Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:00AM
(#12743327)
This system is used for many elections globally, and my understanding is that it's widely considered to be quite fair. I'm struggling to understand your specific objections.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:49AM
(#12744260)
IRV is the worst of the five commonly discussed alternative voting methods as measured by Bayesian Regret.
http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html
Score Voting and Approval Voting are simpler and better.
http://scorevoting.net/CFERlet.html http://www.electology.org/approval-voting-vs-irv
Clay Shentrup Co-founder, The Center for Election Science
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:47PM
(#12745962)
Approval voting is fabulous. Why have I never seen this discussed before?
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by mojuba on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:07AM
(#12743378)
I think the problem (at least theoretically) is that second-choice votes are not weighted. It could've been e.g. 1 for first choice, 0.5 for second and so on. Because obviously your second choice candidate is not as good to you as the first one, but some not-so-good candidates can get more votes. In fact I can even see some potential patterns for manipulation here.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:21AM
(#12743499)
That isn't a problem; the impact of your vote is inherent in the ranking, so lower preferences are automatically "worth less" than higher ones. I don't see a particular pattern that would allow for manipulation. AFAIK it's fairly resistant to tactical voting and manipulation by withdrawal.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:10AM
(#12744462)
Ludicrous.
http://scorevoting.net/TarrIrv.html
And irrelevant, since IRV performs worse with 100% honest voters than Score or Approval with 100% strategic.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by mojuba on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:36AM
(#12743607)
Is it so in case of Maine though?
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by jimhefferon on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:37AM
(#12743624)
But there are many results showing that manipulation is NP complete. So Arrow's work is only a first take on the entire story.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:11AM
(#12744470)