News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by carsongross on Monday October 24, 2016 @04:51PM (#12782772)
Seems like they will stay a niche until they can replace phones entirely, and perhaps even past then. A lot of people just don't like having something strapped to their wrist and/or want a large screen.

As a watch guy (and most watch people are guys) the first smart watch I've been excited about is the upcoming gear S3:

http://www.samsung.com/global/galaxy/gear-s3/

Because it looks like a real watch and has the rotating bezel for input, but I recognize I'm a tiny market.

I hope it doesn't set my wrist on fire.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by Mahn on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:19PM (#12783002)
> until they can replace phones entirely

I.e. never? I mean, I can picture making phone calls or dictating SMS by voice with a smart watch, but people are not going to be browsing the web or taking pictures with a tiny wrist device when they already have a 5-6" inches display device on their pockets, and almost no one would ditch the latter for the former if they had to choose.

I think it's likely that smart watches will continue to be niche devices for the foreseeable future, at very least until someone figures out a killer feature that sets them apart from smartphones.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by nostrademons on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:52PM (#12783225)
FWIW, I said the same thing about smartphones when they came out - who'd want to browse the web on a tiny 4" screen when you've got a 13" laptop? And indeed, I do very little web-browsing on my smartphone; it's generally just used to answer quick questions when I absolutely need information (or, well, when I want to win an argument over dinner :-P).

What made smartphones useful was people discovered new uses that you just couldn't use a computer for. You can't do turn-by-turn navigation with your laptop in the car. It's nearly useless if you're standing at a street corner in an unfamiliar city and want to know where the closest coffeeshop with wifi is. You can't use it to take a picture of the cute little ducks crossing the road and send it to your wife. It does you no good when you want to hail a car to take you home.

People haven't yet discovered similar uses for a smartwatch. It's highly likely that they exist, though. What the watch gives you is hands-free information: you can receive quick, 1-5 second notifications even if you're carrying something or immersed (sometimes literally) in physical activity. I've already found this useful for getting notifications that my founders' group has changed where we're meeting while I'm driving there, or that my wife has already gone to the grocery store, or for checking off items on my shopping list while carrying shopping bags. There are probably other bigger uses waiting to be discovered.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by toyg on Monday October 24, 2016 @08:10PM (#12784058)
> What the watch gives you is hands-free information

But your phone can also give you that, through earphones or headsets. Smartwatches must find new uses that a phone cannot also do as well, which is a much harder bar to clear.

For example:

> notifications [...] while I'm driving there

Phones can do that already, and will do more and more as CarPlay etc become mainstream.

> checking off items on my shopping list while carrying shopping bags

Siri can probably do that already (I use Trello for my shopping lists and it works fine as it is, tbh).

The one use where smartwatches will likely be unbeatable, forever and ever, is fitness/health: carrying around a phone in those circumstances is simply more annoying than carrying a watch. Once they get cheap enough, they might replace smartcards and badges for access control. If smartglasses become mainstream, they could augment each other (your glasses display and record, your watch stores and computes) and actually replace phones altogether; but alone, I don't see them going anywhere.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by nostrademons on Monday October 24, 2016 @08:31PM (#12784193)
Bluetooth earbuds & headsets have all the downsides of smartwatches: they cost roughly the same (for headsets; earbuds are a lot cheaper), they make you look as dorky or more, they're IMHO less comfortable, and they're another accessory that can fall out and get lost. And they seem to have similar adoption numbers. The main difference is audio vs. visual: headsets are better for some uses (notably taking calls) but worse for others (interacting or reading quick notifications).
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by coldtea on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:33PM (#12783115)
>I.e. never? I mean, I can picture making phone calls or dictating SMS by voice with a smart watch, but people are not going to be browsing the web or taking pictures with a tiny wrist device when they already have a 5-6" inches display device on their pockets, and almost no one would ditch the latter for the former if they had to choose.

People might also not have 5-6" devices in their pockets, but special glasses with HUDs or smart contact lenses...

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by aetherson on Monday October 24, 2016 @07:33PM (#12783863)
If we're assuming the existence of non-sucky smart glasses or contact lenses [1], why exactly would anyone use a smart watch?

[1] Smart contact lenses are such a crock. Seriously, guys, how do you think you're going to power these things?

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by coldtea on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:19PM (#12784750)
>If we're assuming the existence of non-sucky smart glasses or contact lenses [1], why exactly would anyone use a smart watch?

For the same reasons we use smartwatches with our phones today. It's more plausible they'd fit a great cpu, cellular phone, gps, etc on a watch size, than they'd fit it in a decent glass frame.

So the watch could handle most things, plus there are interactions that can't be done with glasses (like measuring one's heart rate, or similar).

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by aetherson on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @11:51AM (#12788942)
Heartrate, okay, sure. But all the rest of it, let me suggest that smart glasses + smartphone makes a lot more sense than smart glasses + smartwatch.
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by toyg on Monday October 24, 2016 @08:17PM (#12784093)
Bulk. It makes sense to keep glasses as light and small as possible, whereas a watch can be relatively bulky without being socially unacceptable. So you could have just enough electronics for glasses to display information and record, then have the watch store or compute the resulting data.

It could basically split smartphone features into two gadgets that are easier to carry around. For that, though, we still need quite a few leaps in miniaturization.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by annerajb on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:28PM (#12783088)
Unless people resort to another device like mounted glasses for web viewing and picture taking. Or a ipad for bookreading, web browsing and picture taking.
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by BoorishBears on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:07PM (#12782906)
Back in 2007 I remember seeing smartwatches that could replace phones (make calls, text, Internet, even take pictures) for sale in Ghana

The problem is a watch can only be so big before it's too big, but input and battery life on small devices sucks (for now)

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by bobajeff on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:23PM (#12783053)
Well the over all problem here is that today only Apple and Samsung even make money on Smartphones. Not Sony, not HTC, not Motorola, not not LG, not Xiaomi, not Huawei neither of those make money from selling phone hardware.

If they can't do that then first of all Why and more importantly what's driving innovation in hardware?

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by pyrophane on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:21PM (#12783023)
I own the Gear S2. I've also owned the Apple Watch (S0) and the Moto 360 2nd gen. The interface on the S2 with the rotating bezel works really well. It is the only time I really felt like my smartwatch was an actual watch and not just a "device" strapped to my wrist. The cellular functionality was also handy in a pinch, as it offered some communication utility if I left my phone at home.

That being said, I don't think I'll get the Gear S3. The biggest problem is that while the S2 works great for displaying notifications, the lack of phone apps makes it difficult to take any action on most of them without switching to your phone. On top of that, I found it extremely difficult to get text into the watch to do things like respond to texts with anything other than a pre-selected message template. The T-9 keyboard was awkward and S Voice didn't work well at all (in part, I'm sure, to the quality of the microphone embedded in the watch).

I don't think smartwatches will be much more than notification mirrors until the ability to quickly input text gets better, probably through improved voice dictation.

One other thing about the S3: I really don't understand their choice to offer cellular connectivity only one the Frontier model. That feature is one of the main things that would attract me to the device, but I don't like the styling on the frontier.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by samastur on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:28PM (#12783084)
I am another watch guy, but I disagree that the main problem is that people don't like wearing them (although there certainly is no shortage of such people). Last year there were 1.2 BILLION watches sold (http://www.statisticbrain.com/wrist-watch-industry-statistic...). On whole smart watches sold as well as Swiss did even though they are on average significantly cheaper.

I don't know why they are not selling, but clearly combination of their advantages and disadvantages is not compelling enough compared to alternatives.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by verytrivial on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:41PM (#12783165)
Anyone else remember graffiti input on PalmOS[1]? It strikes me that even a low resolution digitiser (32x32, maybe less?) would still resolve those characters. That gets you SMS entry and contact search, maybe?

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graffiti_(Palm_OS)

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by steaminghacker on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:47PM (#12783199)
It was great. but writing on a micro screen is no fun. press and swipe are about as far as it should go with wrist touch interfaces.
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by j_syk on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:18PM (#12782993)
The gear S2 has a similar rotating bezel, though it's less obviously looking at it. The strap design on the S2 is awful- too easy to break. Good to see they are moving to normal watch bands. One thing that would keep me from buying a samsung again is if they stick with SVoice instead of letting you use Google voice search (especially with Google Assistant)
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by bobajeff on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:04PM (#12782885)
Yeah that's me I'm waiting for them to come out with one that's a replacement for a phone not some unjustifiably expensive accessory for a phone.

That or just make phones smaller. My favorite flip phone is smaller than even the smallest iPhone. I'd probably still use it today if my network still supported 2g.

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by sosuke on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:05PM (#12782894)
I saw the Fossil Q (https://www.fossil.com/us/en/wearable-technology.html) in the wild the other day and it looked very attractive.

I love that bezel input idea! I hadn't seen the Gear S3

Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by tgb on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:22PM (#12783037)
What does the "charging not required" claim mean for the hybrid watches? They claim a 6-month battery life. What do you do afterwards? Replace the battery?
Re:Smartwatch sales are tanking by sosuke on Monday October 24, 2016 @05:52PM (#12783226)
There are several types of self charging watches out there. Solar are some, kinetic watches. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_quartz

I think that means it will sit on a shelf unworn for 6 months