https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now...
(front page discussion of that story: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12748863 )
What innovation? Autonomous vehicles? Volkswagen is working with Stanford researchers and Mobileye (you know, the people who helped build Tesla Autopilot):
http://www.volkswagengroupamerica.com/autonomous.html
I mean, sure, if you don't leave the front page of HackerNews, you'd think that Tesla is literally inventing this stuff in real-time. But believe it or not there are lots of smart people and companies working on autonomous vehicles. They just don't market as well or as often as Tesla. And in some cases, yes, they're behind.
Other than the 250,000 drivers of Nissan Leafs... I think that's beyond twice as many as every Tesla ever built.
Otherwise it's inferior to Tesla model 3 in almost any aspect (not to mention the larger Teslas):
- only 107 mile range vs. 215 miles - no super chargers or own network, relies on third party generic chargers - less trunk space - less acceleration - no battery swap - no regular software upgrades over the internet - no self driving capabilities - no flat screen controls
When Tesla model 3 is out, selling at $35,000, Nissan will have to make serious upgrades to remain a viable alternative.
2. While 'more acceleration' sound nice in theory, using all this power is usually pretty bad for your range.
3. While the battery swap sounds nice, in practice battery degradation hasn't been that bad according to many EV owners I talked to. Will it actually be necessary? If you're thinking about swapping the battery for a quick 'charge' I'm not sure that's going to be available for the Model 3 (and even if available, what the costs for doing so will be.).
4. Some might like the flat screen, I'm personally not a very big fan. Plain old fashioned knobs and buttons are really easy to work with.
I agree with the rest of your list but I'm pretty sure EV sales (especially for the near future, say the next ten years) are not a zero-sum game. Plenty of Leafs, Bolts, Souls, and Model 3s will be sold regardless of the fact that the Model3 may be 'better' based on your definition.
Disclaimer: I drive a Kia Soul EV with 'only' ~100 miles real-world range.
Currently, Tesla is the only one who is delivering practical innovation and success!
Here's Mercedes in 2014: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_RFzC_G5BA
Tesla has the hardware in every car it sells, and will be mining super useful data with all these sensors, and tweaking it's software (machine learning based on real use cases for a year) before it puts it out to the public! The scale of data mining that can be done with Tesla's approach is near impossible with other cars (if they continue to sell the cars with and without the sensory hardware)
Again, Tesla may very well do it better than anyone else, but it's a bit early to talk like they've won anything here.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_autonomous_cars#199...
[0]: https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now...
Other than being able to charge a premium for activating later why install it on all the cars? Tesla is basically using data from sensors that'd be in a Fully Autonomous Vehicle, driven by a human for at least a year. Thats a lot of free valuable data being collected for the cost of just the hardware installation!
Instead of doing all the testing and tweaking once car is street legal for test runs as an autonomous car, Tesla benefits from putting every single piece of hardware needed for its future as early as possible, just to mine this data gold.
As a German citizen, it really bugs me that Volkswagen is incapable of this kind of innovation. I don't see their roadmap play out like they plan it, because Tesla might beat them to market hard. I fear German regulation will jump in (again) to help them against Tesla.
Currently, the German government gives out electric vehicle subsidies (~5k per car), but it is limited cars less expensive than 60k. At the moment there is very low demand for this subsidy, because everyone who goes EV wants to go Tesla.