Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by sickbeard on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:57AM
(#12743302)
Ranked choice voting is not good enough, it has far too many flaws like not amounting to majority rule. In fact it only encourages fringe candidates who have more to gain and end up getting disproportionately represented in when voting ends
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:00AM
(#12743327)
This system is used for many elections globally, and my understanding is that it's widely considered to be quite fair. I'm struggling to understand your specific objections.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:49AM
(#12744260)
IRV is the worst of the five commonly discussed alternative voting methods as measured by Bayesian Regret.
http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html
Score Voting and Approval Voting are simpler and better.
http://scorevoting.net/CFERlet.html http://www.electology.org/approval-voting-vs-irv
Clay Shentrup Co-founder, The Center for Election Science
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:47PM
(#12745962)
Approval voting is fabulous. Why have I never seen this discussed before?
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by mojuba on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:07AM
(#12743378)
I think the problem (at least theoretically) is that second-choice votes are not weighted. It could've been e.g. 1 for first choice, 0.5 for second and so on. Because obviously your second choice candidate is not as good to you as the first one, but some not-so-good candidates can get more votes. In fact I can even see some potential patterns for manipulation here.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:21AM
(#12743499)
That isn't a problem; the impact of your vote is inherent in the ranking, so lower preferences are automatically "worth less" than higher ones. I don't see a particular pattern that would allow for manipulation. AFAIK it's fairly resistant to tactical voting and manipulation by withdrawal.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:10AM
(#12744462)
Ludicrous.
http://scorevoting.net/TarrIrv.html
And irrelevant, since IRV performs worse with 100% honest voters than Score or Approval with 100% strategic.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by mojuba on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:36AM
(#12743607)
Is it so in case of Maine though?
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by jimhefferon on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:37AM
(#12743624)
But there are many results showing that manipulation is NP complete. So Arrow's work is only a first take on the entire story.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:11AM
(#12744470)
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by sp332 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:14AM
(#12743443)
This is less of a problem if there are more than two established parties that can expect to get the vast majority of the votes. With multiple real choices, smaller parties don't have to be "fringe".