News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by hackuser on Thursday October 27, 2016 @01:49PM (#12807399)
A good point, but experts can review the algorithms and report on them to laypeople. Almost everything in the world that we understand is a result of that process, other than some things (not all) in the field we have expertise in. Nobody has time to review the source material in more than a tiny fraction of the things they know.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by k__ on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:11PM (#12807689)
Just look at the "Science Must Fall" movement in South Africa.

The problem with this is simply, that if some people don't understand the science, other that ALSO don't understand it can tell them they DO understand it. Who should tell the differens, besides the people wo really understand it?

Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by freshhawk on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:52PM (#12808306)
Excellent example!

There are three groups or movements in question:

Rhodes Must Fall: protestors unhappy with having a large statue of Cecil Rhodes (founder of De Beers, "architect of apartheid", extreme white supremacist) on their campus.

Fees Must Fall: Large protests against university fee increases that used the naming convention

Shackville-TRC: advocates for alternative dispute resolution for those students who were expelled for participating in the protests.

"Science Must Fall": a hashtag made to mock one single student who said very crazy stuff in a video on youtube.

There is no "science must fall" movement documented, there was one viral story about one single person saying one single dumb thing. It went viral on Reddit in the /r/videos and /r/rage sub-reddits (those bastions of coherent discourse). It was picked up by click-bait sites who implied the existence of a movement because the angrier you are the more likely you are to click "share".

This is an excellent example of the exact problem being discussed, although I'm not convinced transparency into the algorithms is the solution here. We already know exactly why these stories were pushed out to people's feeds: this type of disinformation makes money.

Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by r_smart on Friday October 28, 2016 @03:07PM (#12819589)
Off topic: The interesting thing about that video to me was how closely it mirrored the rhetoric from the opening of the 'Three Body Problem' as the Chinese revolutionaries tried to force a college physics professor to revoke science.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by gozur88 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @11:58PM (#12812944)
Yeah, as I recall when I watched that video the other students struggled to remain respectful but eventually started to openly laugh at her.

You wouldn't necessarily know it from the framing text search engine bots would have scanned.

Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:53PM (#12808330)
So, perhaps the issue here is not that average people can't comprehend high science (or politics, or economics, etc).

The issue is really one of trust.

Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by paavokoya on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:56PM (#12808371)
Yeah but most of the time laypeople disregard the scientists and substitute their own logic anyways.. People are incredibly stubborn and set in their opinions.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by drakonandor on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:45PM (#12808161)
The issue is there that an uneducated person cannot know if an 'expert' is actually an 'expert'.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by szatkus on Thursday October 27, 2016 @03:55PM (#12809217)
In my experience true experts win sooner or later. Almost no one today believes that Earth is flat.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by srd on Friday October 28, 2016 @02:46AM (#12813636)
Except sometimes later is too late. See climate change.
Re:Angela Merkel: internet search engines are 'distorting pe... by omginternets on Thursday October 27, 2016 @02:41PM (#12808107)
I think Assimov's "A cult of ignorance" is a good analysis of where this approach falls short.