News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by zerognowl on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:02AM (#12692871)
This is why I use 'browser isolation', which is a way to separate different types of surfing activity into different buckets. Currently the best way to do this in Firefox is to create multiple profiles, or in Chrome, you can simply add a different user/persona.

Having one profile, or even an entire dedicated browser just for Twitter/FB ensures the login is not spilled over into other sites. If you're surfing the web heavily, I would recommend spawning a new private window so cookies, and other artefacts are not bleeding into your session.

It sounds like common sense, but many people have cookies and login information persisting for years at a time in their browsing sessions. The Mozilla Firefox team are planning to introduce a feature which makes compartmented surfing sessions a lot more user-friendly by separating sessions into tabs. Currently, the 'profiles' feature of Firefox is not user friendly and requires a bit of tinkering with the filesystem.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by Bartweiss on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:55PM (#12695091)
At risk of being depressing, it's worth knowing that a dedicated profiler can reconcile accounts across all of the protections you've mentioned - not just as a targeted attack, but algorithmically.

There are a lot of fingerprinting tricks which transcend cookie restrictions and user profiles. The battery percent/value one will reconcile all accounts on one device (as will several other like fonts). If you log into one bucket on multiple devices, it becomes possible to traverse devices and reconcile one-device profiles via the shared profile. If I were truly paranoid, I would only trust "separation" if it involved a clean account on a clean device on a clean network.

None of which is to say that you shouldn't do this! I do lots of privacy things which aren't bulletproof, and I think other people should also. Fighting common tracking structures is still progress, and tools like bucketing and Privacy Badger are great ways to do this.

It's just also worth noting that dedicated profiling will break all but the most pathological defensive measures.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by drvdevd on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:26PM (#12696172)
What about virtualization? It seems to me that something like Qubes might not at present protect against this (I don't know what information is available to guest/isolated domains on that system), but could be made to? One can easily lie to a browser about battery status and fonts from the OS too, for example.

I guess my point is that it depends on what you view as pathological? I surmise that this is the kind of thing that needs an algorithmic countermeasure, such that systematic deception by user agents is no more difficult for the end user than browsing the web is currently.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by duaneb on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:06PM (#12696788)
It's very difficult to prevent side channel thumbprints—something as simple as traceroutes, wifi hotspots, caches (DNS, routing) can be uniquely identifiable. Add on top of this biometrics like how you type, how you move your mouse, etc, and it becomes very difficult to avoid concerted tracking efforts.

Of course, if you're not pissing off state actors, you're probably fine with qubes/tails.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by sliverstorm on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @08:14PM (#12697416)
if you're not pissing off state actors, you're probably fine

Thank you, this seems to be a point that is often ignored. Most of us don't need to hide our trail from a full wing of CIA analysts, just drive-by snooping and the like. (It of course doesn't help the Snowdens of the world)

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by derefr on Thursday October 13, 2016 @01:12AM (#12698605)
I usually prefer to think of the middle case: someone with a grudge against me, who would love to blackmail me if they could get the dirt, and who has money to hire some blackhats and buy some zero-days and set up spear-phishing—but who doesn't actually have any access to the things that states get by default by sending fancy letters with Important Signatures.

It's interesting to work through the case of an absurdly rich private actor, because it works out differently for diferent companies; for some, they can just get a "man on the inside" to leak out your data easily enough, while for others (e.g. Gmail) the employees themselves aren't trusted to access user data, and have been firewalled/ACLed away from it to prevent just such intrusions. State actors get pretty much the same "help" from every service (save for the rare Lavabits of the world) but corporate actors get a rather unpredictable response landscape.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by derefr on Thursday October 13, 2016 @01:07AM (#12698584)
Presuming you are being pursued by a state actor, isn't using a computer at a library or Internet cafe enough to thwart most of that? Especially if you're using asynchronous store-and-forward protocols like NNTP or Freenet, where you can be long-gone from wherever the computer you used was, before anyone else ever sees "your" activity.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by Bartweiss on Thursday October 13, 2016 @09:47AM (#12700717)
I remember at least one security expert commenting that if he ran an actual attack, his precautions would be "sitting in a computer lab using a stolen library card". Physical anonymity is by far the best cure for some of these things.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by drvdevd on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @07:46PM (#12697307)
Very interesting list, thank you. I will have to read up on this subject in greater depth.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by throwaway7767 on Friday October 14, 2016 @11:06AM (#12708535)
Qubes VMs cannot get the battery state. Assuming that the user didn't install custom fonts, the font list should be the same across all the installs.

I think Qubes closes most of the low hanging fruit in this space, but completely preventing fingerprinting is very hard and there are probably ways to leak identifying info.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by zerognowl on Thursday October 13, 2016 @06:31AM (#12699714)
Indeed, you can take this a step further and assign each bucket its own VPN, with JS turned off to minimize fingerprintability. You can even setup multiple virtual machines with multiple screen resolutions on each to further divide up your sessions, making your surfing modified beyond recognition. It might take a weekend or two to wrap your head around VMs and VPNs, but it's worth it.

Also, if you're paranoid about your VPN provider spying on you, you can install HTTP nowhere: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/http-nowhere/ to further compartmentalize the risk of spying. DNS, however is tricky to obfuscate, so I would recommend surfing under broad and generic domains, like TWITTER.com and places like REDDIT.com which often scrape and proxy the content from other sites so you don't need to visit those sites explicitly.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by tscs37 on Thursday October 13, 2016 @08:48AM (#12700354)
but is that in itself not another signature in a fingerprint?
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by zerognowl on Thursday October 13, 2016 @11:30AM (#12701364)
Not necessarily. The amount of bits needed to fingerprint somebody is substantially lowered doing this, and although you stand out by taking extra steps like this, it's substantially better than a large portion of the configurations you do see.

Of course if your threat model is such that nation states are targeting you, either passively, or actively, then TOR is fitting in most cases, but TOR can prove to be overkill in most cases.

For example, if I'm surfing a website which blocks TOR, I can use a JonDoFox[1] profile to visit a website with a VPN, and achieve better-than-most anonymity for my needs, albeit not as rigorous as what TOR provides, but at least my connection has rudimentary protection from passive eavesdropping.

Keep in mind, VPNs are a countermeasure only and do not provide perfect privacy, but you can lessen the information gathered using the techniques I outlined. Surf under generic domains, and block traffic downloaded en clair

[1] https://anonymous-proxy-servers.net/en/jondofox.html

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by tscs37 on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @08:24AM (#12733715)
The problem is that even if the number of bits on the fingerprint shrink, you're also lowering the selection size.

It's a tradeoff, you can overdo it and certainly end up less anonymous than before.

A bigger fingerprint might make it easier to identify you but if there are more fingerprints, there might also be more fingerprints that are exactly the same, thus being drowned by the mass.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by antocv on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @02:51PM (#12695524)
Indeed.

Another trick is to change or settle for one very common user-agent across all browsers, and to run them with differently sized windows.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by emodendroket on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:26PM (#12696170)
At this point you may as well just go full rms and use wget to download pages which you then read offline.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by andai on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:34PM (#12696937)
Would it be possible to make a browser plugin to do exactly that?
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by emodendroket on Thursday October 13, 2016 @08:17AM (#12700197)
Well why?
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by nitrogen on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:58PM (#12695990)
Be sure to use a common window size, though. If you pick a nice size with your mouse (as I always do), your window size is almost certainly unique when paired with just a few more bits of info.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by zerognowl on Thursday October 13, 2016 @11:31AM (#12701376)
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by brashrat on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:56PM (#12695970)
it found nothing for me and I don't do anything pathological
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by Bartweiss on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:24PM (#12696150)
This page didn't, because it only profiles third party cookies - that is, your browser explicitly admitting which sites you're logged into. Privacy Badger, Disconnect, or uBlock will all handle that, as will simply disabling the browser setting.

That was pretty much my point: this is a "nice" profile. One that targets unintentionally identifying image like browser window dimensions can easily track you despite all of those precautions.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by daleharvey on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:41AM (#12693268)
Its only in testing right now, but Firefox Nightly has "Containers" so you can exactly have different "buckets" for different types of browsing - https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Contextual_Identity_Projec...
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by mahyarm on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:10PM (#12694107)
What I really want is something like this and it opening containers automatically based on url sets.

So going to facebook would go to the facebook set automatically and isolate facebook. But I don't have to manually open the "facebook profile" to do the switch. Same with twitter, amazon, google*, youtube, apple, etc.

If you have multiple accounts, you can have the interface pop up a "choose your subcontainer" automatically with the new google container or whatever. All browsing in that container would then stay in that subcontainer until you close it.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by ethbro on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:02PM (#12694586)
After Firefox adds this, wouldn't that be a relatively simple plug-in? Just maintain a list of known info greedy URLs? (Note, not a tracker blocklist)
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by ufmace on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:25PM (#12696167)
Yeah, as long as it only activates that container based on typing in facebook or going to a bookmark, not just any random site hitting that URL. Which would then probably break following links to those sites - could you trigger it based on a normal navigation to that domain, but not based on some other site trying to fetch an image from it out of the blue?
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by Normal_gaussian on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:07PM (#12696050)
and deny other containers from embedding facebook urls?
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by mahyarm on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @07:01PM (#12697055)
If you want. Put it as a checkmark option?
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by nathancahill on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @02:17PM (#12695272)
Yes! I use and love containers.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by b101010 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @11:09AM (#12693541)
For anyone wanting to do this, the profile and no-remote command line options[1] may be useful if you want to create shortcuts to launch specific profiles

You might also want to consider using a different theme[2] in each profile to help avoid mixing them up if your running multiple instances simultaneously.

My initial use case for this was adding the lets encrypt staging certificate authority to the trusted root certificate authorities in a profile only used for testing.

[1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Command_Lin... [2] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/themes/

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by staticelf on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:49PM (#12695035)
I also use seperate browsers for some stuff, but these two addons is a must:

https://addons.mozilla.org/sv-SE/firefox/addon/self-destruct... together with https://addons.mozilla.org/sv-se/firefox/addon/i-dont-care-a...

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by whamlastxmas on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @11:17AM (#12693617)
Slightly easier way is to use the Disconnect/Privacy Badger extensions, along with uBlock Origin. It does a lot to prevent cookies from leaking across sites.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by dwiel on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:51PM (#12695044)
I use all 3 of those and a few others, yet it still detected quite a few sites I was logged in to.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by e_proxus on Thursday October 13, 2016 @08:33AM (#12700274)
If you're still worried, I'd take the time to learn and use uMatrix (https://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix) in addition to uBlock. For me, uMatrix has replaced Privacy Badger and other similar addons because they're no longer needed. It requires a bit more effort to maintain though.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by jlarocco on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:33PM (#12694899)
Yeah. I use those, and this site doesn't do anything AFAICT.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by vacri on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @07:48PM (#12697312)
> It sounds like common sense, but many people have cookies and login information persisting for years at a time in their browsing sessions.

If it requires quite a bit of domain knowlege (almost everything in security does), it's not 'common sense'.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by j_s on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:17PM (#12694755)
I use the http://qupzilla.com/ browser because each private window is a new session, no cookies are shared between windows.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by mark_l_watson on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:44AM (#12693286)
Great advice. I use Chrome for Google, twitter, and Facebook, and another browser for everything else. This isn't quite as good as your approach, but gives me some web platforms isolation.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by spacemanmatt on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:12AM (#12692980)
I was horrified to find I'm logged in to FB with my 'common' cookie jar. At least that explains the recently increased accuracy of its targeted ads.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by to3m on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:38AM (#12693238)
I only ever log in to Facebook in private browsing mode.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by tankenmate on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:32PM (#12696221)
I only ever log into Facebook via a VPN to a remote VPS using a private window on a browser I don't use for anything else. And also...

Chain OUTPUT (policy ACCEPT 6309 packets, 599K bytes)

pkts bytes target prot opt in out source destination

  330 19800 REJECT     all  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0            match-set block-facebook-ips dst reject-with icmp-port-unreachable
I have an ipset that matches FB networks.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by welanes on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:25PM (#12696535)
Yikes. Sounds easier just to not use Facebook.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by tankenmate on Thursday October 13, 2016 @05:06AM (#12699415)
There in lies the problem, all those Facebook widgets on various 3rd party websites are used to track you. If you block FB's network ranges then it gets much harder for them to do that.

In effect you are "using" Facebook whether you want to or not; this is the issue some people have with shadow FB profiles.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by sliverstorm on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @08:16PM (#12697429)
Careful, too strict and you'll start to be identifiable from your conspicuous lack of identifiable information ;)
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by spacemanmatt on Friday October 14, 2016 @12:34PM (#12709205)
I always use incognito mode but apparently I must have inadvertently logged in to a regular frame at some point. Horrified!
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by joosters on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:51PM (#12696689)
Shouldn't disabling 3rd party cookies also prevent this kind of attack? The request for the facebook/twitter favicon is being made from a non-FB/TW page and so the login cookie won't be sent.

This would depend upon how the browser implements its 3rd party cookie blocking. If it only blocks setting cookies, but still allows existing cookies to be sent, then there would be no protection.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by Ankaios on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:50PM (#12698065)
I've had a fantasy of not just using different browser profiles (effectively) for each site, but routing requests for each site through a different personally-run cloud-hosted proxy.

Someday maybe I'll get around to setting it up. Maybe.

Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by necessity on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:15PM (#12694727)
Or you can enable basic privacy settings on about:config, NoScript, etc. I get "No platform" both on my phone and Desktop (though I don't have any social networks, I created a Facebook account to test).
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by aquilaFiera on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:37PM (#12694350)
Firefox Nightly has container tabs available right now and they are fantastic! Only thing missing is a shortcut / better way to open a different type of container tab.
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by i2shar on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:31PM (#12696925)
Lately I've been using Opera Incognito with free builtin VPN for all general browsing and I highly recommend it. (I use Chrome to stay logged in to email).
Re:Show HN: Your Social Media Fingerprint (maybe NSFW) by givinguflac on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:05PM (#12694060)
This seems like a good plan. However I find it funny that one would use Chrome and be concerned about sites gathering information about you.