Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by Zak on Monday April 19, 2010 @09:56AM
(#1276680)
[F#] is the first time we've seen integration of a functional programming language with an industrial-strength framework and toolset
I think this requires very specific definitions of all his terms. It would be easy to argue that Lisp machines met this definition, and that's just the first example that came to mind.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by Zak on Monday April 19, 2010 @12:04PM
(#1277008)
F# appears to have been started in 2002. Scala was in 2003 and Clojure around 2005 with the first public release in... 2007? This announcement isn't about the release of F#, but its productization.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by mbrubeck on Monday April 19, 2010 @04:01PM
(#1277676)
F#, like OCaml, is also multi-paradigm. Maybe not as much as Common Lisp, but it does have language-level support for OOP and imperative programming. It's not a purely functional language like Haskell.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by DrSprout on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:41AM
(#1276789)
I suspect by "industrial-strength" what he actually means is "something you have to pay a lot of money for." rather than "is widely acknowledged as a useful and powerful tool by the industry."
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by ekiru on Monday April 19, 2010 @05:29PM
(#1277899)
Or now, if for some reason you still want one. It wouldn't cost you quite as much as Visual Studio Ultimate, but it would likely cost you more than Visual Studio Professional With MSDN($1,199) and a fairly impressive modern PC.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by eru on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:39AM
(#1276785)
You may be right.
Though the Lisp on the Lisp machines wasn't very functional, yet. Or at least `less' functional by default than F# is. I am thinking mostly of static scoping.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by _delirium on Monday April 19, 2010 @09:57AM
(#1276686)
Not only have you been hearing about it for years; it's also been released for years: F# 1.0 came out in 2006! The only difference here is that with the release of F# 2.0, it's now shipped by the Microsoft "product" teams instead of "research" teams: it's included in Visual Studio 2010 available in boxes on shelves, whereas previously it was available for download.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by BudVVeezer on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:05AM
(#1276707)
Which is actually a pretty big deal because it means the integration into VS will be greatly improved. I've not tried the VS 2010 F#, but the plugin version was pretty clunky within the IDE.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by gaius on Monday April 19, 2010 @12:25PM
(#1277069)
It's a big deal because now you can just go ahead and use it and no manager can complain that it's not an official language. Hackers sometimes forget how conservative the mainstream IT industry can be.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by confuzatron on Monday April 19, 2010 @03:25PM
(#1277600)
Nope you weren't going crazy, you were just reading The Register.
It's a kneejerk anti-MS site where all headlines must sufficiently glib before being accepted for publication. Blech.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by borisk on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:06AM
(#1276849)
Very stable and fast implementation. Just finished porting a Scala project and the F# code runs around 50% faster on CLR 4.0 compared to Scala on JRockit JVM.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by cygwin98 on Monday April 19, 2010 @04:00PM
(#1277674)
I've been thinking of this for a while.
Although there is fswebtools that shares the same spirit as GWT
http://tomasp.net/blog/fswebtools-intro.aspx, it's not as polished.
IMHO, F# for the backend to provide web service, jQuery for the frontend, and with JSON as the intermediate protocol may be a good combo.
Re:Microsoft stealth launches 'historic' programming languag...
by MichaelGG on Monday April 19, 2010 @06:28PM
(#1278043)
They did make a good point: F#'s marketing is severely limited. It seems that Microsoft doesn't want to be in the position of saying "hey, here's a language that does everything C# does, plus a ton of extra great things, and the only drawback is the tool support".
I think this requires very specific definitions of all his terms. It would be easy to argue that Lisp machines met this definition, and that's just the first example that came to mind.
The Lisp Machine was the opposite of that. The frameworks and the toolsets were integrated INTO the Lisp Machine.
Maybe they haven't been looking around - cough Clojure cough
They predate F# by a couple decades.
For some values of "functional programming language" and "industrial-strength framework and toolset"
Though the Lisp on the Lisp machines wasn't very functional, yet. Or at least `less' functional by default than F# is. I am thinking mostly of static scoping.
Write it all in F#, including using async workflows for seamless server-side calls, and have it compile down to JS.
Then I found out that they want you to pay them $80 to change the desktop background in Windows 7 Starter.
So now I have forgotten about F#, and recommend Haskell instead. OCaml and Scala are also fine. Fuck Microsoft, they'll never change.