To be very fair I've called out when libelous pictures are posted of Clinton. I consider anything that makes a candidate look confused or stupid or ineffective politically loaded, damaging to reputation (in the context of an election) and therefore libelous.
His quote had nothing to do with his policy (which I agree is as vacuuous as Clinton's). He was talking about attribution. Separate topic.
Regarding "deflection technique" I don't expect Ars to come up with a uniform policy. I do expect them to have standards (other than number of pages) to evaluate criteria by. The author of the article clearly doesn't. This is what I intended to say and I fully admit that I didn't say it clearly before.
The you are clearly misinformed as to the nature, facts, and purpose of libel law, and it would be a mistake for anyone to believe what you have to say on the matter.
Using an unflattering picture or depiction cannot be libel. Making a false statements (an in the case of public figures, such as presidential candidates) those statements must be made with "actual malice" or be published with a reckless disregard for the truth. N.B. I am not a lawyer.
It's a mistake to take everything everyone says as legalese.
I mean these terms in the vernacular sense.
It seems to me that you are trying to pick a very technical fight in a forum where it is not suited. Neither you nor I are lawyers and this is not a courtroom.
Do you understand what I mean by libelous?
I find it unfortunate that conversations can be and are derailed so effectively this way. I'll try to avoid the term in the future when speaking about both Clinton, Trump and others.
I edited the top comment to reflect this.
You could fairly describe the picture in the article as mocking, but not libelous.
I suppose, since we don't want to keep arguing, that it will remain unresolved.
Thankfully it appears you understand my use of the term.
Or to put it another way, you're the only person who thinks it's unsolved, everybody else understands the meaning of libel and how you're using the term incorrectly. If you truly don't want to argue this, you should just accept that and move on.
I've changed the original wording.
That's a very strong statement, and AFAICT completely unwarranted. The picture depicts him thinking of a 400 pound weight, which is a reference to his statement that was quoted later in the article:
"[Hillary Clinton’s] saying Russia, Russia, Russia. Maybe it was. It could also be China, it could be someone sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds."
And the question marks on the picture are representative of the fact that his tech policy (the main subject of the piece) is incoherent and largely undefined.
> For instance this article can't come up with what a good policy might look like
Classic deflection technique. A critic does not need to be able to come up with a good answer in order to criticize someone else for not doing so. It's not Ars Technica's job to define this nation's tech policy, but it is the president's job (or at least, the president has a huge influence on it), so presidential candidates really ought to be able to define a clear policy.