Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by clouddrover on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:48PM
(#12696994)
> most of the problems he lists have since been fixed by many implementations of the language
Which problems haven't been fixed?
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by qwertyuiop924 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:57PM
(#12697034)
None I can think of, but I've long since given up on absolute certainty.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by clouddrover on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @08:00PM
(#12697366)
Then what are you in agreement with in Kernighan's assessment of Pascal? His assessment may have made sense 35 years ago but is out of date today.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by pjmlp on Friday October 14, 2016 @06:01AM
(#12707070)
Even 35 years ago it didn't make much sense, because he deliberately ignored the Pascal dialects that didn't had those set of issues.
Also C outside UNIX was just a mix of K&R C dialects, each with its own set of quirks and as portable across compiler vendors, as those Pascal dialects.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by qwertyuiop924 on Friday October 14, 2016 @03:18PM
(#12710421)
C inside of unix, which is probably the world Brian was coming from, didn't have those problems. And he had a point about the lack of unification. As to ignoring the dialects lacking that set of issues, I don't see how so. He explicitly stated that various dialects had solved the problems he discussed, but noted that such solutions were non-portable.
So I still consider it a valid assessment of the language he assessed. But I also acknowledge that Pascal is no longer that language.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by qwertyuiop924 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @08:08PM
(#12697396)
...Which was the point I was trying to make. I am in agreement with Kernighan's assessment of the language he assessed. This is not the same language that Pascal is today.
This was probably confusing. I am sorry.
It is unsurprising, in light of this, that the person who submitted this to HN is pjmlp, a well-known fan of Wirth's languages, and a person who notably dislikes C. He's probably also a Unix Hater, although I never asked.
Not that any of this is bad, mind you (I was raised on C/UNIX, and even I'll indulge in some Unix-Hating from time to time (It's probably the Lisp that does it), and whether or not you like the Wirth family, you can't deny it's interesting), but it explains a lot about why this (exceptionally interesting, by the way) project was likely submitted to HN.