engine.
Am I missing something?
My car was stolen
LawBot
Sorry, could you try to explain that in a different way? Maybe be more specific about the incident?
----
I may not be a native English speaker but come on, isn't that wording pretty clear?
http://0bin.net/paste/rBkOCw5hi2sAdvPx#5e1Be08sJSV9sFCWTbS2D...
xD