What if you demand full disclosure of the science that drives the accelerator at CERN? Well, it's "disclosed" already, just read the papers. Quantum-electrodynamics-something-something. Now what? Might as well be magic.
This is a core issue with democracy. You're asking average individuals to express a choice on matters that are orders of magnitude above their cognitive abilities.
The problem with this is simply, that if some people don't understand the science, other that ALSO don't understand it can tell them they DO understand it. Who should tell the differens, besides the people wo really understand it?
There are three groups or movements in question:
Rhodes Must Fall: protestors unhappy with having a large statue of Cecil Rhodes (founder of De Beers, "architect of apartheid", extreme white supremacist) on their campus.
Fees Must Fall: Large protests against university fee increases that used the naming convention
Shackville-TRC: advocates for alternative dispute resolution for those students who were expelled for participating in the protests.
"Science Must Fall": a hashtag made to mock one single student who said very crazy stuff in a video on youtube.
There is no "science must fall" movement documented, there was one viral story about one single person saying one single dumb thing. It went viral on Reddit in the /r/videos and /r/rage sub-reddits (those bastions of coherent discourse). It was picked up by click-bait sites who implied the existence of a movement because the angrier you are the more likely you are to click "share".
This is an excellent example of the exact problem being discussed, although I'm not convinced transparency into the algorithms is the solution here. We already know exactly why these stories were pushed out to people's feeds: this type of disinformation makes money.
You wouldn't necessarily know it from the framing text search engine bots would have scanned.
The issue is really one of trust.
Also, 'orders of magnitude'? I'm guessing that's hyperbole, but if not, what does that even mean?
Amusingly enough, Europe already does this through their 'right to be forgotten' laws. Criminals routinely use it to hide their past indiscretions.
People can also use internet search engines to determine when the German government is lying to them, scandalous!
EU "right to be forgotten" only applies to things which are no longer relevant.
If someone's done the crime, and the time, and it's not relevant anymore, then they're done. No point in them being constantly punished for minor crimes.
https://blog.wikimedia.org/2016/10/19/petition-right-to-be-f...
To shape your users' traffic - is that not exactly what's occurring? The question is whether they're doing it on our behalf, or for their own ends (and what happens when those two align?)
The hypothetical you pose is not nearly so cut and dry - in fact, I argue it's happening now, but it just so happens in more cases than not, that it aligns with what users want. Just take a look at the Facebook "trending" issue.
I have a hard time getting riled up about the lesser actions companies may potentially take confronted with the reality of the actions governments do take.
that line was crossed a long time ago
This is what _every_ business would do and actually does when it is offered a significant advantage over all potential competitors in the market. That's what lobbying is all about. Large corporations pay politicians so they create laws in order to suppress competition.
Everyone loves free markets as a consumer, but a business is never interested in the kind of competition that could put it out of existence, its employees fired and leave its founders bankrupt.
The solution here is not to create new regulations which make it even harder to do business than it already is, or to enact laws that make this kind of bribery illegal (it would continue no matter what you do) but to impose serious limitations on government power so it can't rig the system for a handful of powerful corporations that can afford engaging in this kind of bribery.
> This is what _every_ business would do and actually does
Google and the NY Times refused the Chinese government's proposals and were kicked out of that market.
> to impose serious limitations on government power so it can't rig the system for a handful of powerful corporations that can afford engaging in this kind of bribery.
I don't see how limiting government power to regulate large businesses will help; it will shift power to the large businesses, worsening the situation. I don't think Google and Facebook's success is due to government rigging the market, nor do I think their influence will now diminish if government regulatory power is reduced.
Human advancement on every level is not driven by greed, but by rational self interest. Self interest is a necessary precondition for improving anything, otherwise what's the motivation to build for example a nice house if I don't care about the better life quality that I'll have living in it? Greed is just a subjective or collective way to say that someones self interest goes far beyond what is considered productive and rational. (if you p--- everyone off with inflated self interest you will likely have a problem rather sooner than later)
Just compare the improvements that societies made which didn't allow or limit direct self interest as the primary motivation for economic activity to those that did. There's just no doubt that life in Socialist countries was in almost every case much worse and it is even today. (USSR, pre Capitalist China, North Korea, Nazi Germany, Venezuela, Cuba and so on)
> Google and the NY Times refused the Chinese government's proposals and were kicked out of that market.
You are omitting that I wrote "significant advantage over the competition". I doubt China would _ever_ tolerate officials rigging its system in order for the NY Times to have a significant advantage over its national mainstream media. Or Google over Baidu. Most likely these companies do not even have a chance at competing with local Chinese companies anyway. An average Chinese person might desire to use an iPhone with Chinese apps on it, but reading the NY Times, c'mon.
> I don't see how limiting government power to regulate large businesses will help; it will shift power to the large businesses, worsening the situation. I don't think Google and Facebook's success is due to government rigging the market, nor do I think their influence will now diminish if government regulatory power is reduced.
I do not say that Google's and Facebook's success is due to bribing politicians, this is most certainly wrong. But large corporations do it after reaching a certain size in order to ensure that they will be able to maintain it into the future.
There would be no need to ever bribe a politician if these corporations were fully confident that they could stay dominant in the market and beat new competition. The mere fact that corporations decide to do this shows that it is often more efficient to spend resources on suppressing competition via government power than using it to innovate and improve products and services.
Who looses in all of this? The consumer (more expensive, lower quality products), the worker (lower incomes) and anyone who wants to build his own company. (high entry barriers to the market resulting in a static class of elites with less upward mobility)
Again, look at markets where government directly owned or ran almost all businesses. What was the result for the average person? How competitive were the products? These countries usually allowed and desired to export while suppressing imports, but for some reason all the Capitalist societies wanted to buy was natural resources, not finished products. Buy Soviet Lada cars? Who would have bought that when there's Mercedes, Audi, BMW, VW and so on? (I'm in a German country so that's what we drive here)
Of course there were a few cases were largely Socialist countries did work, but these were to my knowledge always edge cases where they for example have a very small population and enormous natural resources (like oil)
> Libertarian/Objectivist ideology
Yes, something along these lines. I desire to live in a society that offers as many freedom to every one of its members as possible, though I recognise that there must be limits too. The Socialist on the other hand wants to mold society in some way or another in order to achieve or reach some kind of higher or better form of society. This is always done by the use of force and I reject that. If you try to convince me to better myself - fine, but passing laws that threaten fines (robbing me of my resources) or prison is not okay with me.
But it's funny how you jumped to conclusions I am a Trump voter and asserted ultimate knowledge of "reality", you must be a liberal I guess.
I doubt that Google would tweak their algorithm in such a way that it would work against their interests (if this happened, I bet they would just roll back the change) - That alone gives Google an advantage over everybody else.
It's a bit like how some manufacturers were able to slowly lower the quality of their products over time and still retain or improve market share because people just didn't notice...
Twitter is already banning people from a particular side of politics.
zuck don't give a fuck.
I don't think engineers are more principled than others, and thinking we are exceptional is, IMHO, the number one way to expose ourselves to these human frailties.
So I'd like to add to your rebuttal that extremely principled people are also capable of awful actions. All it takes is a good theory.
It's not about nobody finding out about it. It's about having enough people in key positions who are OK with doing it.
Extremely principled about who should win the election.
I don't want to turn this discussion into the presidential mess, but it's no secret that virtually almost everyone working for a particular search engine, from employee to executive support one particular candidate and not the other.
A small group of people here are very vocal about who they support, but probably 90+% of people never mention politics and don't seem to like to talk about it at work.
I guess I'll say I only know the google model of things, where pretty much 99.9% of the codebase is open to FTEs. It would be very very difficult to slip anything into the code there without someone catching on and causing a shitstorm.
You may think the current leadership of those organizations wouldn't do that, but they are human beings.
* What if a powerful business partner, such as the Chinese or Indian governments or a large company, wants search results 'made more fair and balanced' in return for their business? Hollywood studios, Bloomberg, and (IIRC) Fox already have censored themselves for the Chinese government. Advertisers' influence on the news is well-known.
* What if one of the big platform's leaders feels very strongly about an issue, feels attacked, or thinks they are doing the right thing? IIRC, Jimmy Wales used his power to alter articles in Wikipedia to suit his preferences and to cover up the changes. What if a highly critical, maybe even partly false story about Zuckerberg or his wife goes viral? Will it get treated the same as other such stories?
* What happens when a big platform's leadership changes? Maybe the new people will be highly politicized. Maybe the Koch brothers or Fox/Murdoch (or Peter Thiel?) or another politicized investor will buy in - precisely to gain that influence, as many have done before.
These platforms have the responsibilities of journalists, without the institutional or professional norms and training, and with far more power than any news organization ever had. Rush Limbaugh, Fox, CNN or the NY Times each (or even together) have nothing compared to the breadth and depth of influence of Google, Facebook, and Twitter, in the U.S. and around the world.