News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:45PM (#12748371)
The article itself is actually very generous to Clinton, as it primarily questions Trump's policies, features a ridiculing picture of him, and praises Clinton's policy documents (focusing, actually, on the number of pages rather than their clarity, consistency or purposes). They also snub Trump for questioning whether the hacks of the DNC were supported by the government of Russia.

In doing so this article falls prey to much of what plagues the media during the election cycle. Broadly aligned against particular candidates and willing to take widely biased and selective approaches toward writing and editing about them, they fail to say much of anything substantive at all.

For instance this article can't come up with what a good policy might look like, any particular appraisal of either candidate's policies (it merely cites pages and makes an issue of known Clinton's backdoor policies).

The article mentions that both candidates consider Snowden a traitor, with Trump explicitly using the word and Clinton calling for Snowden to be extradited to the United States under investigation for violating the Espionage Act.

Reading between the lines the article emphasizes that Silicon Valley doesn't understand or trust the policies from either candidate, but appears to have a stronger majority support for Clinton due to issues not related to either campaign promises or policy directions.

EDIT: People below in the thread take issue with the term "libelous" so I replaced it with "ridiculing".

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by eridius on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:16PM (#12748555)
> features a libelous picture of him

That's a very strong statement, and AFAICT completely unwarranted. The picture depicts him thinking of a 400 pound weight, which is a reference to his statement that was quoted later in the article:

"[Hillary Clinton’s] saying Russia, Russia, Russia. Maybe it was. It could also be China, it could be someone sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds."

And the question marks on the picture are representative of the fact that his tech policy (the main subject of the piece) is incoherent and largely undefined.

> For instance this article can't come up with what a good policy might look like

Classic deflection technique. A critic does not need to be able to come up with a good answer in order to criticize someone else for not doing so. It's not Ars Technica's job to define this nation's tech policy, but it is the president's job (or at least, the president has a huge influence on it), so presidential candidates really ought to be able to define a clear policy.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:19PM (#12748577)
Meh. I get what you're saying.

To be very fair I've called out when libelous pictures are posted of Clinton. I consider anything that makes a candidate look confused or stupid or ineffective politically loaded, damaging to reputation (in the context of an election) and therefore libelous.

His quote had nothing to do with his policy (which I agree is as vacuuous as Clinton's). He was talking about attribution. Separate topic.

Regarding "deflection technique" I don't expect Ars to come up with a uniform policy. I do expect them to have standards (other than number of pages) to evaluate criteria by. The author of the article clearly doesn't. This is what I intended to say and I fully admit that I didn't say it clearly before.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by diyorgasms on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:59PM (#12748805)
>I consider anything that makes a candidate look confused or stupid or ineffective politically loaded, damaging to reputation (in the context of an election) and therefore libelous.

The you are clearly misinformed as to the nature, facts, and purpose of libel law, and it would be a mistake for anyone to believe what you have to say on the matter.

Using an unflattering picture or depiction cannot be libel. Making a false statements (an in the case of public figures, such as presidential candidates) those statements must be made with "actual malice" or be published with a reckless disregard for the truth. N.B. I am not a lawyer.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:02PM (#12748821)
Seems to be on the same line as this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12748759

It's a mistake to take everything everyone says as legalese.

I mean these terms in the vernacular sense.

It seems to me that you are trying to pick a very technical fight in a forum where it is not suited. Neither you nor I are lawyers and this is not a courtroom.

Do you understand what I mean by libelous?

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by diyorgasms on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:07PM (#12748854)
It seems you are intent on using the term "libel" which carries a very specific and technical meaning. As best as I can parse, you mean to say they chose a deliberately unflattering picture. I suppose I understand what you are going for, but you are not doing yourself any favors by using a term that has a very specific meaning in a non-standard manner and expecting people to understand that you are using that word in a non-standard manner.
Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:17PM (#12748912)
As the use of the term completely derailed the thread into unproductive and off-topic territory, I acknowledge that my uncareful use of it has done me no favors and invited a variety of "conversation noise."

I find it unfortunate that conversations can be and are derailed so effectively this way. I'll try to avoid the term in the future when speaking about both Clinton, Trump and others.

I edited the top comment to reflect this.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:52PM (#12748759)
To be libelous, it must not merely be damaging to reputation, but also concern a matter of fact and be a maliciously false representation on that matter of fact.

You could fairly describe the picture in the article as mocking, but not libelous.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:57PM (#12748787)
I agree that you could argue one interpretation over the other (as would happen in a courtroom).

I suppose, since we don't want to keep arguing, that it will remain unresolved.

Thankfully it appears you understand my use of the term.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by eridius on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:38AM (#12750156)
I appreciate that you don't want to keep arguing this, but the matter certainly is not "unsolved". Libel is a specific term with specific meaning, and you are using it to mean something different. There is no common vernacular usage of libel that means "unflattering statement/depiction".

Or to put it another way, you're the only person who thinks it's unsolved, everybody else understands the meaning of libel and how you're using the term incorrectly. If you truly don't want to argue this, you should just accept that and move on.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:08PM (#12754680)
See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12748805

I've changed the original wording.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by dogma1138 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:03PM (#12748470)
>The article mentions that both candidates consider Snowden a traitor, with Trump explicitly using the word and Clinton calling for Snowden to be extradited to the United States under investigation for violating the Espionage Act.

Only 15% of American believe that Snowden is a hero, 30% call him a traitor outright and only 25% of them believe that he should be offered any type of deal/pardon.

http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/edward-snowden-rasmussen-po...

So both candidates either appeal too or represent to the vox populi.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by mhays on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:43PM (#12748716)
>Only 15% of American believe that Snowden is a hero, 30% call him a traitor outright and only 25% of them believe that he should be offered any type of deal/pardon.

According to that poll. I think it's a reasonable possibility that one of those buckets is shortchanged by the way polls are conducted.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by dogma1138 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:07PM (#12748853)
Honestly, I was surprised that 25% of the US public/registered voters are willing to pardon Snowden, I would've thought that that percentage would be far lower.

You need to realise that even in the Huff's online polls e.g. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/05/edward-snowden-poll... Snowden was viewed unfavourably, and if online and the Huff is not pandering to a favourable demographic even tho on paper the poll might match the US demographics then I don't know what is.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:14PM (#12748542)
I think that's a fair point.

Our republic, much like many historical republics including (crossing immediately the Godwin line) the Weimar Republic, are fervently nationalistic and willing - through fear, state disinformation, and through prejudice - to support cases against liberty in support of centralized autonomous power.

While the youth population of America either broadly support Snowden or are deadlocked (depending on the poll), the more religious and jingoistic elements of the American public and those whose generations participated in World and Cold wars have been easy to convince that civil liberty is something cheap to trade for consolidated power.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by dogma1138 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:14PM (#12748894)
There is a difference between supporting the position and supporting the act.

I would go as far as say that the majority of "young" (18-35) Americans would call for a trial rather than a blanket pardon.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:20PM (#12748935)
Pew Studies seem to indicate the opposite of what you've said: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/22/most-young-a...
Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by dogma1138 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:22PM (#12748947)
That doesn't mean the majority will support blanket pardon over a trial, especially a trial like the one Snowden requested where he could mount a defence based on the public's interest which is not possible for espionage charges.

In fact by your own poll it looks that the majority of 18-35's would favour criminal persecution since the 18-29 is 42 for 42 against and 30-49 is 56 for 36 against.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by jwtadvice on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:24PM (#12748958)
I see. Yes I think that's right. I think more 'young' people would want to see a fair and open public trial than a blank pardon.

It's my impression that more 'young' people would want to see a blanket pardon over a secret trial where a defense can't be mounted.

Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by dogma1138 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:38PM (#12749035)
Myself personally (not an American) would favour trial (of any kind) over a blanket pardon, however I will support a full pardon or full commute of the sentence in case he is found guilty by a trial in which he could not mount a proper defence due to the espionage act limitations, if it would be a closed trial or if it would be a military tribunal instead of a trial by jury.
Re:If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commissi... by slg on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:14PM (#12748548)
>For instance this article can't come up with what a good policy might look like

I'm not sure I've seen anyone able to do this. The political and law enforcement communities simply don't seem to understand the tech side. While the tech community seems unwilling to acknowledge that widespread and freely available encryption is a world altering proposition for governments who have been able to use warrants to get this same information for literally hundreds of years. If some type of “Encryption Commission” is established to get these sides talking, that is at least progress.