- https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
Sounds like this probably would have happened with or without the Post.
The Post provides them that.
https://wikileaks.org/dnc-emails/emailid/2699
This site has a copy with more readable formatting:
http://heavy.com/news/2016/07/wikileaks-emails-clinton-berni...
And that's just one example. Such horribleness is all over those systems. I had a hearing get moved 40 miles away -- apparently en-masse because of a computer system change -- with no notification to myself or my lawyer. I didn't even find out about that until we showed up. Sure, the US system is fantastic compared to other places in the world and justice during the middle ages. However, there's still a lot to it that's horrible.
EDIT: The takeaway from this article, my experience, and from many accounts of the justice system in the US, is that it is good on the large contexts of the world and history. However, it's still capable of cruel and arbitrary effects that run drastically counter to reality. Many of these effects come as myriad little "bites" or as if one is fighting a current. And the direction of these effects is strongly influenced by perceived socioeconomic status and race. This is still not up to the point of "good governance."
When you have problems with the "retail" side of government at any level, call your local councilman, alderman, or whatever. If they suck, call the police chief.
Isn't that the way it's supposed to be? It's an old concept: In the eyes of the law, people don't get special treatment depending on their social status.
So no, I'm not expressing disappointment that I'm not spoken to as a privileged person. I'm just wishing I was spoken to equally as a person.
Neither was the part where they expected "special treatment depending on their social status." You don't get to dismiss the author's suspicions as imaginary while elevating your own to fact.
As a result, there isn't really anyone who can tell even all the federal courts, much less the state ones, to all plug into a central electronic filing system. Indeed, even though the federal courts all use the PACER software, each court actually maintains it's own system.
[0] https://www.wired.com/2016/05/problem-feds-profiting-off-cou...
Congress can, in fact, do that for federal courts; as for state courts, its true that there is no one body that can, but Congress has been very successful in the past at getting fairly good national compliance with programs that are outside of its ability to mandate by setting rules and providing implementation and maintenance funds to states who choose to follow the rules; there's no reason why this couldn't work with court record systems.
No, you said there was no one who can do it -- more specifially, you said that, as a result of the organizational structure of the US government, "there isn't really anyone who can tell even all the federal courts, much less the state ones, to all plug into a central electronic filing system."
In point of fact, there is someone who can tell the federal courts to do that, and while they can't actually tell the state courts to, they have a lever that they've been quite adept at using at the past that would likely get at least most state courts to comply were they to choose to.
Now, you can shift to arguing that the entity who could act has a historic lack of will in this area, but that's a very different argument than the absence of an entity with capacity to act.
I think that's an accurate statement. There is no central administrative authority over the U.S. courts.[1] The chief judges of the courts are responsible for their administration, and the Administrative Office of the Courts serves a policymaking/support role. So there is no "CTO" that can impose a judiciary-wide IT policy like moving to a single electronic filing system. That's why every single court has a different website, runs a different PACER version, etc.
Sure, Congress can exercise its legislative powers to impose such a policy, but it can do lots of things that way.
[1] I don't know what authority Congress Constitutionally has over court administration. Apparently, before reforms in the 1930s, courts were administered through the executive branch.
https://free.law/ https://github.com/freelawproject/courtlistener https://www.courtlistener.com/
Disclaimer: While I have no affiliation with this project, I am friends and former roommates of the Free Law Project's Director.
This shows an important reason why court proceedings should be openly accessible at scale. Lawyers can spread legal DOS attacks out across jurisdictions, where individual judges would have a hard time discovering the pattern. Allowing citizens to do large scale pattern matching will uncover such things.