News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by wyager on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:10PM (#12694678)
> It's happened many a time before.

And who can blame them? If you started putting a bunch of high-risk no-income people in section 8 housing in a formerly nice neighborhood, any rational person who could afford it would move away.

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by thinkmoore on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:22PM (#12694801)
"High risk, no-income." Really? Section 8 supports the working poor. You need to check your prejudices against reality.
Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by wyager on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:41PM (#12694976)
I guess most of them work from home then? I see you go to Harvard, so you have the privilege of being insulated from the realities of publicly supported destitute poverty. I suspect you've never seen massive fights in a section 8 complex, or people setting trash cans on fire, or people smashing windows, or stealing appliances from their own buildings.
Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by azinman2 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:52PM (#12695058)
Down the street from Harvard is section 8 housing that I'm sure the GP isn't even aware of, because it looks just like any other building near by. No trash can fires or the like. I used to be a big brother to a kid in that building, so I've been inside many times. None of those things you described were happening.
Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by duaneb on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:28PM (#12694860)
If only the working poor were "high-risk no-income". That would indicate some free time to get into trouble! That would mean they could simply find a job instead of stretching their current ones.

This is a classist dogwhistle labeling the poor as lazy, violent people.

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by wyager on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:38PM (#12694947)
I have lived near section 8 housing in Texas. They are not, generally speaking, working. It's also not the kind of place you want to be near at night.

"The poor" is not the same as "people who live in public housing". There are a lot of dirt-poor rural areas that are very safe (and generally more employable).

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by yummyfajitas on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:24PM (#12695751)
Why are you trying to shame people for making claims that are fundamentally correct?

The poor are lazy: http://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publication... Table 3 on page 21.

They are also disproportionately violent: http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hpnvv0812.pdf

I have no data on section 8 recipients in particular; do you?

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by duaneb on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:15PM (#12696468)
Neither source remotely supports your claims. Laziness is not qualitative. I think people who work desk jobs are lazy; I imagine you believe people on disability to be lazy. The thing you linked doesn't even contain the word. You have to use your words if you want to communicate.

The rich would be violent, too, if they were threatened by losing their wealth. Being able to reject violence wholesale is privileged.

Let's just agree never to interact; I think we'll both be happier.

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by wyager on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:24PM (#12696528)
> Being able to reject violence wholesale is privileged.

Ah, so not beating your wife, as discussed in the paper, is privileged? It's OK for poor people to do it?

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by duaneb on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @07:58PM (#12697351)
> Ah, so not beating your wife, as discussed in the paper, is privileged?

Avoiding conviction certainly is.

[dead]
Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by tptacek on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:24PM (#12696888)
What is the rhetorical purpose of lines like these?

I'm glad we could come to agreement that the poor are predominantly high-risk no-income people who are also disproportionately violent

I've noticed you employ this assumptive-close rhetoric a lot, but always in such an outlandish fashion (in this case, for instance, coming within epsilon of saying "I'm glad we agree the poor are bad people") that I have to stop and wonder whether your point is that the argument you've been pursuing is ludicrous, and you're pushing it as an exercise in showing how ludicrous this kind of logic can be.

In a sales conversation, you lead a prospect gradually to the point where the assumptive close feels natural, and the counterparty is meant to feel like they've convinced themselves. But your assumptive closes are so clumsy and obvious it's like you're trying to hit people over the head with them.

You're not stupid, so I assume there's some kind of intriguing rhetorical strategy here I'm just not picking up on.

Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing by yummyfajitas on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:38PM (#12696950)
I'm curious what you find ludicrous about the argument. I claim the poor are predominantly no-income people and disproportionately violent. The violence includes all sorts of violence with no economic motive, e.g. intimate partner violence. The Census and BJS support this claim. Do you disagree?

The rhetorical strategy is very simple: pointing out that duaneb did not disagree with me on this. He just clumsily redefined his terms so as to avoid the facts I presented - e.g. redefining lazy to mean "desk job" rather than "no job" in a manner that renders his parent comment nonsensical.

Consider the possibility that I'm not selling duaneb anything; the target of my comments might instead be the moderate people persuaded by facts.