Seems to be a Windows IDE in Free Pascal that renders single self sufficient program images to use on the pi without any linux involved, similar to Arduino.
I would prefer it to be in c and on linux, but nonetheless, interesting.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by Avshalom on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:40AM
(#12693255)
Well the IDE, Lazarus, is cross platform so it looks like you would just need to put the ultibo source some where Lazarus knows about. Free Pascal/Lazarus are infamous for the ease of cross compiling (or they would be if any one paid attention to them).
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by qwertyuiop924 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @11:57AM
(#12693985)
Pascal is a neat language. I am generally in agreement with Kernighan's assessment of it (https://www.lysator.liu.se/c/bwk-on-pascal.html), but most of the problems he lists have since been fixed by many implementations of the language, leaving something quite usable, and a heck of a lot safer than C.
It is unsurprising, in light of this, that the person who submitted this to HN is pjmlp, a well-known fan of Wirth's languages, and a person who notably dislikes C. He's probably also a Unix Hater, although I never asked.
Not that any of this is bad, mind you (I was raised on C/UNIX, and even I'll indulge in some Unix-Hating from time to time (It's probably the Lisp that does it), and whether or not you like the Wirth family, you can't deny it's interesting), but it explains a lot about why this (exceptionally interesting, by the way) project was likely submitted to HN.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by pjmlp on Friday October 14, 2016 @06:01AM
(#12707070)
Even 35 years ago it didn't make much sense, because he deliberately ignored the Pascal dialects that didn't had those set of issues.
Also C outside UNIX was just a mix of K&R C dialects, each with its own set of quirks and as portable across compiler vendors, as those Pascal dialects.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by qwertyuiop924 on Friday October 14, 2016 @03:18PM
(#12710421)
C inside of unix, which is probably the world Brian was coming from, didn't have those problems. And he had a point about the lack of unification. As to ignoring the dialects lacking that set of issues, I don't see how so. He explicitly stated that various dialects had solved the problems he discussed, but noted that such solutions were non-portable.
So I still consider it a valid assessment of the language he assessed. But I also acknowledge that Pascal is no longer that language.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by qwertyuiop924 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @08:08PM
(#12697396)
...Which was the point I was trying to make. I am in agreement with Kernighan's assessment of the language he assessed. This is not the same language that Pascal is today.
Re:Ultibo – An embedded or bare metal development environmen...
by nanolith on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:23AM
(#12693076)
I think it's interesting. The fact that it's written in Pascal takes me back to my youth, when Pascal was still commonly taught as an entry-level language in schools.
It's probably not for everyone, and the license terms suit it best for a hobby projects (LGPL or a more permissive license would be better), but it's neat that it exists.
EDIT: I stand corrected. It is released under the LGPL. That is permissive enough for more use cases when static linking is required.
Seems to be a Windows IDE in Free Pascal that renders single self sufficient program images to use on the pi without any linux involved, similar to Arduino.
I would prefer it to be in c and on linux, but nonetheless, interesting.
- Who are you?
- What makes it different?
- How does it make it different?
- What is expected of me? (Hint: "Give it a try" is not a good answer.)
- Cannot scroll because of weird scroll-component in the middle.
- Fonts are way too big. Too much whitespace, low signal-to-noise ration.
It is unsurprising, in light of this, that the person who submitted this to HN is pjmlp, a well-known fan of Wirth's languages, and a person who notably dislikes C. He's probably also a Unix Hater, although I never asked.
Not that any of this is bad, mind you (I was raised on C/UNIX, and even I'll indulge in some Unix-Hating from time to time (It's probably the Lisp that does it), and whether or not you like the Wirth family, you can't deny it's interesting), but it explains a lot about why this (exceptionally interesting, by the way) project was likely submitted to HN.
Which problems haven't been fixed?
Also C outside UNIX was just a mix of K&R C dialects, each with its own set of quirks and as portable across compiler vendors, as those Pascal dialects.
So I still consider it a valid assessment of the language he assessed. But I also acknowledge that Pascal is no longer that language.
This was probably confusing. I am sorry.
It's probably not for everyone, and the license terms suit it best for a hobby projects (LGPL or a more permissive license would be better), but it's neat that it exists.
EDIT: I stand corrected. It is released under the LGPL. That is permissive enough for more use cases when static linking is required.
"What licence does Ultibo use? The GNU LGPL version 2.1, the same licence used by many other popular open source products."
http://www.eluaproject.net
I remember spending a great deal of time playing with the TurboPascal compiler, and the Pi is a nice, simple piece of hardware to build an OS for.
This sort of thing could be great fun.