News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by hx87 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:12PM (#12807703)
Exactly--open salaries might cause some companies to crash and burn, but these are companies that /should/ crash and burn.
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by jjnoakes on Thursday October 27, 2016 @05:39PM (#12810493)
I'm not arguing one way or the other about open salaries, but should a company really crash and burn for hiring someone who was willing to work for some price $X, even if it is lower than their peer? I mean the person did accept the job knowing $X, right?
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by hx87 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @06:20PM (#12810822)
If the "willing to work for $X" was based on flawed or incomplete information, and X would be higher if more complete information was accessible, then yes, I would say they should crash and burn. OTOH, if two people with access to the same information were willing to work for different salaries, that would be fine. IMO, information asymmetry that is enforced and not the result of research costs is a form of rent-seeking and should be abolished.
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by cmdkeen on Friday October 28, 2016 @07:17AM (#12814754)
From some of the management training I've sat through money is a poor motivator but a really powerful demotivator. If I give you a pay rise you very quickly come to see yourself as "worth" that amount of money and so any boost is short lived. If you feel that you are underpaid that leads to a long running and very powerful effect as described above.

There are plenty of other things that are much more powerful motivators than money, and a good company to work for is probably not the one paying you the most. Otherwise everyone would be in finance working 100 hour weeks and loving it. The issue isn't that someone was paid $X is that they felt they were worth $Y and the other incentives and motivators weren't sufficient to overcome that. If they were paid less than they could command elsewhere but doing work that mattered to them and challenged them, felt valued by the company, were part of a good team, had flexibility in work life balance, were given opportunities to develop and learn, had prospects for advancement and the myriad other things that different people value (and sometimes value very differently) then the situation may have been very different.

Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by eloisant on Friday October 28, 2016 @06:07AM (#12814476)
That's a bad move on the part of the company, because an underpaid person is a time-bomb.

From what I've seen, the problem often arise not with people hired at a low pay because they didn't know better, but hired at a low pay because that was the market price at the time. They end up having less pay than people with the same experience (or even less) who were hired later when the market salary was higher.

Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by jjnoakes on Friday October 28, 2016 @07:53AM (#12814904)
> an underpaid person is a time-bomb

I disagree. There may be some instances of this, but there are also instances of people who love their job and would not change it for more money.

Money isn't the only motivator.

Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by Chris2048 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:24PM (#12848762)
Love their job, or love their role?
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by edoceo on Thursday October 27, 2016 @05:56PM (#12810641)
Yes. And then more data becomes available, which changes perspective. Then employees leave for better opportunity
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by jjnoakes on Thursday October 27, 2016 @06:03PM (#12810698)
No disagreement here; I just don't know how "companies might crash and burn because they pay their employees lower than market rate" equates to "companies that pay their employees lower than market rate should crash and burn".

One doesn't follow from the other, and I don't agree that there's inherent evil just because the salary was lower than elsewhere.

Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by ozzy6009 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @10:21PM (#12812516)
It doesn't, what he is saying is that the companies that do crash and burn after revealing salary information to their employees are the ones that should crash and burn. There is not an inherent evil in paying a lower salary. On the other hand,if the only reason they are able to pay a lower salary is because their employees do not know any better, they are more likely to be negatively affected by opening their salary information.
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by jungturk on Saturday October 29, 2016 @09:05AM (#12823755)
I didn't read it as a moral judgement.

The important characteristics of the companies he's talking about is that they're in an unstable equilibrium dependent on wage ignorance. Meaning that wage info itself would destabilize them rather than any of the mentioned toxicity.

I think he's excluded "companies that underpay but are stable in the presence of wage info" from the class that "should [be expected to] crash and burn".

Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by Retra on Thursday October 27, 2016 @07:45PM (#12811501)
If that were true, these companies would have no reason to fear opening up. After all, each of their employees made conscious decisions to be underpaid, so why would they leave?
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by user5994461 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @08:46PM (#12811853)
No they didn't. Most likely their employees have no clue what they could get elsewhere, or they better take that job here first than wait 2 months for another offer elsewhere, or they needed to be in city X before moving to a better company, or...

Random number: 50% of employees consider their employment as a stepping stone.

Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by Retra on Friday October 28, 2016 @08:18PM (#12821851)
That's my point. "the person did accept the job knowing $X, right?" is not a valid assumption.
Re:Open Salaries: Outcomes by IshKebab on Friday October 28, 2016 @05:46AM (#12814384)
Which is exactly why it won't catch on.