The vast majority of "altcoins" are minor tweaks on Bitcoin and a couple others, they're not at all technically interesting, and I think it's an open secret they're pump-and-dump schemes.
I don't know much about ZCash, but I know it's pretty unfair to dismiss it as "another altcoin". The people behind it are well respected [1][2] and it makes use of novel technology.
ZCash has this ability to de-anonymize users through targeted blocks, and is a privately-held U.S.-based company that claims no liability for it's user's actions, meaning if subpoenaed they will [probably] turn over information.
They're also privately cashing in on 20% of all transaction fees.
Just because someone behind a project has credentials you respect doesn't mean we should ignore aspects of the project.
I agree. Good thing that's not what I did.
Regardless of any flaws, there has clearly been a lot of effort put into it by multiple smart people with good intentions (from what I can tell), therefore it is unfair to characterize it as just "another altcoin".
That's the only assertion I made.
From the ZCash Whitepaper:
>A powerful attacker could potentially fabricate an additional block solely for a targeted user. Spending any coins with respect to the updated Merkle tree in this “poison-pill” block will uniquely identify the targeted user.
Zcash 10% vig is an improvement over instamine or premine. I agree this structure is still not ideal for maximizing zcash value, as it creates an incentive to clone zcash (without the vig). Zcash looks like it will be rather more difficult to clone than, say, Ethereum. But it will certainly be done. I also expect that some of zcash features will be added to other protocols, thus diluting its tech advantage.
No one has figured out how to force everyone to invest in the same version of bitcoin, and perhaps that is as it should be. I still expect the Zcash devs to make out OK.
It's two year in the making and we're hoping to launch in March. Governance is necessary for the maintenance of the commons, but we don't think it should be in the hand of a foundation or a core development team.
For those reading this who don't know him, Doug has an impressive pedigree both as a lawyer and as a technologist / cypherpunk. He was, for instance, to president of "Evil geniuses for a better tomorrow"
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mnet_(peer-to-peer_network)
He now specializes in advising startups and I cannot recommend him enough. http://barneslegal.net/
To my knowledge, ETHC maintained chain of title with original ETH up to the fork. However, the DAO exploits may have transferred some of the premine to the team that worked the exploit, to the extent any of the devs invested in the ill-fated DAO.
The way the "10%" is done is that it's really 20% for the first 4 years then 0%. Given the past history of premined altcoins I wouldn't weigh the odds that this specific system really lasting more than 4 years out especially high.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/investing/shares/lego-a-better-in...
b/ Open source works well for very complicated pieces of software.
c/ As we saw in the case of Ethereum, assuming you can buy due diligence with money alone is a mistake.
Please let me know what specific topic of zkSNARK you find challenging to explain and we can write a blog post about it.
a) the mechanics of the proof generation, including outlining the time for proof generation.
b) How the trusted setup works; for extra credit describe in detail how zcash plans to do it.
c) an ELI5 explanation of zkSNARKS
d) a comparison of the Ben-sasson and Parno implementations.
- "MPF (Mental Poker Framework): A new family of practical and secure Mental Poker protocols" http://www.dc.uba.ar/inv/tesis/licenciatura/2010/lerner
- MAVEPAY: a new lightweight payment scheme for peer to peer currency networks: https://bitslog.files.wordpress.com/2012/04/mavepay1.pdf
- Strict Memory Hard Hashing Functions: http://www.hashcash.org/papers/memohash.pdf referenced in the Ethereum original paper: http://gavwood.com/paper.pdf
The last link is more formal, and talks about models of computation, but once again does not provide any reductions.
Since there's no cryptographically provable way to know they won't do this, well, we have to assume it's what they'll do. Distrust is the basis for cryptocurrencies afterall.
Moreover, having worked with some of them, I can assure they're not shady no-gooders...
But these guys are much less likely to be scammers than the typical no-name GitHub/Twitter/Bitcoinforums accounts promoting a new revolutionary coin.
Tromer's paper [2] may be helpful. At least there, the references are cited and findable. Tromer's first result deals with collision-resistant hash functions. That's been a big headache in practice. It's really hard to develop a cryptographic hash function for which someone can't create two strings that result in the same hash.[3] MD4 and MD5 have been broken, SHA-1 has been partially broken, and SHA-256 hasn't been (publicly) broken yet. Tromer seems to claiming that he has a solution to weak hash functions. But it's really hard to tell from his writing.
Anybody really understand this?
[1] http://web.stanford.edu/class/ee380/ [2] http://www.cs.tau.ac.il/~tromer/papers/huntingsnark-20140724... [3] https://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs6830/2009fa/scribes/lec...
Though to be fair, the rate at which new cryptocurrency pools are being created seems to more than keep up with the growth of the economy. Who needs the government to print money when anybody can?
That kind of macroeconomic analysis assumes that everybody already owns some amount of the currency.
However in the new currency markets that are developing, you have to consider the incentive to even start accepting a currency.
One that loses value over time is not attractive to the recipient.
Correction: One that changes value over time is not attractive to the recipient.
You can shine the deflationary currency as much as you'd like, but economists have a consensus on why the volatile behavior of set-supply currencies are inferior.
It's precisely why the world's major currencies don't use the gold standard, but honestly, this conversation repeats itself almost every time a deflationary cryptocurrency gets posted.
How about stability and liquidity instead? The more readily exchangeable a unit of currency is for goods, the easier it will see adoption. Deflationary currencies, due to their incentivization of hoarding, tend to be both unstable and illiquid, driving away anyone but speculators.
EDIT: Time and again getting downvotes because of HN's cognitive dissonance. Pathetic low-tier reddit run-off is entering HN's market share.
letting people exchange money (directly) with whatever currencies they want
If you had any idea the amount of regulation and ridiculousness involved in banking and forex, you'd laugh at this statement.Edit: This altcoin also seems to provide anonymity [1]
> The value of Gulden is determined by the demand for Gulden, as with gold or silver. The price can go up or down, but on average the value of Gulden goes up.
Sure. It will only go up. Just like all the other altcoins.
There is something that irks me about the name of this project. Gulden is the name of the Dutch currency used before the introduction of the Euro. At this point in time it has strong historical connotations (obviously), but it is also a symbol of adherents of the nationalistic political (far) right in the Netherlands. There are plenty of people from the lower socio-economic classes who fuelled by demagogues who believe we should revert to the Gulden (the actual currency, not this altcoin), close our borders, get out of the EU and once again prosper (even though we are already doing pretty well all things considered, and the EU benefits us on the whole, despite all its warts).
Choosing Gulden as a name for this project seems to explicitly place it at the heart of that particular bit of discontent. It also feels extremely pretentious to use the name of our historic currency that anyone over the age of twenty actually used. This I can grok from a commercial standpoint, but it leaves a nasty taste.
Gulden is used for actual value transfer that is easier than currently possible between banks, I can just transfer value to you by scanning your QR code. As such there is value in this method. Moreover I can not only transfer value to you but also to shop holders and taxi drivers around Groningen, this is due to human labor by the company behind Gulden. Gulden was trending in the iOS store a couple of days ago by the way, so many people have heard of it, even internationally.
The name YouTube also refers to old CRTs, perhaps indeed to evoke a certain feeling. Who cares.
> Gulden is used for actual value transfer […]
I can see some of the benefits touted, but for most of those situations cash or our excellent system of debit cards and POS-terminals already do this, and transferring money via IBAN is peanuts (and free within most EU countries). But convenience aside, cash works without a smartphone and middlemen. It's mostly anonymous too.
Besides, I get that companies are vying for the position of the one digital money transfer 'app' here in the Netherlands, because whoever manages to do that is in for a very profitable ride (like that one similar app popular in Sweden), but linking it to their own altcoin seems like a way to propagate a pyramid scheme by means of an app some will find useful.
"Zcash's monetary base will be the same as Bitcoin's — 21 million Zcash currency units (ZEC, or ⓩ) will be mined over time. 10% of that reward will be distributed to the stakeholders in the Zcash Company — founders, investors, employees, and advisors. We call this the “Founders Reward”."
Here's a list of the other 709 altcoins.[1] 373 of them are still tradeable. 88 have a market cap in excess of $1M. 27 have a market cap in excess of $10M. 4 have a market cap in excess of $100M. PayCoin, which was last year's heavily promoted new cool coin with a "guaranteed floor" of $20, is now at position 415 with a value of $0.002606 and a market cap of $30,247.
[1] https://coinmarketcap.com/all/views/all/