Re:New data challenges the cultural consensus on public housing
by yummyfajitas on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:38PM
(#12696950)
I'm curious what you find ludicrous about the argument. I claim the poor are predominantly no-income people and disproportionately violent. The violence includes all sorts of violence with no economic motive, e.g. intimate partner violence. The Census and BJS support this claim. Do you disagree?
The rhetorical strategy is very simple: pointing out that duaneb did not disagree with me on this. He just clumsily redefined his terms so as to avoid the facts I presented - e.g. redefining lazy to mean "desk job" rather than "no job" in a manner that renders his parent comment nonsensical.
Consider the possibility that I'm not selling duaneb anything; the target of my comments might instead be the moderate people persuaded by facts.
I'm glad we could come to agreement that the poor are predominantly high-risk no-income people who are also disproportionately violent
I've noticed you employ this assumptive-close rhetoric a lot, but always in such an outlandish fashion (in this case, for instance, coming within epsilon of saying "I'm glad we agree the poor are bad people") that I have to stop and wonder whether your point is that the argument you've been pursuing is ludicrous, and you're pushing it as an exercise in showing how ludicrous this kind of logic can be.
In a sales conversation, you lead a prospect gradually to the point where the assumptive close feels natural, and the counterparty is meant to feel like they've convinced themselves. But your assumptive closes are so clumsy and obvious it's like you're trying to hit people over the head with them.
You're not stupid, so I assume there's some kind of intriguing rhetorical strategy here I'm just not picking up on.